Quantcast
Connect with us

CNN guest schools ex-cop over Laquan McDonald shooting video: Your claims violate the laws of physics!

Published

on

Chicago is bracing for the release of video showing the police killing of 17-year-old Laquan McDonald — which some observers fear could tear the city apart.

A judge set a Wednesday deadline for city officials to release the video — which has been described as depicting an execution — but CNN’s police expert has already made up his mind without seeing the video himself that Officer Jason Van Dyke was justified in shooting the fleeing teenager multiple times in the back.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The fact is, this gentleman did have a knife in his hand,” said Harry Houck, a CNN contributor and former New York City police detective. “This could come down to experience, I don’t know. The fact is that apparently they followed this man for almost half a mile with a knife.”

“New Day” host Michaela Pereira reminded the contributor that McDonald was a teenager, not an adult.

“A teenager would kill me just as dead as a 30-year-old,” Houck said. “He had a knife in his hand and he was under the influence of PCP, which is a psychotic drug that makes you go crazy.”

He said officers should have feared that McDonald might encounter and then violently attack a random civilian, and Houck disagreed that police could have set up a perimeter around the teen and then arrest him.

ADVERTISEMENT

“You can’t shoot somebody for a hypothetical citizen who never entered the fray,” said Marc Lamont Hill, a CNN political contributor. “The other five officers were there, and they didn’t perceive a threat.”

Hill said Van Dyke inaccurately claimed after the shooting that McDonald was approaching him with a knife, although those who have seen the dashboard camera video say it shows the officer repeatedly shoot the teen as he lay face-down on the ground.

“That raises serious questions about the veracity of his claims,” Hill said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Houck said officers must act quickly to eliminate potential threats.

“I don’t know if, all of a sudden, I’m sitting there playing stupid, silly games, this guy comes this way here, and he kills an officer — when I could have shot him five minutes ago,” Houck said.

Houck said the officers were trying to contain McDonald when one of them opened fire, but he said Van Dyke was likely justified because the teen could have cut them with the four-inch knife he was carrying — even from 10 to 15 feet away.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Ten to 15 feet — wow,” Hill said.

“I’m not exactly sure of Harry’s sense of physics here and distance, but a four-inch knife 15 feet away — I’m not sure how you can cut someone, particularly if you’re running away from them, just based on the laws of physics,” Hill continued. “Harry, I don’t need to be an expert to know that a knife this long can’t cut somebody from 15 feet away unless it’s a super knife or you throw it.”

Houck argued that McDonald could have run at officers and stabbed them.

ADVERTISEMENT

“But my point is, Harry — he was running the other way,” Hill said.

Houck said he needed to see the video before determining what the threat the teenager actually posed.

“That’s my point,” Hill said. “You have an extraordinary amount of insight into what the police officer was thinking, that the police officer didn’t break any rules, even though you haven’t seen the video. My claim isn’t on what’s on the video — my claim is that if an officer says one thing and then later on a video shows the guy was running the other way, that calls into question the claims that he made.”

Watch the entire segment posted online by CNN:

ADVERTISEMENT


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Tapper smacks Mnuchin with Trump kids’ international business deals after attack on Biden son

Published

on

In a fairly contentious interview with Steve Mnuchin, CNN host Jake Tapper pointed out how Donald Trump's children -- Don Jr., Ivanka and Eric -- have been using their father's name to swing international deals after the Treasury secretary accused former Vice President Joe Biden's son of doing the same.

Mnuchin first dismissed reporting by the Washington Post and the conservative Wall Street Journal that Donald Trump was withholding Ukraine funding in an effort to get dirt on Biden and his son -- saying neither newspaper could be trusted -- he then complained to the CNN host about having to spend seven and a half minutes talking about Trump's Ukraine scandal.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Will Trump peacefully vacate the Oval Office if he loses the presidential election in 2020? A lesson from 1800

Published

on

As primary season heats up in the United States, the Democrats are anxiously debating the best path to unseat Donald Trump in 2020. But the question of how to beat Trump is perhaps less urgent than the issue of whether he will accept defeat.

Trump has already questioned his loss of the 2016 popular vote with baseless accusations of voter fraud. He has also repeatedly toyed with the idea of extending his presidency beyond the eight-year limit enshrined in the U.S. Constitution, even trumpeting Jerry Falwell Jr.’s assertion that his first term be extended by two years to compensate for the Russia investigation. Perhaps most ominously, Trump’s former lawyer Michael Cohen warned while testifying before the House Oversight Committee in February 2019:

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Something is killing galaxies — and science is on the case

Published

on

In the most extreme regions of the universe, galaxies are being killed. Their star formation is being shut down and astronomers want to know why.

The first ever Canadian-led large project on one of the world’s leading telescopes is hoping to do just that. The new program, called the Virgo Environment Traced in Carbon Monoxide survey (VERTICO), is investigating, in brilliant detail, how galaxies are killed by their environment.

As VERTICO’s principal investigator, I lead a team of 30 experts that are using the Atacama Large Millimeter Array (ALMA) to map the molecular hydrogen gas, the fuel from which new stars are made, at high resolution across 51 galaxies in our nearest galaxy cluster, called the Virgo Cluster.

Continue Reading
 
 
Help Raw Story Investigate and Uncover Injustice. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1 and go ad-free.
close-image