New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s Friday announcement on X that he will be closing the city’s largest jail complex at Rikers Island caused conservatives to go off the deep end.
“We’re closing Rikers once and for all,” Mamdani posted on X alongside a video with Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards. The plan calls for replacing the island complex with four smaller borough-based jails, the first opening in Brooklyn in 2029.
Nonetheless, conservatives felt the need to express alarm and stoke up panic on social media.
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) accused the city of “abandoning law and order.”
“Where will the violent criminals go? Back onto the streets?” Mace wrote. “New York should be a world-class city. Not a lawless hellhole.”
Former NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton called the plan “insanity,” arguing that the new jails, “if they ever are built,” won’t hold enough people.
“Does any sane, rational person believe that in a city of over 8 million people there are only 3,500 criminals who need to be incarcerated?” Bratton asked. He warned it was “the recipe for mass migration to Florida.”
Ari Fleischer, former press secretary to former President George W. Bush, quoted Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Scarlet Letter” before declaring, “The problem isn’t the prison. It’s the people inside.”
ACT for America founder Brigitte Gabriel warned that freed inmates are “coming straight back to your streets, subways, and neighborhoods,” while Rightline News editor Eric Daugherty mocked the Uganda-born mayor as the “Ugandan Mayor” and complained the new jails would be “more comfortable," before writing a panicky, "NEW YORK CITY IS COOKED!"
The Trump War Room account knocked the plan as “toxic empathy for criminals,” while conservative Rasmussen Reports scoffed at the claim that closing Rikers “means safety for everyone,” adding, “Really?”
The plan doesn’t empty Rikers overnight. Under Mamdani’s timeline, the complex would close by the end of 2032, five years past the August 2027 deadline set by a 2019 City Council law, according to amNY. The new facilities would hold about 4,500 beds, and the city must shrink its jail population from about 6,600 to 4,100.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement, Newsweek reported. “For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane.”