US President Barack Obama will tout New Orleans’ inspirational if incomplete resurgence Thursday, 10 years after Hurricane Katrina ravaged the “Big Easy” and shattered Americans’ confidence in government.
Obama will travel to Louisiana to mark the rebirth of a city eulogized by Tennessee Williams as the “last frontier of Bohemia,” but which in August 2005 became a Hobbesian dystopia of death and looting.
“If you think about nine and a half years ago, I don’t think anybody would have envisioned the dramatic progress that the city of New Orleans has made,” said White House spokesman Josh Earnest.
“It is an opportunity to celebrate the remarkable revival of an American city.”
More than 1,800 people were killed and one million others displaced when Katrina barreled in from the Gulf of Mexico, destroying levees and submerging 80 percent of the city in effluent-tainted storm water.
Americans — almost congenitally imbued with optimism and a sense of invulnerability — watched shocked as stranded survivors waited day after day on rooftops for government help that was painfully slow to come.
Obama will look to contrast that troubled initial response with more successful efforts to resurrect New Orleans: An allegory of what happens when government gets it wrong, and what happens when government gets it right.
The implicit contrast is between his administration’s efforts to get New Orleans back on its feet and George W. Bush’s initial vacillation.
The storm surge scarred the city, but also forged a high watermark of criticism of Bush’s administration.
A photograph of a concerned but detached president Bush viewing the damage from Air Force One has become emblematic of the politics of the crisis.
“I prided myself on my ability to make crisp and effective decisions,” Bush later wrote in his memoir.
“Yet in the days after Katrina, that didn’t happen. The problem was not that I made the wrong decisions. It was that I took too long to decide.”
– Black and white –
But Obama risks looking similarly out of touch if he too strongly talks up New Orleans’ recovery.
That message “would resonate more with the city’s white residents than with its black residents,” said Michael Henderson, of Louisiana State University.
According to a recent LSU poll, the vast majority of white people in the city believe Louisiana has mostly recovered from “the storm.”
Three in five black residents say it has not.
Strong local support for Obama and his Democrats will prevent a backlash, even if his message “does not fully mesh with many residents’ own views or experiences,” said Henderson.
As a senator Obama told a Baptist Church in New Orleans that the government had failed the region even before Katrina. There are signs history may be repeated.
While the last decade has seen an influx of wealthy new residents to New Orleans, many complain that gentrification has left them by the wayside, transforming public schools into charter schools and pushing housing beyond reach.
Ten years on, like the rest of America, the gap between rich and poor — and often white and black — has only grown.
In New Orleans that threatens to fray the unity and resolve that fueled the recovery.
“Even if it is in part a national phenomenon, it is not just a national phenomenon,” said Henderson.
WATCH LIVE: House holds historic vote on the impeachment of Donald Trump
After a 14-hour House Judiciary Committee Thursday hearing considering the impeachment of Donald Trump, Democrats and Republicans on the committee will reconvene once again Friday morning where they are expected to finally vote on the articles of impeachment before sending them to the House floor for a full vote scheduled for next week.
According to NBC, "In a surprise move, Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler delayed the vote until Friday morning at 10 a.m. after more than 14 hours of debate. There were five votes on Thursday: one to eliminate the first article on abuse of power, a second to strike a reference to former Vice President Joe Biden, a third to note the aid withheld from Ukraine was eventually released, a fourth to strike entire second amendment on obstruction of Congress and a fifth to strike the last lines in each article. All were voted down and along party lines."
‘Trump was caught’: Every major GOP excuse for president’s conduct destroyed by ex-prosecutor
Former federal prosecutor Barbara McQuade said Thursday's marathon impeachment hearing left her "shouting" at her television, so she gathered her thoughts and blew up Republican defenses one by one.
McQuade, an MSNBC legal analyst and former U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan, exposed the weaknesses in each of the GOP's sometimes contradictory defenses of President Donald Trump against impeachment by the House of Representatives.
Here are the GOP defenses I have heard so far to articles of impeachment, along with the knee-jerk responses I have been shouting at my television.
‘Selfie-seeking frat boy’ Matt Gaetz scorched in brutal takedown after House committee blow-up
In a brutally blunt look at Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL), the New Republic's Jacob Bacharach paints a portrait of a publicity-seeking Washington newcomer storming the nation's capital with an eye on mirroring the actions and rhetoric of the blustery president that he slavishly defends.
Following Gaetz's "drama queen" performances while serving on the House Judiciary Committee, Bacharach recalls, "On October 23, a gaggle of House Republicans, led by Matt Gaetz of Florida, stormed the Capitol’s Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility. Gaetz had hoped to expose the supposedly secretive nature of the impeachment inquiry into Donald Trump. “Stormed” was his own overly dramatic word (though Gaetz soon topped it by comparing his crew to the 300 glorious, nearly naked Spartans who, as you may recall, lost to a numerically superior force during the Battle of Thermopylae). A more accurate description would be to say they barged into a committee room like a bunch of entitled fussbudgets, argued with the committee chairman, took selfies, and then trundled off to hold a press conference."