Attorney Lisa Giovinazzo warned Fox News on Wednesday that allowing one medically necessary sex reassignment for an inmate in California was a “slippery slope” and soon the U.S. would have to start building women’s prisons to hold all of the transgender inmates who received surgeries.
During a Fox & Friends segment titled “Taxed To The Max,” host Steve Doocy wanted to know if it was fair that taxpayers had to pay for the gender reassignment of a California inmate, Shiloh Quine, who doctors have said would kill herself without the surgery.
“Does a sex change constitute medical care?” Doocy asked.
Giovinazzo, who specializes in divorce law, insisted that the reassignment was not medically necessary, even though the corrections department has said that “every medical doctor and mental health clinician who has reviewed this case, including two independent mental health experts, determined that this surgery is medically necessary for Quine.”
“This is a person that’s been incarcerated for 15 years, 20 years already,” Giovinazzo argued. “They have maintained this person and now all of the sudden in the last several years, they’ve decided that this person needs to have a transgender reassignment surgery. It’s ridiculous.”
“If we allow this this to happen, it’s a slippery slope,” she continued. “It will happen in every single prison in the country. And then what do we do? Do we create more women’s prisons to accommodate for reassignment?”
According to Doocy, the U.S. Constitution only required states to provide enough medical care to inmates “to keep them alive.”
“This person would not die without this particular gender reassignment,” he insisted.
“The doctors are saying this woman will kill herself if she doesn’t get the surgery,” attorney Rebecca Rose Woodland pointed out. “She has a medical disorder. It is not a desire for her.”
“Medically necessary? What are we really doing to this person?” Giovinazzo interrupted. “They’re getting one surgery, they’re getting their genitalia changed. They’re not getting breast augmentation, chin implants.”
“But you’re not a doctor,” Woodland replied. “She’s actually been under female hormone therapy for years.”
Watch the video below from Fox News’ Fox & Friends, broadcast Aug. 12, 2015.
‘It’s a disgrace’: Conservative torches Trump and the GOP — saying they’ve betrayed voters
In 2012, Stuart Stevens served as the chief strategist for Republican Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign and tried to prevent President Barack Obama from winning a second term; in 2020, he is a Never Trump conservative who is rooting for former Vice President Joe Biden, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee. And when Stevens appeared on MSNBC’s “The 11th Hour” on Thursday night, August 6, he stressed to host Brian Williams that many GOP incumbents — from President Donald Trump to members of Congress — could be in trouble in November.
Promoting his new book, “It Was All a Lie: How the Republican Party Became Donald Trump,” Stevens told Williams, “This is a very negative environment for Republicans…. There are external forces out there that make this a very tough race for incumbents in the Republican Party.”
Trump aides frustrated by his ‘nonsensical’ Biden attacks in Ohio: AP reporter
During a segment on MSNBC's "Morning Joe," Associated Press White House correspondent Jonathan Lemire stated that aides close to President Donald Trump thought the president made some good points about the U.S. economy on Thursday -- only to have his message overlooked when he attacked former Vice President Joe Biden.
Speaking with co-host Willie Geist, Lemire said there were other problems with the Ohio visit -- including Republican Gov. Mike DeWine being unable to attend because he tested positive for COVID-19 -- but Trump stating Biden "hurts God" made the economic points the president made secondary in a state where he needs votes.
Expert: Trump playing ‘whack-a-mole’ in attempt to salvage states he should be winning
A top political analyst says President Donald Trump seems to be flying blind as he heads toward an electoral loss.
Dave Wasserman, the U.S. House editor for the Cook Report, told MSNBC's "Morning Joe" that demographic changes had turned formerly reliable red states into competitive congressional races, and that same dynamic had made Trump's re-election campaign even more challenging.
"Pennsylvania, Florida and North Carolina, if you talk to the Trump data people they'll hang their hat on the gap getting narrower in those states," Wasserman said. "What's happening is that a lot of the older voters who, for lack of a better term, are exiting the electorate. They are disproportionally registered Democrats who are conservative and voted for Trump in 2016. Yes, the registration gap is narrowing, fewer voters are registering to vote this year than did in 2016 because we're in a pandemic. That doesn't mean the states are getting more favorable to Trump."