China says U.S. has ulterior motives and calls hacking allegations a ‘hullabaloo’
Chinese state media stepped up the war of words Thursday over allegations of sophisticated cyberattacks on US firms, branding the accusations a “commercial stunt” and accusing Washington of ulterior motives.
American Internet security firm Mandiant earlier this week said that a Chinese military cyberspy unit had been targeting US and other foreign firms and organisations with hacking attacks.
But an editorial in the state-run China Daily said: “One cannot help but ask the real purpose of such a hullabaloo.
“With the US economic recovery dragging its feet, it is reasonable to think that some in Washington may want to make China a scapegoat so that public attention is diverted away from the country’s economic woes.”
Defence ministry spokesman Geng Yansheng said the People’s Liberation Army had itself been the target of a “significant number” of cyberattacks.
“A considerable number” of them originated in the United States, judging from the IP addresses involved, he said, but added that he did not accuse the US government of being involved. He had earlier said Mandiant’s claims had “no factual basis”.
The media backlash came after the US government Wednesday vowed to aggressively combat a rise in the foreign theft of trade secrets.
A new strategy document released by the White House did not explicitly name China, but warned that foreign governments and firms had stepped up efforts to obtain such material, threatening US economic and national security.
In its report, Mandiant alleged the hacking group “APT1” — from the initials “Advanced Persistent Threat” — was part of the Chinese military’s Unit 61398 and had stolen hundreds of terabytes of data from at least 141 organisations across 20 industries.
Targeted companies included some involved with significant sections of the American domestic infrastructure.
Western analysts dismissed the Chinese denials as “meaningless”.
A strongly worded commentary by the official news agency Xinhua said the Mandiant document “reeks of a commercial stunt”.
“Next time, the CEO could simply say: ‘See the Chinese hackers? Hurry up, come and buy our cyber security services’,” it went on.
It said the US had a “matchless superiority and ability to stage cyberattacks across the globe”, and that the US military had “established a significant cyber force, including the 780th Military Intelligence Brigade, which is a regular military unit tasked with carrying out cyber missions”.
Washington, it added, had a “habit of accusing other nations based on phony evidence”.
“Facts will eventually prove that the cyberattacks accusations are groundless and will only tarnish the image and reputation of the company making them, as well as that of the United States,” it said.
An expert quoted in China’s state-run Global Times newspaper questioned US motives, saying Washington was exaggerating the cyber threat posed by China in order to garner support from other Asian countries.
“The US is raising the profile of the ‘invisible’ cyber threat as a new weapon in order to balance its losses in the Asia-Pacific pivot strategy,” said Hun Xudong, a professor with the PLA National Defence University.
“The US controls the world’s main servers. This has been a threat to China’s cyber security,” he added.
Western academics said they were unsurprised at the rhetoric used by Chinese officials in denying the hacking allegations.
James Lewis, a senior fellow at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, said: “It’s a standard Chinese diplomatic ploy to say ‘it isn’t us, and in any case, you do it, too’.
“So their denial and accusations are meaningless.”