Tensions flare at GOP fundraiser as angry gun rights activist confronts Republican legislator

A Texas GOP fundraiser Tuesday brought state House Speaker Dennis Bonnen face-to-face with the gun rights activist whom state troopers recently intercepted at Bonnen’s home, the latest chapter in sharp tensions between the two.

“It was a setup,” Bonnen told The Texas Tribune in an interview Wednesday evening, saying the activist, Chris McNutt, was seated close to Bonnen and appeared prepared for an encounter with him.

After a confrontation with McNutt and others in his group, Bonnen left the closed-door event early, before his scheduled speaking slot.

The incident illustrated the still-flaring tensions from a couple weeks ago when McNutt was met by officers with the Department of Public Safety outside Bonnen's home while the speaker was in Austin.

The troopers had already been monitoring Bonnen's home after McNutt visited homes of other lawmakers that he has blamed for inaction on "constitutional carry" legislation that would allow Texans to carry guns without a permit. Bonnen accused McNutt of intimidation tactics, and the revelation of the home visits dealt a death blow to the constitutional carry push at the Capitol.

The latest incident unfolded Tuesday evening inside the JW Marriott hotel in downtown Austin, where the state party was holding its annual spring fundraising dinner. The headliners were the Big Three — Bonnen, Gov. Greg Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick.

McNutt was invited to the fundraiser by Darlene Pendery, a top Republican donor who had purchased three VIP tables to fill with 30 guests. She said she invited McNutt and Bonnen before the controversy surrounding McNutt's travel to lawmakers' homes.

McNutt did not respond to requests for comment Wednesday, but both Bonnen and Pendery offered detailed accounts of the evening. Pendery said it was a "horrible night" marked by Bonnen looking for a fight and losing his cool, while the speaker said it was the other side that took it too far, well aware of the situation it was creating.

Bonnen said he first learned about McNutt's attendance at the fundraiser earlier in the day when some fellow lawmakers gave the speaker a heads-up that the activist would be there and may try to confront him. Bonnen said he then inquired about the situation with organizers and was assured he would not be seated with McNutt.

Bonnen nonetheless ended up seated "back to back" with McNutt — at the table next to his, the speaker said. As the dinner was getting underway, Bonnen said he walked up to McNutt, tapped him on the shoulder and shook his hand.

"'Hi, I'm Dennis Bonnen,' I said," the speaker recalled. "'You should never go to my residence or any member of the Legislature's residence when you know they're in Austin doing their job. I want you to tell me you're never gonna do that again.'"

Pendery said the initial interaction was not so innocent, with Bonnen appearing "out of nowhere" and confronting McNutt while he was trying to eat his salad, raising his voice at the activist.

In any case, McNutt remained quiet while the speaker talked to him, according to both Bonnen and Pendery. Then, Bonnen said, McNutt handed the speaker an envelope with a letter personally addressed to him. Bonnen said he took the letter and expressed some gratitude to McNutt, saying the letter was an appropriate way to advocate for an issue as opposed to going to lawmakers' residences.

That was not the end of it, though. In Bonnen's telling, something strange then happened: an unidentified man seated next to McNutt handed the speaker a Kool Aid packet. Bonnen said he tossed the packet on the table, prompting the man to stand up and threaten a "physical altercation." The man, Bonnen said, "kinda got in my face and said you should just leave."

While Bonnen did not identify the man, Pendery said another one of her guests, David Wylie, had stood up and tried to defuse the situation. But ultimately Wylie "urged [Bonnen] to leave after several attempts to reason with him," Pendery said.

While their accounts weren't identical, Bonnen said he ultimately obliged with the suggestion he should leave.

"I'm the speaker of the House," Bonnen said. "I don't need to be in that type of confrontation. So I left."

Bonnen's departure came before he was set to speak at the event, a major annual fundraiser for the Texas GOP. Party officials did not respond to messages seeking comment Wednesday.

Pendery was a "co-sponsor" of the event, meaning she paid $25,000 per table. According to an invitation, the co-sponsor level included a “VIP table with 10 seats” as well as the donor’s “choice of elected official to be seated at your table — on a first confirmed basis.”

Pendery has become one of the state's larger Republican donors, perhaps best known for bankrolling primary challengers in state House races as well as boosting other anti-establishment causes. In the 2018 election cycle alone, she donated almost $740,000 to GOP candidates and groups at the state level, according to records with the Texas Ethics Commission.

Among the candidates she supported was Bonnen’s primary challenger, Damon Rambo, who got a $10,000 contribution from Pendery.

In an email, she defended McNutt's activism, saying she has talked with him at length about the recent drama and believes he is "guilty of nothing more than flyer distributing." Bonnen, of course, sees it differently.

"We're at a point where these people think that threatening your family ... and then setting up confrontations in public where they mock you and lie about what has occurred is the way to participate in the process," Bonnen said. "It's destroying the process, quite frankly."