Quantcast
Connect with us

Alabama on a collision course with the Supreme Court over gay marriage

Published

on

Alabama could be on the edge of a constitutional crisis because of tensions over same-sex marriage that have pitted the state’s chief justice against the supreme court in a battle over state and federal law.

Last week, a federal judge ruled the state’s ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional, just as her colleagues across the US have been doing over the past two years. Alabama officials are nonetheless putting up a fight, even though advocates for marriage equality are optimistic that the supreme court will this year rule against all state bans.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Alabama has so far been more resistant to complying with the judge’s order and opinion than almost any other state,” said Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond.

Related: Legal same sex marriage is coming to Alabama – it’s just a question of when | Steven W Thrasher

US district court judge Callie Granade struck down Alabama’s ban on Friday of last week . On Tuesday, she ruled against the ban again in a separate case, citing her previous ruling. Both decisions are temporarily on hold, though, so no same-sex marriages have happened in the state.

Granade, who was appointed by President George W Bush, said the ban was unconstitutional, echoing rulings made by judges at state, district and appellate level in the past two years. As several states have done before, Alabama appealed.

Alabama supreme court chief justice Roy Moore sent a letter to the state’s governor, saying the US constitution does not give the federal government the power to regulate Alabama law. He also said state judges should not issue licenses for same-sex marriages, though he did not legally prohibit them from doing so.

ADVERTISEMENT

This led Granade to clarify in an order on Wednesday that state judges would have to allow same-sex marriages if the stays on her rulings were lifted. The Alabama Probate Judges Association said it would follow her judgement.

“The letter was extremely unusual and is based on very shaky legal grounds at best,” said Sonja West, associate law professor at the University of Georgia, about Moore’s words.

The supremacy clause of the US constitution says federal law takes precedence over state law. The most notable instances of states refusing to abide by such federal directives have primarily concerned racial issues.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rulings for both Alabama cases are on hold until 9 February and the state has filed a request for an appeal in the 11th US circuit court. If its appeal is granted, Granade’s ruling will be stayed until the supreme court makes a ruling on same-sex marriage. That is due by the end of June. If the state’s appeal is denied, same-sex marriages will begin in Alabama, which will be the 37th state to legalize such nuptials.

The situation in Alabama is almost identical to what happened in Florida, where same-sex marriage became legal earlier this month. Florida officials fought rulings striking down the state’s ban, including one that applied to a specific county. This led to confusion across the state in county clerk offices, where marriage licenses are issued.

ADVERTISEMENT

Eventually, the 11th circuit and the supreme court refused to grant stays on a district judge’s ruling against the state’s ban.

“There’s some real tension in the air between the federal judge’s ruling and state compliance,” said Tobias. “We’ll see what happens.”

The plaintiffs in the first Alabama case, Cari Searcy and Kimberly McKeand, married legally in California. They brought the challenge because Searcy is not allowed under Alabama state law to adopt McKeand’s biological son. A state and appeals court ruled against the couple before Granade ruled in their favor.

ADVERTISEMENT

The plaintiffs in the second case, James Strawser and John Humphrey, are seeking the ability to get a marriage license in Alabama. They have not been married in another state.

The supreme court said earlier this month that it will take up the issue in its current session.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media 2015


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

‘Light ’em up’: Police open fire on people filming them from their front porch

Published

on

Video reportedly taken from the Wittier neighborhood of Minneapolis on Saturday shows authorities shooting projectiles upon people filming them from a front porch.

On Friday, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey imposed a curfew on the city, but his emergency order did not apply to citizens' homes or front porches.

Yet a video posted on Twitter shows a Minnesota National Guard humvee rolling down residential streets, followed by a group of police.

"Look at this, they just keep coming," a woman is heard saying as the camera shows the police.

"Go inside. Get inside," the police shouted.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

‘They just fired on us’: Horrifying videos of cops ‘using journalists for target practice’ in Minneapolis

Published

on

Journalists covering the protests in Minneapolis reported on being targeted by police on Saturday.

Multiple reports -- including live coverage on CNN -- showed police firing rubber bullets at journalists.

It’s open season on the media for the cops in Minneapolis. Evil. https://t.co/ZR3Nnf9ofH

— Nick Stellini (@StelliniTweets) May 31, 2020

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Scientists warn of ‘superspreaders’ as Americans flock back to restaurants, salons and churches

Published

on

SAN DIEGO — Churches. Hair salons. Restaurants. Malls. What do they all have in common?They’ve all been cleared to reopen in San Diego County amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic — and by and large, they all require people to congregate inside, potentially with strangers.This comes as an increasingly vocal group of scientists has sounded the alarm about the danger of indoor gatherings due to the potential for airborne transmission of the disease by “superspreaders.”This week Kimberly Prather of UC San Diego’s Scripps Institution of Oceanography penned an urgently worded perspective paper in t... (more…)

Continue Reading
 
 
You need honest news coverage. Help us deliver it. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free.
close-image