Quantcast
Connect with us

Maryland court ruling could delay Freddie Gray officer trials for months

Published

on

By Baynard Woods, The Guardian

State’s second-highest court rules it will not hear arguments in William Porter’s appeal case until March, after which court has months to reach decision

A scheduling decision by Maryland’s second-highest court Tuesday could push back for months the trial of several police facing charges for the death of Freddie Gray.

Maryland’s court of special appeals ruled it would not hear arguments in William Porter’s appeal until 4 March. The state constitution allows the court of special appeals three months after that hearing to reach a decision.

Porter is challenging a ruling that forces him to testify in a fellow officer’s case, despite the risk of incriminating himself before he is tried on his own charges of involuntary manslaughter, reckless endangerment, misconduct in office and assault for his role in Gray’s death.

ADVERTISEMENT

Porter’s appeal of that ruling postponed the trial of Caesar Goodson, which was scheduled to begin 11 January. Goodson faces the most serious charges of the six officers implicated in Gray’s death, and is viewed as prosecutors’ best shot at a conviction. It will likely also hold up the trial of Sgt Alicia White, who was to be tried in February.

Porter was initially scheduled to be tried first so that prosecutors could use him as a material witness in their cases against Goodson, the van driver whose trial for second degree depraved heart murder was scheduled to begin this week, and White. But when the jury in Porter’s case couldn’t reach a decision and the judge declared a mistrial and rescheduled Porter’s case for June, things got complicated.

In what some have called an unprecedented move, the judge ruled last week that the state could compel Porter to testify by offering him limited use immunity. Gary Proctor, one of Porter’s attorneys, promised to appeal the ruling with the court of special appeals. The next day, that court issued a stay on the trial until it could hear the appeal. On Tuesday, the hearing date in that case was set for 4 March.

ADVERTISEMENT

Court watchers say the court’s most recent decision solidifies the perception that officers on trial are getting better treatment than the typical defendant.

“I think the defense has succeeded in declaring that this is unprecedented but it is a very common tool of prosecution to compel testimony,” said Douglas Colbert, a law professor at the University of Maryland. “What’s taking place is not the experience of the typical defendant. The typical defendant rarely succeeds in gaining the attention of the appeals court to enjoin, to prevent a trial from commencing … Typically, appeals courts wait until a conviction occurs and then there’s time periods for both sides submitting briefs. But at the pre-trial stage, it’s exceedingly rare for an appeals court to rule on a pretrial motion.”

Davon Neverdon, an activist who goes by the name PFK Boom, agrees, calling the appeal “a manipulation of justice”.

ADVERTISEMENT

“These officers are getting the White House treatment,” he said, referring to a perceived disparity between the treatment of these officers and the average defendant in Baltimore.

The ruling on Porter’s appeal hearing may mean not only that prosecutors’ best shot at a conviction of Goodson is held up for months, but that trials for any of the six officers will not resume until late February. Edward Nero was scheduled to be tried on 22 February, followed by Garrett Miller on 7 March and Lt Brian Rice on 9 March.

The state has argued that allowing Porter not to testify in the case of Goodson would “result in irreparable harm to the People of Maryland by effectively gutting their government’s prosecution”, so it is not likely that it will proceed with prosecution of White until the appeal is settled, either.

ADVERTISEMENT

This leaves a city — already on edge, but with many patiently waiting for the wheels of justice to turn — facing trials through the spring, when warmer weather encourages protest. It also means that the trials could bump up against the anniversary of Gray’s death in April.

In his first trial, Porter testified that he told Goodson that Gray needed to be taken to the hospital when he arrived to check out the prisoner.

“I suggested for officer Goodson to go to the hospital so he didn’t waste time,” Porter testified.

ADVERTISEMENT

Goodson did not go to the hospital but continued on to the police precinct. Dr Carol Allan, the medical examiner, testified: “If [Gray] had gotten prompt medical attention, it would not have been a homicide.”

But Porter also repeatedly testified that he couldn’t give Goodson a direct order. “I can’t tell Goodson to do anything. I’m not Goodson’s supervisor,” he said.

Porter testified that he also told his own supervisor, Sgt White, that Gray needed to be hospitalized.

ADVERTISEMENT

A gag order imposed by judge Williams prohibits any parties involved in the case from commenting.


Report typos and corrections to [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Facebook

US House of Representatives kills attempt to impeach Trump

Published

on

The U.S. House of Representatives by a wide margin just voted to not take action on a resolution to consider impeaching President Donald Trump over his racist remarks. The forced vote, which is still ongoing, currently stands at 331 in favor of "tabling," or putting aside, the motion, and 93 voting against tabling, meaning 93 voting to consider the motion.

The motion was brought by Democratic Congressman Al Green, who has been trying to impeach President Trump.

This is the first time the House has weighed in officially on the issue.

Some who support impeachment voted against the motion, saying it needs to go through proper channels, generally the House Judiciary Committee.

Continue Reading

Facebook

‘Fat people don’t wear shorts’: North Carolina girl goes viral after being body shamed in church

Published

on

On Wednesday, WCTI News Channel 12 reported on a viral video circulating of a girl in North Carolina being body-shamed at her own church by a community leader.

"She had came [sic] in and said you're too fat to wear those shorts, fat girls don't wear shorts," said 19-year-old Jenna Munger, describing the encounter, which happened as she was visiting the restroom while singing in the church choir.

On the video, which has already gathered more than 5 million views, the woman can be heard saying, "She's a chubby girl, but she's got a dress on that's appropriate; it comes down to the top of her knees."

Continue Reading
 

Facebook

Trump administration diverts development aid meant for Guatemala and Honduras to boost Venezuela’s Guaido

Published

on

President Donald Trump's administration is diverting nearly $42 million intended for development aid in Guatemala and Honduras to support Venezuela's opposition chief Juan Guaido, including staff salaries, an internal document showed.

In a memo obtained by AFP, the US Agency for International Development called Venezuela's political crisis "a significant, exigent event in the US national interest" that required a switch in $41.9 million in funds.

The United States and more than 50 other countries recognize Guaido as president of Venezuela, but leftist leader Nicolas Maduro remains in power despite nearly half a year of international efforts.

Continue Reading
 
 
 

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

Enjoy Summer! Try Raw Story Ad-Free for $1. Invest in Progressive Journalism.
close-image