If any one statement sums up the colossal miscalculation underlying Kansas Republicans’ historic wipeout Tuesday night, it’s a single social media post from Senate President Ty Masterson.
You might remember Masterson as the GOP leader who hoped to succeed Democrat Laura Kelly as governor. He ran against fellow state senator Cindy Holscher, who appeared poised for victory Wednesday after a hard-fought race. In the post, Masterson urged patience as election officials audited ballots in coming days but also edged toward a concession.
That’s not all he said, though.
Last night was a difficult night in Kansas and around the country. But I’m grateful to the hundreds of thousands of Kansans who stood with us, and to every volunteer who gave their time to this campaign.
The first count does not seem to be going our way, but the margin is narrow enough that Kansas law calls for another look, and we’ll let that process finish. Every Kansan deserves to know the result is right.
Whatever the outcome, the fight for lower property taxes, safer communities and better schools doesn’t end tonight. I’ll keep working for those things no matter what, and I’ll work with anyone who wants to get them done.
— Ty Masterson (@TyMastersonKS) November 4, 2026
The Senate president describes the election in black-and-white, good-versus-evil terms. This Manichaean viewpoint allows for no subtlety, no persuasion, no essential humanity. You were either for Masterson or against him.
Look at his first sentence: “Last night was a difficult night in Kansas and around the country.”
Difficult for who, exactly?
Sure, it may have been difficult for Republican candidates and their supporters. But that’s the way elections work. One side wins, and one side loses. What’s more, if a majority of voters selected Democrats rather than Republicans to represent them in Kansas and across the nation, where’s the difficulty?
Masterson implies that Kansas and the Republican Party have some sort of inseparable bond, that a political movement’s setback means a setback for the region. That’s nonsense. Kansas simply made a different choice.
That’s not “difficult.” That’s the essence of representative democracy, and it ought to be celebrated by winners and losers alike.
In my first column after U.S. Sen. Roger Marshall’s loss to Democrat challenger Adam Hamilton, I noted how Marshall’s embrace of similar divisive rhetoric proved toxic as the American people turned against President Donald Trump. Our country may face overwhelming challenges, and we may disagree with one another heartily, but we do reserve the right to change our minds.
Those asking tough questions of Marshall at an Oakley town hall on March 1, 2025, are just as much “real Kansans” as anyone else — Republican, Democrat, Libertarian, Green, independent or devotee of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.
Masterson doesn’t seem to believe that Democrats are real Kansans.
Back in 2018, he denied that Kelly had a mandate as governor, telling Associated Press legend John Hanna that “it’s the legislative elections that are the more indicative of what is going on in the state.”
Well, now that Democrats have won a whopping 57 seats in the Kansas House, does Masterson still believe that? Or was his purpose to never credit his opposition with any claim to guiding this incredible state? (I don’t know why I even bother to phrase those sentences as rhetorical questions. Those with eyes can see the answers.)
Here’s what Hamilton had to say, as a matter of contrast: “This election is a rebuke of unkindness and cruelty in Washington.”
Kansas includes an incredible diversity of people with a range of beliefs. On Tuesday night, some celebrated while others wept. Most, I suspect, simply went to bed and dreamed of a better world.
Politicians who hope to serve this evolving oasis of Midwestern good sense should embrace them all.
Clay Wirestone is Kansas Reflector opinion editor. His first book, “Opinionated: Kansas Journalists Who Proved Why Commentary Matters — Then and Now,” was published in September 2026 by the University Press of Kansas. Through its opinion section, Kansas Reflector works to amplify the voices of people who are affected by public policies or excluded from public debate. Find information, including how to submit your own commentary, here.
Kansas Reflector is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Kansas Reflector maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sherman Smith for questions: info@kansasreflector.com.