The US economy in 2019 expanded by the slowest rate since President Donald Trump took office as worsening trade friction undermined investment and exports, according to new government data released Thursday.
The $21 trillion economy grew by 2.3 percent compared to 2018, according to the government’s initial estimate.
Though that result remains stronger than many advanced economies, it is far from Trump’s promised target of 3.0 percent or higher.
And economists warn that the details are far less encouraging.
American consumers remained relatively upbeat and continued to buy homes, taking advantage of low interest rates, but spending waned in the final three months of the year, according to the Commerce Department report.
The growth slowdown from the 2.9 percent expansion in 2018 came amid Trump’s escalating confrontation with China last year, which created uncertainty that led businesses to put the brakes on investments, as well as reducing exports and imports, while raising costs for inputs.
Business investments — a category known as “nonresidential fixed investment” — plummeted for three consecutive quarters last year, which analysts at Oxford Economics note is the worst performance since 2009 at the height of the global financial crisis.
Trade collapsed in the final quarter of 2019, with exports flat, and imports falling by the largest amount since 2009, with thousands of products subject to punitive duties in Trump’s multi-front trade wars.
– Election year –
Trump is counting on using a strong economic message to boost his chances of winning a second term in November, but even as the trade picture has improved in recent weeks, uncertainty remains.
He signed a “phase one” trade deal with China, which cheered stock markets despite a lack of details and skepticism among some analysts. But tariffs on two-thirds of the products exchanged between the economic powers remain in place.
White House economic advisor Larry Kudlow said the US has a “fundamentally healthy economy,” and repeated the administration’s view that the China deal will be a boon for businesses and growth.
“As we move toward implementation, phase one, even though it may have caused uncertainties before, it will pay off in major growth dividends later this year,” Kudlow said Thursday on Fox Business Network.
But analysts at Oxford Economics said the data are deceptive and create “the optical illusion of an economy chugging along.”
“Businesses are facing the worst outlook since 2016 with lingering headwinds,” they said, warning that although Trump’s trade deals are encouraging, “euphoria about an impending surge in activity would be misguided.”
In the final three months of the year, US gross domestic product rose 2.1 percent, the same pace as in the third quarter and better than economists had forecast.
Economist Joel Naroff warned that US consumer spending decelerated as the “weakening in wage gains is starting to show through,” which is combined with the “unwillingness of businesses to spend.”
Growth and exports likely were undercut by the crisis at Boeing, which halted production of its top-selling 737 MAX after it was grounded worldwide in March 2019 in the wake of two deadly crashes, as well as the lengthy strike at General Motors.
And the outbreak of a new coronavirus in China, which has sickened thousands and killed nearly 400 threatens to undermine the newfound sense of stability on the global economy, raising concerns that growth could be derailed.
Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell said Wednesday the US central bank is keeping an eye on the possible impacts, as businesses in China shut their doors and airlines cancel flights to the country.
Photo: AFP / Johannes EISELE
Rudy Giuliani flooded reporter’s phone with texts about Biden being ‘senile’ and taking ‘ADD drugs’
Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani this week has been on a tear trying to convince Americans that Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden is senile.
During an appearance on "Fox & Friends" on Tuesday, the former New York City mayor claimed that he had "talked to doctors" who told him that Biden "has dementia."
He then accused Biden of taking performance-enhancing drugs to be able to speak coherently.
"The president's quite right to say maybe he's taken Adderall," Giuliani said.
Daily Beast reporter Asawin Suebsaeng subsequently revealed on Twitter that Giuliani's attacks on Biden's mental faculties have been something of an obsession for him.
WATCH: Ex-Trump adviser clashes with CNN’s Alisyn Camerota over New York Time’s tax bombshell
On CNN Tuesday, Republican lobbyist and former Trump adviser David Urban tried to talk over anchor Alisyn Camerota to dispute the bombshell tax story in The New York Times — and Joe Biden strategist and Never-Trump conservative Ana Navarro-Cárdenas promptly mocked him.
"He's not going to increase your taxes or take away your guns," said Urban. "He's not going to do all of the things that Joe Biden and the Democratic platform says he's going to do. With respect to taxes, I just want to point out I made a graphic of what you had up earlier. He paid 1 million bucks in 2016."
Michael Cohen drops tip on possible fraud Trump committed against the government
Appearing on CNN on Tuesday morning to talk about Donald Trump's problems since the New York Times exposed his avoidance of paying taxes, the president's former attorney, Michael Cohen, said there is plenty for investigators to look at if they're looking for fraud.
He then dropped a tip on financial fraud that may have been committed by the president against the U.S. government.
Speaking with host Alisyn Camerota, Cohen detailed some of the president's financial woes -- saying he is likely headed to personal bankruptcy and even jail ("for a century") because of the massive amount of debt he is carrying -- if he is not re-elected.