President Donald Trump’s Justice Department case over an alleged attack on a Turning Point USA reporter was mired in confusion when the defense tied her separate civil lawsuit to a Republican National Committee senior attorney who worked on "election integrity" efforts.
In a filing Monday, lawyers for Christopher, Deyanna and Paige Ostroushko said hidden data in Turning Point contributor Savanah Hernandez’s lawsuit against the family lists RNC senior counsel James Hasson as its author.
Defense attorneys withdrew that filing late Tuesday afternoon.
Hasson has never appeared as a lawyer in that case, where Jesse Franklin-Murdock represents Hernandez. The Ostroushkos asked the court to weigh the evidence as it decides their motion to dismiss the criminal charges as a vindictive political prosecution.
“It reinforces that this is a political prosecution, with its tendrils stretching not just to the White House but also to senior counsel at the RNC,” the defense wrote in Monday's filing.
Attorneys for the Ostroushkos clarified on Tuesday that a "shell pleading" from the RNC had been repeatedly used by Hernandez’s attorney to author his legal documents.
"On November 17, 2026, the government provided Defendants’ counsel a sworn declaration from a lawyer in the civil case indicating that the RNC lawyer was not involved in drafting those pleadings, and that the metadata listing the RNC lawyer as the author of those documents derived from the use of a shell pleading from another, unrelated case," the newest filing said.
The document did not explain why an RNC "shell pleading" was used in the case.
The charges stem from an April 11 protest outside the Whipple Federal Building near Minneapolis. Hernandez says she was attacked as she tried to leave, while the family’s lawyer says she pushed Paige Ostroushko’s face first. All three pleaded not guilty.
The file data lists Hasson as author of six filings, including the complaint and a sworn declaration from Franklin-Murdock himself. Franklin-Murdock appears as author only on an exhibit.
Hasson has been the RNC’s senior counsel and head of litigation since April, according to his LinkedIn page, which the defense attached. During the 2026 midterms, Hasson continued to play a lead legal role for the RNC.
Hernandez launched her lawsuit against the Ostroushkos in May 2025.
No public response from the RNC, Hasson, Franklin-Murdock or Hernandez could be found Tuesday. Prosecutors told the defense they wanted to review the exhibits before taking a position.
Franklin-Murdock spent years working for the official whose office took up Hernandez’s criminal case.
“I moved 2500 miles to work for Harmeet, and spent 4 years working for her,” he wrote on X Nov. 8, defending Harmeet Dhillon, who led the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division until resigning Nov. 5.
He joined her private firm, Dhillon Law Group, in 2021, according to his firm biography, four years before she took over the division.
Hours after the April 11 clash, Dhillon told Hernandez on X that she was “on it.” Three days later, she said her office was “actively involved” in the investigation.
A federal judge had already ordered prosecutors to back up their most serious charge.
On Oct. 29, U.S. Magistrate Judge John F. Docherty ordered a bill of particulars, a detailed statement of the charge, on the felony count against Christopher Ostroushko and Paige Ostroushko. He also granted the defense’s request that he review the grand jury record himself.
That count accuses the two of interfering with a federally protected activity and carries up to 10 years in prison when someone is hurt, but the indictment never says what that activity was. The other counts are misdemeanors, and Hennepin County’s lone misdemeanor case against Christopher Ostroushko was dismissed.
The law also bars such a prosecution without the attorney general’s written approval. Todd Blanche, then acting attorney general, signed it April 27, but it reached the court Sept. 29, two days after the defense flagged its absence.
That leaves the case’s only felony resting on a grand jury record the judge has ordered handed over for his own review.
That kind of review sank the Justice Department’s case against the “Broadview Six” protesters in Chicago this year.
After reading unredacted grand jury transcripts, U.S. District Judge April Perry found that prosecutors had vouched for the case and talked with grand jurors outside the room. The government then dropped the remaining charges for good. The Ostroushkos’ lawyers cited that case when they asked for the review.
“The victim’s connections might imply that she is under some form of special protection,” prosecutors wrote in October, arguing that vindictive-prosecution claims turn on defendants, not victims.
Prosecutors have also said they charged the family over an assault, not their politics, pointing to cases they brought on behalf of Democratic victims.
The court had set Monday as the day it would take the dismissal motion under advisement, giving prosecutors time to submit the grand jury materials. The family wants every charge thrown out.