The city of Cleveland apologized on Thursday for its role in preparing a $500 ambulance services claim against the estate of 12-year-old Tamir Rice, who was fatally shot by police in 2014, and said it had dropped the demand.
City officials said a claim had actually been filed in probate court and that it had now been withdrawn. They said they never intended to bill the Rice family, according to a statement from Mayor Frank Jackson.
The invoice, dated Wednesday, is for Rice’s “last dying expense” and included $450 for an ambulance and $50 for mileage, according to city documents.
“Again, apologizing to the Rice family if in fact this has added to any grief or pain that they may have,” Jackson told reporters.
Rice, a black child who was playing with a replica gun in a park, was shot by a white police officer. The child’s death helped fuel the national debate over police use of deadly force, especially against minorities.
After the Rice killing, a U.S. Justice Department investigation found widespread excessive use of force by Cleveland police. The next day, the Rice family filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the city and officers involved.
In January 2015, the city received a partial reimbursement from Medicaid for $172.90 for ambulance services for Rice, the statement said. The remaining $327.10 was absorbed by the city and the matter closed, the city said.
Earlier this week, the executor for Rice’s estate asked the city to provide a billing statement for services provided to Rice.
When the city got the request, the bill was opened again and sent to the executor, Jackson’s office said. Following standard procedure, a city attorney filed a claim with the probate court for $500 against the Rice estate. On Thursday, the city withdrew its claim.
Jackson said “red flags should have risen” to prevent the claim from being filed.
“But that didn’t happen. Did anybody do anything wrong in this? No, because it’s the normal process.”
Rice family attorney Subodh Chandra said in a statement that the claim made no sense to the family. “This adds insult to homicide.”
A grand jury in December declined to bring criminal charges against the officers involved in the shooting.
Earlier on Thursday, U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton tweeted: “Asking Tamir’s family to pay for his ambulance is heartless. Cleveland should drop this fee.”
(Reporting by Suzannah Gonzales and Mary Wisniewski in Chicago; Writing by Fiona Ortiz; Editing by Bill Trott and Matthew Lewis)
Rudy Giuliani’s devotion has escorted Trump straight to impeachment
"Step by step, [Rudy Giuliani] has escorted President Trump to the brink of impeachment," The New York Times said in a piece following the president's top lawyer and his impact on the scandals facing the 45th president.
Two associates of Giuliani's have already been indicted, Giuliani is under criminal investigation from federal prosecutors, and he was never graced with a top position in the Trump government.
"The separate troubles he has gotten his client and himself into are products of the uniquely powerful position he has fashioned, a hybrid of unpaid personal counsel to the president and for-profit peddler of access and advice," The Times said Sunday.
Trump team ‘is as incompetent, shambolic, paranoid, and given to conspiracy theories as it appears’: MSNBC panel
In a Sunday evening panel discussion, MSNBC commentators explained that the White House appears to be just as chaotic and marred by chaos as the rumors say.
Many in the White House learned that the president's lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, was working overseas in Ukraine. Giuliani claimed that he's been producing a film that he couldn't get Fox News to run, as it will appear on the fringe network OAN.
"What Rudy Giuliani is doing is using Kremlin-manufactured propaganda as a defensive shield for the president," said CNBC's John Harwood. "Fiona Hill was unambiguous in her testimony to the intelligence committee. What Rudy Giuliani has been doing with these two indicted men who are linked to a Russian oligarch who is tied to Russian organized crime, is trying to manufacture a story that Ukraine, rather than Russia or in addition to Russia or differently from Russia, meddle in the campaign. That is false."
Watch Devin Nunes freak out and eject reporters when asked about phone calls with Lev Parnas
Rep. Devin Nunes (R-CA) lost it over the weekend when he was asked about his phone calls with Rudy Giuliani's associate Lev Parnas, who was recently indicted.
Nunes was at a Republican Party fundraiser in New York City when two Intercept reporters asked about the impeachment probe. Recent phone records subpoenaed by the House Intelligence Committee revealed that Nunes had multiple conversations with Giuliani and with Parnas.