A federal judge in Tampa ruled Thursday that the expert backing for New York Times reporters’ tax fraud accusations against President Donald Trump fell short, letting the president’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit move forward.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday denied the motion to dismiss four of the six counts Trump brought against the Times, its reporters and Penguin Random House. The surviving claims center on seven statements, six of which came from the book “Lucky Loser” and accused Trump of tax fraud and related schemes. The seventh came from a Times article and said authorities looked into his ties with the Mafia.
The defendants pointed to experts quoted in a 2018 Times investigation, including a former investigations chief for the Manhattan district attorney’s office who said the family’s arrangement “smells like a crime.” Asked what the tax crime accusations were based on, they also cited the book’s acknowledgments page, which thanked a New York estate lawyer for his help.
Merryday called that kind of input “far from a formal legal opinion.” Without one, he wrote, people who publish such claims “know that they don’t know, but they are undeterred.”
“Knowing of the necessity for that opinion but failing to procure that opinion is a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth, a knowing failure that remains actionable, even after Times v. Sullivan,” Merryday wrote.
The judge found Trump’s allegations on those seven statements plausible enough to go forward, though Trump still must prove them.
A spokesperson for Trump’s legal team praised the decision, telling Politico: "The New York Times has a long pattern of defaming President Trump in service of its leftist political agenda, and today’s momentous ruling is a victory for honesty in America."
Merryday threw out 27 other statements, writing that they are not actionable “even if untrue, even if published with ill-will or evil intent.” He dismissed two counts, refused to let Trump amend his complaint again and gave the defendants 28 days to answer.
Merryday, a George H.W. Bush appointee, struck Trump’s original 85-page complaint last year and sent his lawyers back to rewrite it. In July, he put off ruling on the Times’ motion to dismiss and ordered another amended complaint.
In September, Trump bashed The Times and The Washington Post as “fake news” after banning three newsrooms from the White House. The Times has called the suit meritless and an attempt to stifle independent reporting.