New Jersey Governor Chris Christie is unlikely to face criminal prosecution for the “Bridgegate” lane closure scandal, even after two of his former associates were convicted for their roles in the scheme on Friday.
U.S. prosecutors have essentially conceded that charges are not forthcoming against the Republican, even though a key government witness testified that Christie was aware of the scheme as it unfolded in September 2013.
State charges are also a long shot, legal experts said. The Democratic-controlled state assembly might explore impeaching Christie, though that is no sure thing.
“Much as I do think this was an abuse of office, I think the potential remedy for that is a political one, rather than a criminal law one,” said Stuart Green, a law professor at Rutgers University who has followed the case.
Christie was a rising political star before the scandal left his reputation in tatters. After his own presidential campaign failed, he became a key adviser to Republican nominee Donald Trump, and many observers believe he hopes to secure an administration post if Trump wins the presidency on Tuesday.
Christie’s former deputy chief of staff, Bridget Kelly, and former Port Authority of New York and New Jersey deputy executive director Bill Baroni were found guilty on Friday of all counts in Newark federal court.
The pair were accused of closing down access lanes at the busy George Washington Bridge in Fort Lee, New Jersey, to create a massive traffic jam as payback for the town’s Democratic mayor failing to endorse Christie’s reelection campaign.
During the trial, David Wildstein, a former Port Authority official who pleaded guilty and cooperated with prosecutors, testified he and Baroni discussed the lane closures with Christie on the third day of the gridlock.
The governor, Wildstein said, laughed when he heard that Mayor Mark Sokolich was frustrated that his calls for help were going unanswered.
Kelly, meanwhile, testified that she discussed the lane closures with Christie a month before they occurred, though she said she thought they were part of a traffic study.
Prosecutors would not specifically explain why they decided not to prosecute Christie.
“I’m not going to answer the question of why I did or didn’t pursue anyone in particular,” U.S. Attorney in New Jersey Paul Fishman told reporters. “At the time, we indicted only the people who we believed had evidence beyond a reasonable doubt to convict.”
Christie, who is barred from running for a third term, denied any involvement again on Friday. His term ends in January 2018.
“I had no knowledge prior to or during these lane realignments, and had no role in authorizing them,” he said. “Anything said to the contrary over the past six weeks in court is simply untrue.”
State prosecutors could pursue their own case against Christie, but Green, the Rutgers professor, said they have probably known about the evidence for some time and would likely have done so by now.
Last month, a judge referred a citizen’s criminal complaint against Christie to a local prosecutor in Bergen County to decide whether it warrants criminal charges, though experts consider that unlikely.
Impeachment, which carries a lower standard of proof, is a more likely scenario, said Brigid Harrison, a professor of political science and law at Montclair State University.
But Democratic state lawmakers may prefer to leave Christie in office as a convenient punching bag and focus on trying to recapture the governor’s mansion next year, she added.
“The reason why Democrats are not pursuing charges of impeachment already is they want to run against the Christie legacy in 2017,” she said.
(Reporting by Joseph Ax; Editing by Scott Malone and James Dalgleish)
Greenpeace action threatens EU summit venue
An EU summit was at risk of being relocated to a neighbouring building on Thursday after Greenpeace activists scaled the planned venue with the intention of staying there as long as possible.
"The police are currently intervening. The summit will go ahead, but consideration is being given whether to relocate it to the Justus Lipsius building," said an internal message to EU staff.
Early Thursday, 28 Greenpeace activists scaled the facade of the EU's Europa building - where the heads of state and government will meet later in the day to discuss climate measures.
The team deployed a large banner saying "Climate Emergency" and remained gripped to the building. They also held flares.
Japan government ordered to pay damages over transgender toilet ban
A Tokyo court on Thursday ordered the Japanese government to pay compensation to a transgender official who was refused use of the women's bathroom at work.
"The Tokyo district court ordered the accused to pay 1.3 million yen ($12,000) in damages," a court spokesman told AFP.
"The court also ordered the government to let the official use the women's bathroom freely, by removing the requirement that she notify female employees she is transgender," the spokesman said.
The official who joined the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry as a man and now lives as a woman filed suit in 2015, demanding 16.5 million yen in damages over claims she was banned from using the women's bathroom, local media said.
Indicted Netanyahu to resign ministries, remain PM: lawyers
Embattled Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, facing criminal charges and a new general election, will resign from all other ministerial positions he holds but remain premier, his lawyers said Thursday.
The announcement to the supreme court came the same morning as parliament dissolved itself and set a date for a new election, the third within a year.
The court had received a petition from the Movement for Quality of Government in Israel (MQG) demanding that Netanyahu, who is also minister of agriculture, diaspora, health and welfare, step down from all his positions in light of his indictments.