FBI reportedly probes Olympus fee; shares tumble
TOKYO (Reuters) – The U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation is probing the massive advisory fee involved in Olympus Corp’s takeover of a British company, a media report said, in a deepening scandal that has wiped out more than half the company’s value.
The British CEO who says he was fired for questioning the $687 million payment to advisers in the $2.2 billion takeover of medical equipment maker Gyrus in 2008 has called on authorities in both Britain and Japan to also investigate the payments.
The endoscope and camera maker said last week it would commission its own independent review of past acquisitions, although the ousted CEO, Michael Woodford, said the company was playing for time. It already carried out a review in 2009 that concluded no management wrongdoing, documents he provided show.
Olympus is struggling to contain the crisis at the 92-year-old company following Woodford’s revelations. In its latest comments, it said on Monday that the replacement of its auditors in 2009 was not linked to the Gyrus acquisition.
The New York Times said that the FBI became the latest authority to decide to probe the Olympus scandal. It cited two people briefed on the case, although it said the exact focus of the investigation was not yet clear.
Woodford, 51, who spent three decades at Olympus, has identified the advisory firms involved in the takeover as New York-based AXES America LLC and AXAM Investments Ltd in the Cayman Islands.
Olympus acknowledges it made the payment and denies any wrongdoing. But it has not explained why it should have agreed to a fee that amounted to about a third of the value of the takeover when such fees normally come to about 1 percent.
At $687 million, the fee is the largest on record.
NO ILLEGAL, UNJUST CONDUCT
Documents provided by Woodford show that Olympus appointed a three-person external panel in May 2009 to look into the Gyrus takeover and three other deals. The panel found no problems with the way the acquisitions had been conducted.
“Please ask Messrs Kikukawa and Mori why they need another ‘independent’ third party committee investigation?” Woodford said in an email to Reuters, referring to Chairman Tsuyoshi Kikukawa and senior executive Hisashi Mori.
The 2009 report was issued before Olympus paid the bulk of its huge fee to AXES and AXAM, Woodford’s documents show.
Olympus said it was checking whether there was a third-party review conducted in 2009. In a statement on Monday, it denied Woodford’s assertion that it switched auditors from KPMG AZSA & Co to Ernst & Young in 2009 because of a disagreement on accounting for the Gyrus acquisition.
KPMG had advised Olympus against making part of the advisory payment for the Gyrus deal in preferred stock, Woodford says in a letter dated October 11 to the Olympus board. The preferred stock ballooned in value and made up the bulk of the advisory payment.
Olympus said it switched auditors because KPMG’s contract had come to an end, although Woodford’s documents suggested “substantial difference in views” on some aspects of the Gyrus acquisition.
Olympus shares closed down 10.7 percent at 1,099 yen each on Monday. They hit an intraday low of 1,012 yen, their weakest price since March 1998.
Traders attributed the selling to long-only investors bailing out of the stock following the New York Times report of an FBI probe and reaction to more brokerages suspending their ratings recommendation on the firm.
“Many players seem to expect it to fall to around 700-800 yen,” said a trader at a Japanese brokerage. At 700 yen, it will be at about 10 percent above its book value.
The Tokyo Stock Exchange said on Monday it is urging Olympus daily to disclose more information about the controversial payments. It will look carefully at any third-party probe on the case.
Last week, Olympus bowed to investor pressure and announced it was setting up an external panel of lawyers and accountants to probe its past M&A deals.
Harris Associates, a Chicago-based group which holds 2.5 percent of Olympus shares, said the move was a promising sign.
“We think it’s important that the panel members have no ties to Olympus, that they be given complete access to the company’s books and records, and that they work quickly to get answers to our many questions,” said Chief Investment Officer for International Equities David Herro.
Olympus has not given details on the identities of the advisers in the Gyrus takeover other than acknowledging that the fees were paid to two obscure firms, AXES and AXAM Investments.
Woodford, who is now in Britain, has sent dossiers to British and Japanese authorities on the Gyrus payments.
Olympus said it fired him after clashes over management style, while Woodford said he was dismissed for calling on senior executives to resign over the excessive payments.
(Reporting by Lisa Twaronite, James Topham; Writing by Isabel Reynolds; Editing by Edmund Klamann, Miyoung Kim and Neil Fullick)