Connect with us

Blackwater guards lose appeal in Iraqi shooting case



One of the highest-profile prosecutions stemming from the Iraq war period is to go ahead after the US supreme court refused to dismiss manslaughter and weapons charges against four employees of the private security company Blackwater Worldwide.

Supreme court justices declined to review a ruling by a US appeals court that reinstated the criminal charges against the guards for their involvement in the incident, in which 17 Iraqi civilians died and 20 were wounded.

The so-called Nisour Square massacre was the single bloodiest incident involving American private security contractors during the Iraq conflict. It outraged Iraqis, put severe strain on relations between Baghdad and Washington, and served as a watershed moment in the debate surrounding private fighters in foreign war zones.

The shooting took place on September 16, 2007 at the congested Nisour Square intersection, after a convoy of four armoured vehicles manned by Blackwater guards had departed from Baghdad’s heavily-fortified Green Zone.

In a span of 15 minutes, heavy gunfire erupted and by the time it was over, more than three dozen Iraqi civilians had been shot, at least 17 fatally. Among the dead was nine-year-old Ali Kinani, who was shot in the head as he rode in a car with his father, Mohammed Kinnani.


The guards maintain that they opened fire in self-defense after being shot at by insurgents.

Witnesses tell a different story – including Mohammed Kinnani, who later sued Blackwater – alleging that the Americans wantonly shot unarmed civilians and were never in any danger. A Blackwater guard who witnessed the shooting later described it as “murder in cold blood“.

Investigators with the US military and the FBI determined the guards used deadly force without justification. Iraqi prime minister Nouri al-Maliki described the shooting as a challenge to the nation’s sovereignty and threatened to bar the company from operating in the country. Former Blackwater officials claimed the company’s then president approved a $1m payment to Iraqi leaders to silence criticism of the killings.


The state department had ordered the guards – Paul Slough, Evan Liberty, Dustin Heard and Donald Ball – to explain to investigators what happened under the threat of losing their jobs. Bruce Bishop, the contractors’ attorney, claimed his clients’ constitutional right against self-incrimination was violated when these statements were used to charge the men.

On December 31, 2009, federal judge Ricardo Urbina agreed with guards’ claims and threw out the cases, citing “reckless violation of the defendants’ constitutional rights”. After the ruling, Blackwater reportedly paid the some of the victims’ families about $100,000 for each death and issued a statement that it was “pleased” with the outcome.

But in April last year a US federal appeals court reinstated the charges after months of closed-door testimony.


In appealing to the supreme court, the attorney for the guards, Bruce Bishop, argued that by using statements made under duress to charge the men, prosecutors had violated their constitutional right against self-incrimination.

“The issue is of national importance,” Bishop said. “The privilege against self-incrimination is a fundamental and universal value in Anglo-American justice.”

On Monday the supreme court rejected the application and left the appeal court’s ruling intact. But it ordered the judge in the case to conduct a more thorough review, and to separate information based on allegedly self-incriminating interviews with the guards from that which prosecutors had obtained independently.


Prosecutors have already dismissed charges against a fifth guard, Nicholas Slatten. A sixth, Jeremy Ridgeway, has pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and attempted manslaughter and agreed to co-operate with investigators.

Ridgeway, who was serving as a turret gunner for Blackwater on the day of the incident, said in sworn statements that the convoy “opened fire with automatic weapons and grenade launchers on unarmed civilians … killing at least fourteen people.” Ridgeway also said the convoy had not been authorized to leave the Green Zone and were ordered to return after they did.

“None of these victims was an insurgent, and many were shot while inside of civilian vehicles that were attempting to flee,” he added.


According to evidence in the criminal case, a number of guards in the convoy were “horrified” by what they saw and claimed two of the defendants – Liberty and Slough – were seen high-fiving one another after it was over.

Jeremy Scahill, national security correspondent for The Nation magazine, who interviewed witnesses and victims of the shooting, as well as US military officers who conducted the original investigation at Nisour Square, welcomed the supreme court decision. In an email to the Guardian, he wrote: “What is at the heart of this case is whether or not the US government can or will hold corporate killers accountable for their crimes. The supreme court decision keeps the possibility of justice open in this notorious case.

“It is a devastating statement on the lack of accountability for criminal contractors that the men who did the shooting have not been successfully prosecuted. This was not an isolated incident, unfortunately. I believe that [Blackwater founder] Erik Prince and other top – now former – Blackwater executives should be brought up on charges for all of the murder and mayhem their forces unleashed on the people of Iraq and Afghanistan.


“Short of shutting down the mercenary industry completely, that would be the strongest deterrent we would have to future massacres by US government-funded and supported mercenaries.”

After the shooting and other controversies, Blackwater changed its name to Xe Services and then to Academi.

According to former company officials, the payments to the Nisour Square families were not the only ones that Blackwater had made to quell discontent surrounding the shooting. A New York Times report claimed that in December 2007 – three months after the shooting – Blackwater’s former president, Gary Jackson, approved payments to Iraqi officials totalling $1m out of fear that the company would no longer be able to operate in Iraq.


At the time, American and Iraqi investigators had already concluded that the shootings were unjustified. The company dismissed the allegations as “baseless”.

© Guardian News and Media 2012

Report typos and corrections to: [email protected]. Send news tips to: [email protected].
Continue Reading


NYT columnist says one of Trump’s friends begged him to talk him out of launching war with Iran



On Monday, Thomas Friedman of The New York Times spoke to CNN's Anderson Cooper, following President Donald Trump's attacks on him for calling his behavior racist in a recent article. The president accused him of "kissing [his] a**" in an Oval Office phone call.

Speaking to Cooper, Friedman denied Trump's characterization of their discussion.

"The president tweeted about a private conversation we had and lobbed in a few insults," said Friedman. "Basically, my response, which I put out on Twitter is that I was encouraged by a friend of his to speak to him after the downing of the American drone, because I thought it was wise that we not retaliate, and I thought he was wise not to retaliate, and this friend of his wanted me to encourage him in that, because he was evidently agonizing a little over that not retaliating. And I did that. I began the conversation by saying that 'I disagree with you, Mr. President on many things, but I think you did the right thing on this.' We talked for about four minutes. We also talked about China and we left it at that."

Continue Reading


Trump is a ‘human opioid’ who feeds racism to his ‘white identity cult’: author



Democrats will lose the 2020 campaign if they treat it like a typical election and instead need to make a moral issue against President Donald Trump, author Tim Wise explained on MSNBC on Monday.

Wise is the author of the 2004 book White Like Me: Reflections on Race from a Privileged Son.

"As Democrats work on their strategy to counter President Trump ahead of the 2020 election. Anti-racism activist Tim Wise -- who helped to defeat David Duke in two campaigns in the 1990s -- provided this advice for Democrats," anchor Chris Matthews said.

He read excerpts of tweets from Wise.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump asked right-wing conspiracy theorist congressman to help him pick his next Director of National Intelligence



On Monday, Politico reported that President Donald Trump is consulting with Rep. Devin Nunes (R-CA) about who he should consider to replace Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats.

Nunes has led the Republican side of the House Intelligence Committee since 2015 and chaired the committee for four years, despite having no professional qualifications of any kind for that role. Since 2017, he has been known for his stunts and conspiracy theories intended to discredit the Russia investigation and throw suspicion on anyone who looks into Trump's conduct.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

Join Me. Try Raw Story Investigates for $1. Invest in Journalism. Escape Ads.