Connect with us

Conspiracy theories flourish in Vatican after Pope Francis health scare



After a choppy few weeks for Pope Francis, a strongly denied report that he has a brain tumour has sent Vatican and Italian conspiracy theorists into overdrive.

“The timing chosen reveals the manipulative intention of throwing up a cloud of dust,” the Vatican’s Osservatore Romano claimed in its first edition after another newspaper, Quotidiano Nazionale, published its “scoop” about the pontiff’s health.


Italian media on Thursday largely concurred with the Vatican’s description of the story as baseless and commentators were quick to air their suspicions of a plot to undermine Francis’s authority in the run-up to this weekend’s conclusion of a synod on family that has divided the Church along progressive/conservative lines.

Massimo Franco, an editorialist for Corriere della Sera, said the episode should be seen in the context of a number of embarrassing, controversial or scandalous incidents Francis and his staff have had to react to recently.

Rather than a conspiracy orchestrated by one person or group, the sequence of events realed “a more heterogenous and diffuse malaise,” Franco wrote.

Nevertheless, the architect of the false story, clearly wanted to plant an idea that the pope’s way of speaking and moving reflect the fact that “his brain has something not working,” he added.

Vatican Radio journalist Romilda Ferrauto, acting as a spokeswoman for the synod, said: “One has the feeling that some people want to discredit Pope Francis.”


The synod’s start three weeks ago was overshadowed by a headline-generating ‘coming out’ of a Polish priest who worked at the Vatican. That was quickly followed by a scandal over gay priests in Rome having sex with male prostitutes and vulnerable people in a city park.

Francis subsequently apologised on behalf of the Church for “recent scandals”.

– ‘We wrote the truth’ –


In parallel with these developments, the leaking of a private letter to the pope from conservative cardinals opposed to the way the synod is being run raised the spectre of a return to the “Vatileaks” days when infighting seriously undermined Francis’s predecessor Benedict XVI.

There were also suggestions of manipulation over anti-gay marriage activist Kim Davis’s brief meeting with the pope in Washington — which the Vatican insisted was not intended as a sign of support for her stance.


Cardinal Walter Kasper, a liberal theologian thought to have Francis’s ear, attacked the tumour story as “a maladroit attempt to influence the work” of the synod.

“But they will not achieve that. Nobody will manage to manipulate the Holy Father and the synod fathers,” he added, noting that Francis’s robust health was visible for all to see.

“We see him every day, the pope, and I can assure you he certainly does not give any impression of being sick, you could even say he works too much!”


Quotidiano Nazionale’s director, Andrea Cangini, continued to stand by his story on Thursday and dismissed suggestions the paper could have let itself be used as a tool in a murky, Machiavellian battle.

“We never thought for a moment of organising a campaign against Francis or getting involved in the dynamics between his enemies and supporters.

“We simply got a tip off, we followed it up and we wrote the truth,” he said.

“And this affair will not weaken the pope. It simply makes him more human and closer to the people.”


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
Continue Reading


New Jersey Governor unloads on ‘pathetic’ Blue Dog Dem switching parties: ‘He put politics over the constitution’



New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy blasted Rep. Jeff Van Drew (D-NJ) for being "pathetic" after reports he would become a Republican.

Murphy, a Democrat, was interviewed by MSNBC's Yasmin Vossoughian on Sunday.

"I think it's ridiculous," Murphy said.

'He put politics over the constitution," he continued. "He's trying to be cute instead of being courageous."

"I think it's outrageous. this is a guy who is trying to find a path to get re-elected to Congress, not trying to find a path to do the right thing," Murphy said.

and we've seen it all over new jersey, all around the country, folks who stand up with conviction and courage and state their case more often than not, far more often enough folks say notwithstanding how tense and passionate this discussion is, they get credit for that, as opposed to cutting and running.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Rep Ocasio-Cortez blasts complexity of health care marketplace: ‘No one should go through this’



Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez blasted the complexity of the health care marketplace on the day of the deadline to sign up for 2020 coverage.

Health care has been a major topic in the 2020 Democratic primary, with some moderate candidates defending the Affordable Care Act passed under President Barack Obama, while progressive candidates push for Medicare for All.

"Members of Congress also have to buy their plans off the exchange," she explained. "That means I get to 'choose' [between] 66 complex financial products."

"This is absurd. No person should go without healthcare, and no one should go through this, either," she argued.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Hallmark Channel reverses course and apologies for caving to anti-LGBTQ group



The Hallmark Channel reversed course after a boycott resulted from the network caving to an anti-LGBTQ group.

On Saturday, #BoycottHallmark trended on Twitter nationwide after the network refused to show ads featuring two women kissing after being married.

Continue Reading