Quantcast
Connect with us

Creationist home school curriculum isn’t just inaccurate — it’s really, really dumb

Published

on

A popular curriculum used by home-schooled students has drawn criticism for inaccurate, misleading information and an over-reliance on rote memorization, but those aspects may not be the worst things about it.

A lot of the material that children are exposed to in the Accelerated Christian Education is just astonishingly stupid, according to a former Christian fundamentalist.

ADVERTISEMENT

Blogger Jonny Scarmanga shared some of the multiple-choice questions he found in some ACE packets used by British home-school students Monday on the blog, Leaving Fundamentalism.

In one question aimed at 9- or 10-year-old fourth-graders, students are given this example: “Children played happily in the water spout.” They are then asked to define a water spout from three examples: “a stream of water,” “two dry ducks” or “playground.”

Another example shows that “Elisabeth Howard sat and listened carefully.” Students are then challenged to identify whether Elisabeth Howard is “a kind of airplane” or “a missionary.”

Still another question asks 12- or 13-year-old seventh-graders to identify whether sports coaches, piano tuners or librarians “can touch the lives of their students.”

ADVERTISEMENT

If that sounds like a trick question, that’s because it is.

“The correct answer, for those puzzled, is piano tutors,” Scaramanga writes. “It’s not that ACE doesn’t believe that sports coaches or librarians can touch students’ lives. The point is that the exact sentence, ‘Piano tutors can touch the lives of their students,’ has previously appeared in (an ACE packet), and the student is expected to remember this. Verbatim regurgitation of previously seen material is the entire point of the ACE system.”

The ACE curriculum relies on thousands of these multiple-choice questions to imprint the materials in students’ memories.

ADVERTISEMENT

The curriculum designates which materials are intended for average students of particular age and grade levels, but ACE students work through the packets at their own speed — so some material could be presented to students who are older than what’s suggested.

For example, one question asks 14- or 15-year-old ninth graders to identify whether the Bible teaches that God or man is “the Creator of the universe and the center of all things.”

The ACE curriculum is accredited by the Middle States Associations on Elementary and Secondary Schools and by government-funded voucher programs in 11 states.

ADVERTISEMENT

In the past, the curriculum has drawn criticism and scorn for teaching that the existence of the Loch Ness monster disproves evolution and that humans coexisted with dinosaurs.

The materials also include a strong conservative political bias that suggests God’s own views are right-wing, while liberals are villainous, and students are taught that government programs should not be used to meet needs that can’t be filled by family members or churches.

But those biases and falsehoods pale in comparison to a stupefying curriculum that expects to engage 10-year-olds by asking them whether an envelope is “a letter holder” or “donkey supplies.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The curriculum has also drawn criticism for its exclusion of literature, but ACE lessons on the topic are hardly sophisticated.

One question asks 17- or 18-year-old 12th graders to identify the main characters in Macbeth from among these choices: “three weird sisters,” “Malcolm or Donalbain,” “Shakespeare and the groundlings,” or “Macbeth and Lady Macbeth.”

Another asks those same 12th graders to identify who Macbeth was probably written to honor — Macbeth, Shakespeare, James I or “God whose ancestors came from Scotland.”

“ACE says its curriculum is used in 192 countries and 6000 schools worldwide. This is happening nearer than you think,” Scaramanga said. “All this means that parents are more likely to choose this academically third-rate and theologically fourth-rate education for their children. This has got to stop.”

ADVERTISEMENT

[Image: Little girl home school via Shutterstock]


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Boris Johnson said he would rather be ‘dead in a ditch’ than delay Brexit — but just asked to extend deadline

Published

on

Prime Minister Boris Johnson is to write to Brussels seeking a Brexit deadline extension after MPs voted Saturday to demand he delay Britain's October 31 departure date.

In a phonecall with European Council President Donald Tusk after the vote, Johnson said he would send the letter mandated by MPs to seek more time, a EU source told AFP.

"The PM confirmed that the letter would be sent to Tusk today," the source said.

"Tusk will on that basis start consulting EU leaders on how to react. This may take a few days," he added.

Tusk said on Twitter that he was "waiting for the letter".

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Trump is ‘weakened on virtually every front’ as impeachment intensifies: Washington Post analysis

Published

on

President Donald Trump is in a "fragile state" and telegraphing weakness, according to a new analysis by Washington Post reporter Philip Rucker.

"President Trump, whose paramount concern long has been showing strength, has entered the most challenging stretch of his term, weakened on virtually every front and in danger of being forced from office as the impeachment inquiry intensifies," he wrote.

Continue Reading
 

2020 Election

Rep AOC helped Bernie Sanders turn out ‘the largest crowd drawn by any candidate’: report

Published

on

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) helped Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) turn out a huge crowd at a campaign rally in New York City.

Ocasio-Cortez, also known as AOC, officially endorsed the Vermont senator at the event.

"Bernie Sanders has a crowd of 25,872 this afternoon at his Queens rally, according to the security company handling the event, Contemporary Services Corp. That would make this event, his first since his heart attack 18 days ago, the largest crowd drawn by any candidate," Buzzfeed News correspondent Ruby Cramer reported.

Continue Reading
 
 
Help Raw Story Uncover Injustice. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1 and go ad-free.
close-image