The son of U.S. Senator Jeff Flake and his wife pleaded not guilty on Thursday to multiple animal cruelty charges after 21 dogs died while the couple were caretakers at a boarding kennel that overheated in suburban Phoenix, court officials said.
Austin Flake is married to Logan Flake, daughter of the Green Acre kennel’s owners, who were on a trip to Florida and had left the couple, both aged 21, in charge of the facility when the incident happened in June.
The pair entered their pleas in the high profile case at Maricopa County Superior Court, where they each face 21 felony and seven misdemeanor counts after being indicted by a state grand jury last month.
“Austin and Logan Flake have declared their innocence,” the Flakes’ attorney Dennis Wilenchik said in a statement. “This was a tragic and unforeseen accident, nothing more.”
Attorney John Schill, who represents the dead dogs’ owners in a civil lawsuit against the Flakes and the owners of the kennel, disagreed.
“I do not see this as an accident and neither did the grand jury,” Schill said. “This was a crime … and there is no way of getting around that.”
Sheriff’s department investigators say the canines likely died from suffocation and heat exhaustion after being confined in a small room. The authorities were told the air-conditioning was knocked out, possibly by a dog chewing through an electrical cord, but the investigators could not confirm that.
The civil lawsuit against the owners and caretakers alleges the dogs were kept in cramped quarters and faced “neglect, mistreatment, physical injury and psychological abuse.”
The lawsuit includes the 21 dogs that died in the incident, and two others that survived.
The owners are also accused of lying to several people about the death of their pets, including some who were initially told that their dogs had run away.
Green Acre’s owners, Jesse Todd Hughes and Maleisia Hughes, separately pleaded not guilty in October to 22 felony charges and seven misdemeanor counts of cruelty to animals, as well as one count of fraud each.
The felony charges carry penalties of up to 10 years in prison, said Jerry Cobb, spokesman for the county attorney’s office, although he said most defendants receive probation in animal cruelty cases.
(Reporting by David Schwartz; Editing by Daniel Wallis and Sandra Maler)
‘Russia is delighted’: Maddow says the elephant in the room is ‘rearing up and stomping its feet’
The host of "The Rachel Maddow Show" on MSNBC broke down how all of President Donald Trump's decisions in the Ukraine scandal primarily benefited Russia.
"We are in the middle of this impeachment now and it is still unfolding and there is still more to learn and tomorrow is going to be — tomorrow should be a big deal," Maddow noted. "Even just the news tonight is a big deal."
"But even after one day of public hearings so far, the elephant in the room here feels like it’s rearing up and stomping its feet, because who benefits with all these things Trump has done?" Maddow asked. "With all of them. With all this stuff in the middle of the impeachment, but all the other stuff he’s doing simultaneously."
Trump begs Louisiana for a ‘big win’ after his last-minute rally in Kentucky backfired
At his last-ditch rally in Louisiana to help the struggling gubernatorial candidacy of GOP businessman Eddie Rispone, President Donald Trump boasted — incorrectly — that his rally in Kentucky narrowed the gap for Gov. Matt Bevin, who lost the race, by 19 points. He then begged voters to give Rispone a "big win."
"We elected everybody," said Trump. "The governor got brought up, in a few short days, 19 points. I went, we made a speech, the whole ticket was there, everybody won big. Governor's a really good guy. But 19 points is a big thing, and he lost by just a few thousand votes. And the headlines next day, Trump took a loss — I lifted him up a lot. But Trump took a loss. So you gotta give me a big win, please, okay? Okay?"
Republicans are treating voters like ‘children’ with their defense of Trump: Ex-presidential adviser
On Thursday's edition of CNN's "Anderson Cooper 360," former presidential adviser David Gergen laid into Republican lawmakers for claiming that the impeachment probe is only based on "hearsay."
"The Republicans are treating us like idiots," said Gergen. "They just — they say you're only bringing forth hearsay. You don't have any firsthand information. We know there are three people who know exactly what happened. One is named [Rudy] Giuliani. One is chief of staff [Mick] Mulvaney and the third is [John] Bolton. And what's happened here? They all three have been called. The president said no, you must not talk. So the Republicans then come up and say, well, you only have hearsay."