A federal judge said federal agents pulled a stunt so outrageous she struggled to find words for it in a blistering new ruling.
According to a Wednesday court order from U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney of the District of Colorado, Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents arrested a man moments after his court-ordered release. Sweeney held an ICE official and the government in contempt of court.
Ramon Quintero Alvarez, a Mexican national who has lived in the U.S. for more than 30 years, was the man re-arrested by ICE agents. Sweeney had ordered his release if the government failed to justify his detention by Oct. 27, but the Trump administration never responded. A Nov. 3 status report said that Quintero Alvarez had been released on Oct. 27 and "immediately re-detained," per Sweeney's order. Government lawyers told the court they would not argue his detention was lawful, per the filing.
Quintero Alvarez walked out to the lobby and into "a public area," where "officers met him outside and rearrested him," according to testimony from Nichole Black, an assistant field office director for ICE. Black testified at a Nov. 4 hearing that she received a "direct order" passed down from Acting Field Office Director Nathan Rasper to re-detain released petitioners "that had some type of criminality."
Black said she "knew" he had pending criminal charges, but she agreed it was "fair" to say her information was inaccurate. The charges tied to Quintero Alvarez's most recent arrest had been dropped in April, according to the order.
"Ms. Black said in her own words that she believed it was permissible to simply escort someone to a public area and immediately re-detain them despite a court order to the contrary," Sweeney wrote.
"This should—and, in the Court's opinion, must—shock any reader. There is not a single word in this Nation's Constitution that sustains or could plausibly give rise to Ms. Black's 'belief' that ICE and ICE agents can walk out to the sidewalk and re-shackle a habeas petitioner within a minute of that petitioner's court-ordered release."
Black told the court she knew of "approximately ten" similar cases, and the government later put the number at 18, according to a footnote in the order.
"Sometimes, behavior stuns and renders a listener speechless. In one turn of phrase, lost for words," Sweeney wrote. "Any reader—and chief among them, Respondents—would do well to keep these binding statements in mind."