A federal judge rejected a frenzied late-night Justice Department bid to limit what Chicago’s top federal prosecutor and three of his assistants can tell her about "misconduct" that occurred during the prosecution of protesters who opposed President Donald Trump's militant immigration crackdown in Chicago.
U.S. District Judge April Perry denied the motion from the bench Monday at a status hearing in the collapsed case against six protesters known as the “Broadview Six,” Chicago Sun-Times reporter Jon Seidel reported.
The department filed the motion at 10:16 p.m. Sunday, less than 11 hours before the hearing, court records show. It was the department’s second bid in less than a week to narrow or stop Perry’s inquiry, after she rejected the first on Nov. 11.
If Perry found the department’s privileges did not apply, the new motion asked her to put off the Dec. 2 hearing so the department could seek “reconsideration or, if necessary, appellate review.” The department had agreed to that date four days earlier, court records show.
In those four days, the department went from accepting the hearing date to asking Perry to shrink the witness list and, if she ruled against it, to push the date back.
“They have each been instructed to assert all of those privileges at the scheduled hearing and in any further proceedings in this matter,” the motion said of the four witnesses.
It argued that “there is plainly no need for anyone but the U.S. Attorney to provide information,” and it asked Perry to excuse the three line prosecutors.
The motion argued that communications with the "executive branch" should be beyond Perry's release. However, the Justice Department previously said that there were no communications with the White House about the prosecution before later adopting the position that those communications would be privileged if they exist.
Perry ordered U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and Assistant U.S. Attorneys William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez to testify in a Nov. 2 order about “the misconduct that has occurred before it in this case.” The order also said she will accept testimony from any current or former employee of the office with first-hand knowledge “who wants to ensure a full and accurate record.”
“None of these privileges protects the fact that a communication happened or existed,” Perry said Monday, according to Seidel.
Her questions would be “purely factual,” she said, though she noted that the prosecutors might want to go further, Seidel reported.
On March 30, Hogan told Perry in a filing that there were “no communications of any nature” with anyone outside the Chicago office about investigatory or charging decisions, including anyone in the White House.
Under Perry’s view, privilege cannot stop the prosecutors from telling her whether any such contact happened.
Hogan’s lawyer, Shelly Kulwin, said Monday that Hogan would not invoke the Fifth Amendment “for sure” and “doesn’t intend to assert any privileges,” Seidel reported.
“He’s happy to fully explain his thought processes, who he talked to, who he didn’t. He’s just going to say what happened,” Kulwin said, according to Chicago Tribune reporter Jason Meisner.
Lawyers for Skiba and Almendarez said their clients do not plan to invoke the Fifth Amendment either, Seidel reported. No one spoke explicitly for Boutros, he wrote.
Before the hearing, Almendarez sat at a table with his own lawyer while some of the former defendants watched from the gallery, Seidel wrote on X.
The department told all four prosecutors to assert privilege, but three came to court with their own lawyers, and one of those lawyers said his client won’t.
Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the department’s No. 3 official and a former defense lawyer for Trump allies, including FBI Director Kash Patel, took over the case two weeks ago and was in court Monday, Meisner reported.
“I would think … the appropriate decision-maker would be one of your colleagues, as opposed to you yourself,” Woodward told Perry about who should rule on privilege, Meisner reported.
“I would love to see any case law on that if you can find it,” Perry replied, according to Meisner. When Woodward said he didn’t know that they would, she said, “I don’t think you are either — but best of luck to you.”
Woodward left with his office’s motion denied and, by his own account, no assurance that he could find case law to move the privilege fight to another judge.
The four witnesses are expected to send Perry written proffers of any potentially privileged testimony by Friday, directly to her rather than to the public docket, Seidel reported. The department may respond by Nov. 25, he wrote.