Quantcast
Connect with us

Federal appeals court upholds Univ. of Texas’ affirmative action plan

Published

on

By Jonathan Stempel and Jon Herskovitz

(Reuters) – A federal appeals court upheld the use of race by University of Texas at Austin in undergraduate admissions, a victory for affirmative action proponents, one year after the U.S. Supreme Court ordered closer scrutiny of the school’s practices.

ADVERTISEMENT

By a 2-1 vote, a panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Tuesday said the state’s flagship university had justified its limited use of race to achieve diversity, given a lack of workable alternatives.

A contrary ruling “would hobble the richness of the educational experience,” Judge Patrick Higginbotham wrote for the majority. “University education is more the shaping of lives than the filling of heads with facts.”

Opponents pledged to appeal, which could give the Supreme Court a chance to again review the case in its next term.

In June 2013, the Supreme Court did not directly rule on the program’s constitutionality but ordered the 5th Circuit, which sits in New Orleans, to scrutinize it more closely.

ADVERTISEMENT

Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for a 7-1 majority that courts must “verify that it is necessary for a university to use race to achieve the educational benefits of diversity.” UT Austin admits most freshmen through a program that guarantees admission to students in roughly the top 10 percent of their high school classes. It uses other “holistic” factors, including race, to admit the remainder.

While the program has resulted in significant racial and ethnic diversity, the percentages of black and Hispanic students remain lower than in Texas’ overall population.

EXACTING REVIEW

ADVERTISEMENT

Higginbotham said the holistic review met the exacting scrutiny required by the Supreme Court, and was nearly indistinguishable from a University of Michigan Law School program that the Supreme Court narrowly upheld in 2003.

“A variety of perspectives, that is differences in life experiences, is a distinct and valued element of diversity,” Higginbotham wrote.

Judge Emilio Garza dissented, saying the university failed to show its program was narrowly tailored and “has not defined its diversity goal in any meaningful way.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Tuesday’s decision came three months after the Supreme Court upheld a voter-approved Michigan law banning racial preferences in admissions to state colleges.

The Texas case was brought by Abigail Fisher, who said UT Austin denied her admission in favor of lesser-qualified minorities.

She later graduated from Louisiana State University but, she said, stayed in the case to help others in similar positions.

ADVERTISEMENT

Bert Rein, a lawyer for Fisher, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

A group led by Edward Blum, a driving force behind the opposition to the university’s program, released a statement in which Fisher expressed disappointment. Blum, a Maine resident, leads the Project on Fair Representation, whose website says it devotes “all of its efforts to influencing jurisprudence, public policy, and public attitudes regarding race and ethnicity.”

“I remain committed to continuing this lawsuit even if it means we appeal to the Supreme Court once again,” Fisher said in the statement.

ADVERTISEMENT

University President Bill Powers welcomed the decision, saying it encourages the exchange of ideas and thoughts “when students who are diverse in all regards come together in the classroom, at campus events and in all aspects of campus life.”

The case is Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin et al, 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 09-50822.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York, Jon Herskovitz in Austin, Texas, Joan Biskupic in Washington, D.C. and Brendan O’Brien in Milwaukee; Editing by Dan Grebler and Steve Orlofsky)

ADVERTISEMENT

[Image: “African American Male College Student Sitting At Desk,” via Shutterstock]

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. Like you, we here at Raw Story believe in the power of progressive journalism — and we’re investing in investigative reporting as other publications give it the ax. Raw Story readers power David Cay Johnston’s DCReport, which we've expanded to keep watch in Washington. We’ve exposed billionaire tax evasion and uncovered White House efforts to poison our water. We’ve revealed financial scams that prey on veterans, and legal efforts to harm workers exploited by abusive bosses. We’ve launched a weekly podcast, “We’ve Got Issues,” focused on issues, not tweets. And unlike other news outlets, we’ve decided to make our original content free. But we need your support to do what we do.

Raw Story is independent. You won’t find mainstream media bias here. We’re not part of a conglomerate, or a project of venture capital bros. From unflinching coverage of racism, to revealing efforts to erode our rights, Raw Story will continue to expose hypocrisy and harm. Unhinged from billionaires and corporate overlords, we fight to ensure no one is forgotten.

We need your support to keep producing quality journalism and deepen our investigative reporting. Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Invest with us in the future. Make a one-time contribution to Raw Story Investigates, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click to donate by check.

Enjoy this piece?

… then let us make a small request. Like you, we here at Raw Story believe in the power of progressive journalism — and we’re investing in investigative reporting as other publications give it the ax. Raw Story readers power David Cay Johnston’s DCReport, which we've expanded to keep watch in Washington. We’ve exposed billionaire tax evasion and uncovered White House efforts to poison our water. We’ve revealed financial scams that prey on veterans, and efforts to harm workers exploited by abusive bosses. We’ve launched a weekly podcast, “We’ve Got Issues,” focused on issues, not tweets. Unlike other news sites, we’ve decided to make our original content free. But we need your support to do what we do.

Raw Story is independent. You won’t find mainstream media bias here. We’re not part of a conglomerate, or a project of venture capital bros. From unflinching coverage of racism, to revealing efforts to erode our rights, Raw Story will continue to expose hypocrisy and harm. Unhinged from corporate overlords, we fight to ensure no one is forgotten.

We need your support to keep producing quality journalism and deepen our investigative reporting. Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Invest with us in the future. Make a one-time contribution to Raw Story Investigates, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you.



Report typos and corrections to: [email protected]. Send news tips to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Texas governor busted sending racist call-to-arms a day before El Paso attack: ‘take matters into our own hands’

Published

on

On Thursday, Gov. Greg Abbott (R-TX) tweeted out a message of unity and promised to work to reduce violence in his state, in the wake of the shooting in El Paso that left 22 dead and dozens more injured:

Today we had hearings responding to the tragic shooting in El Paso.

We focused on community healing, combating domestic terrorism, reducing hateful ideologies, & keeping guns out of hands of deranged killers while respecting 2nd Amendment rights.

We’ll keep TX safe.#txlege pic.twitter.com/ymct4aiSgK

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Facebook bans far-right website from pro-Trump advertising after they try to skirt transparency rules

Published

on

On Thursday, NBC News reported that Facebook has banned the Epoch Times from placing political advertisements, after the right-wing website tried to conceal its multimillion-dollar dark money streams and get around the social network's political advertising transparency rules in its propaganda supporting President Donald Trump.

The Epoch Times had tried to skirt rules by running ads under puppet names like "Honest Paper" and "Pure American Journalism," confusing users about who was really behind the ads.

Continue Reading
 

Facebook

Former Overstock CEO tells Fox News the Feds wanted him to sleep with Russian spy Maria Butina

Published

on

Longtime Overstock CEO Patrick Byrne resigned on Thursday after issuing a bizarre press release that caused the company's stock to tank.

Byrne then went on Fox News to claim that federal officials urged him to have a romantic relationship with Russian spy Maria Butina.

He claimed that the government told him they never asked citizens to engage in romantic relationships, but it was "such a national security risk" that the government asked Byrne, then in his fifties, to sleep with Butina, who was at the time in her twenties and half his age.

Continue Reading
 
 

Thank you for whitelisting Raw Story!

As a special thank you, from now until August 31st, we're offering you a discounted rate of $5.99/month to subscribe and get ad-free access. We're honored to have you as a reader. Thank you. :) —Elias, Membership Coordinator
LEARN MORE
close-link
close-image