White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt’s claim that President Donald Trump was holding Big Law accountable for its “lies” is now at the center of a judge's order to search the White House's servers.
U.S. District Judge Amir Ali on Monday ordered the Executive Office of the President to turn over drafts, memos, and emails tied to the directive Leavitt described, or formally claim privilege over them. The ruling came in the American Bar Association’s lawsuit over Trump’s campaign against major law firms.
“President Trump’s policy team is executing on his directive to hold Big Law accountable for their weaponization of justice and their lies, and the strategy has proven tremendously successful,” Leavitt told The Wall Street Journal in April 2025.
The ABA built one of its demands for White House records around those words, and Ali’s order quotes them to define what the White House must search for. He limited the email search to Feb. 13 through April 18, 2025, the weeks when Trump signed five executive orders against law firms and nine firms cut deals with his administration.
Drafts of the orders “may shed light on the government’s motivation,” Ali wrote, while memos “could establish the existence of a policy of intimidation.”
Leavitt’s public remarks described the kind of coordinated effort the government has disputed in court.
“Big Law continues to bend the knee to President Trump because they know they were wrong,” she said in a statement on April 9, 2025, according to the ABA’s complaint.
In seeking dismissal last year, government lawyers argued the ABA had not plausibly alleged a policy that threatened its members, and that any threat had passed by the time the group sued in June 2025. The ABA has called the policy’s existence the case’s “one central factual dispute,” Bloomberg Law reported.
Ali rejected the dismissal bid in March and cited Leavitt’s “policy team” statement among the official remarks pointing to a broader effort. Her words helped keep the lawsuit alive then, and they now help define what the White House must hand over.
Emails the Justice Department has already turned over show White House aides rushing to lift sanctions on Paul Weiss at Trump’s direction. Trump had targeted the firm with an executive order on March 14, 2025, and lifted it after the firm agreed to concessions.
“Per POTUS, this EO needs to be ready now,” White House senior policy strategist May Mailman wrote on March 19, 2025, using shorthand for the president and the executive order.
Later that night, she circulated “the draft statement Paul Weiss has prepared for themselves and POTUS tomorrow.” In it, Paul Weiss leader Brad Karp said the firm was “gratified that the President suspended the executive order.”
“Perkins Coie is welcome to come make commitments too,” Mailman added, referring to the first firm Trump targeted, which fought its order in court.
Those emails came from the Justice Department’s files. Ali’s order now reaches the White House’s own drafts and memos, and he noted that records already produced refer to specific memos.
The administration argued the requests would “disrupt the functioning of the Executive Branch” and “raise substantial separation-of-powers concerns,” the order says. It has also refused to name the members of Leavitt’s “policy team,” claiming presidential communications privilege, a protection for advice given to the president. A White House lawyer argued that naming them would chill candid advice, Bloomberg Law reported.
Ali said some, even many, of the records may be privileged. The two sides must agree on search terms and propose a schedule by Dec. 4. If the government decides to appeal, Ali wrote, it can ask him to pause the order while the appeal plays out.