Quantcast
Connect with us

American Sniper makes Tarantino’s over-the-top movie our sad reality

Published

on

americansniper-ss

I’m glad I’m not the only one who noticed this about American Sniper, which is breaking box office records as wingnut America wallows in their violent fantasies.

Rogen later clarified that he liked the movie, no doubt because of the fussing and whining directed at him. For those who haven’t seen Inglourious Basterds—and if you haven’t, you are missing out, because it may be Tarantino’s greatest film—he’s referring to a movie within the movie that has a plot that is eerily reminiscent of American Sniper.

ADVERTISEMENT

American Sniper is about Chris Kyle, who has been deemed a hero because he’s really efficient at killing, claiming 255 kills of other human beings, 160 of which the Department of Defense has confirmed. This movie is about how being so great at killing makes him a hero.

Stolz der Nation (The Nation’s Pride) is about Fredrick Zoller, who is deemed by the Nazi government a hero because he’s really efficient at killing, claiming 250 kills, mostly of American and British soldiers on the Western front. This movie is about how being so great at killing makes him a hero. Unlike Chris Kyle, however, Fredrick Zoller is a fictional character. He is, however, loosely based on Matthias Hetzenauer, an Austrian sniper whose kill count dwarfs Kyle’s at a whopping 345 kills, mostly of Russian soldiers, all before his 21st birthday. Hetzenauer was awarded the Iron Cross for his killing spree, deemed heroic by his nation, just as Kyle’s is deemed heroic by ours.

Unlike American Sniper, you can watch the entirety of Stolz der Nation online, if you wish. It’s only about 6 minutes long, making it a lot easier to take than American Sniper

ADVERTISEMENT

Many people are very angry at Seth Rogen for noticing that there’s a real movie out now that is nearly identical to a fictional movie within a Tarantino movie that came out more than 5 years before American Sniper. Which is odd, because Rogen’s statement was bland in the extreme. He just noted the obvious, that American Sniper is nearly identical. He did not suggest, for instance, that Tarantino now has a reason to sue Clint Eastwood for plagiarism, even though that would be entertaining as hell. He did not propose, as I might, that theaters show Stolz der Nation prior to American Sniper, without context, and record the largely conservative audiences as they react to a short film about sniping without knowing that it’s fake Nazi propaganda. He just pointed out they are the same, which is like pointing out that the sky is blue and cats are furry.

But conservatives are such babies in our modern era that they feel entitled to denounce you for stating the obvious. Country musician Craig Morgan complained that Rogen’s tweet was “inaccurate and insensitive”, even though he did not explain how it was inaccurate nor did he explain why the sensitivities of American conservatives need special protection from stating the obvious. Kid Rock, furious at even a whiff of a suggestion that perhaps there’s untoward urges underlining the popularity of this movie, said he hopes Rogen “catches a fist in the face soon”. That’ll show those people who are worried that conservatives just love thoughtless violence! The Daily Caller denounced Rogen’s tweet as “offensive” without detailing exactly what they feel Rogen got wrong. Breitbart, unwilling to explain how American Sniper is different from Stolz der Nation, called Rogen “grossly overweight” and said he wasn’t “familiar with the grueling regimen Cooper endured. It is worth pointing out that Rogen is equally unfamiliar with sitting in a tower sniping Allied forces. If Rogen’s unfamiliarity with something is proof that it is awesome, then I feel that Breitbart should really be consistent about this.

It’s just really interesting how zero conservatives I’ve seen can really explain why they think there’s this big difference. I mean, if you believe it, you should be able to explain it. It’s not necessarily self-evident. The point of the short film in Tarantino’s movie wasn’t just “Nazis bad”. He was actually calling into question the way that films that celebrate war as inherently glorious and heroic encourage, no duh, nations to go to war. The fact that it’s hard to tell fascist propaganda from American nationalist propaganda shouldn’t offend you. It should concern you. If we are going to say we’re better than that, we should actually start fucking acting like it, I’d say. 

With that, I’d like to offer another interesting parallel. Here is David French’s review of American Sniper for the National Review:

ADVERTISEMENT

[Th]he movie gives America something it’s lacked since the start of the war — a war hero on a truly national, cultural scale. Yes, we’ve learned the stories of Marcus Luttrell and others who’ve achieved great and heroic things, but with the success of this movie, Chris Kyle has entered the pantheon of American warriors — along with Alvin C. York and Audie Murphy — giving a new generation of young boys a warrior-hero to look up to, to emulate. After all, our kids’ heroes can’t be — must not be — exclusively quarterbacks, rappers, or point guards.

Feel free to explore the racial implications of his concerns about kids looking up to basketball players and rappers in comments. I, in the meantime, will quote the character Fredrick Zoller from Inglourious Basterds:

 This is a German night, a German event, a German celebration. This night is for you, me, the German military, the High Command, their family and friends. The only people who should be allowed in the room are the people who will be moved by the exploits on the screen.

 

Report typos and corrections to [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Pandagon

Ch-ch-changes…..

Published

on

After many years and many server changes and finally landing here at Raw Story, which has taken very good care of us, it's time to say goodbye to Pandagon. I've been blogging under this banner for ten years, after Jesse Taylor asked me to join. He, in turn, had been running this joint since he was in college. A lot has changed since then. I became a journalist, moved from Austin to New York and learned to play Dungeons & Dragons. Jesse became a lawyer and, just this past weekend, a married man.

Continue Reading

Pandagon

Carly Fiorina defends her lie with a whole bunch of lies

Published

on

I do like it when Republican candidates sport a resume full of corporate executive work, because it really shows the public how many fools and idiots coast into that position not on merit but on their bullshitting abilities. Donald Trump, Herman Cain, and now we have Carly Fiorina, who just can't understand why her perceived underlings (voters, journalists) won't scurry away, pretending to accept her bullshit like former employees of hers had to do, lest they lost their jobs.

And so it goes that Fiorina, who could make this entire Planned Parenthood controversy go away by saying something like, "I may have misremembered the video, but I still think abortion is wrong," instead is doubling and tripling down. And every time she does, she lies more and more. She was on Meet the Press and, so enamored of the idea that she is perfect and could never do anything wrong, just went to town with the defensive posturing.

Continue Reading
 

Pandagon

Marco Rubio has an astoundingly low opinion of women’s intelligence

Published

on

At RH Reality Check, I covered this story that I wish was getting more press, about how Marco Rubio goes back and forth between suggesting that women who get abortions are greedy monsters who get pregnant for cash:

I just think you’ve created an industry now … a situation where very much, you’ve created an incentive for people not just to look forward to having more abortions, but being able to sell that fetal tissue for purposes—these centers—for purposes of making a profit off it, as you’ve seen in some of these Planned Parenthood affiliates.

Continue Reading
 
 

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

I need your help.

Investigating Trump's henchmen is a full time job, and I'm trying to bring in new team members to do more exclusive reports. We have more stories coming you'll love. Join me and help restore the power of hard-hitting progressive journalism.

TAKE A LOOK
close-link

Investigating Trump is a full-time job, and I want to add new team members to do more exclusive reports. We have stories coming you'll love. Join me and go ad-free, while restoring the power of hard-hitting progressive journalism.

TAKE A LOOK
close-link