Nobel winner tells US to drop books — not bombs — on Islamic State jihadists
The US-led coalition of countries involved in airstrikes against Islamic State will never bomb the jihadist group out of existence, a Nobel peace prize winner warned Friday.
Shirin Ebadi was one of Iran’s first female judges. She was demoted after the 1979 Islamic revolution and went on to become the country’s most prominent rights campaigner. She won the Nobel price in 2003 and was forced into exile in 2009.
After spending most of her adult life coping with and combating the impact a fundamentalist interpretation of Islam has had on herself, her family and her homeland, she is convinced that there is no military remedy to a problem that appears to intensify with every passing year.
In an interview with AFP, Ebadi said the experience of Afghanistan demonstrated that the US-led campaign aimed at ousting IS from the areas of Iraq and Syria it now controls would not solve anything.
“Look at all the years and all the money that have been put into fighting the Taliban,” the 67-year-old said. “Have we eradicated them? Unfortunately not.
“ISIS is like a branch of the Taliban. It is not only a terrorist group, it is also an ideology and, like any ideology, you have to fight it at its roots. When you kill the roots it will not expand.
“For me those roots are two things — illiteracy and a lack of social justice.
“Instead of throwing bombs at them, we should be throwing books at them and building schools: then you will see that fundamentalism will be eliminated.”
– Meddling and discrimination –
Ebadi, in Rome for a conference of Nobel winners, also added her name to those who argue that the West must accept some responsiblity for a problem it is now confronting on multiple fronts: Iran’s alleged development of nuclear weapons, IS, Boko Haram in Nigeria, chaos in Libya and terror attacks on the streets of western cities.
A history of meddling in the Middle East, the propping up of corrupt dictatorships and the mistreatment and discrimination faced by Muslims in Europe and North America are all part of a resentment-breeding cocktail, she argues.
“You see today that even many European people have joined this fundamentalism,” she said. “What does that tell us? I think it says something about how many second-generation Muslims feel humiliated and discriminated against.”
That same point was made forcibly by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan when Pope Francis visited Ankara earlier this month.
– Homecoming? –
While her office is in London, Ebadi pays her taxes in the United States, where she has permanent residency. But ask her where she now lives and she laughs: “In airports, because that is where I spend ten months of the year. London is the place I wash my clothes.”
For the forseeable future, she is resigned to a schedule that would make many a younger woman wilt, to raise awareness of a human rights situation in Iran which she says has not improved since the Twitter-friendly, supposed moderniser Hassan Rouhani was elected president last year.
“Many people thought the situation would get better with his election but unfortunately that has not happened,” Ebadi said. “In some cases, such as the number of executions, they have got worse.”
According to Ebadi, there is a simple explanation: “All the power remains with the supreme leader Ayatollah (Ali) Khamenei.
“The problem with Rouhani was he made promises he really did not have the authority to implement.”
Ebadi’s husband and sister have both been temporarily imprisoned during her time in exile and receive regular anonymous threats against her life.
All her properties, including a rights centre funded by her Nobel award, were confiscated after she left Iran, and have since been auctioned off. Even her Nobel medal was taken by the Revolutionary Guards, although it has since been returned thanks to pressure from Norway.
While she cannot contemplate a return home now, she says she is sustained by a belief that will one day be possible.
“It is not possible for me to continue my activities outside of Iran (while living) inside of Iran. So I prefer to be out, where I can be more useful for my country.
“Over 80 percent of the population in Iran are unhappy with the government and the way things are, so certainly change will come. I just cannot predict when.”