Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY) baffled real estate veterans when a mystery buyer paid $910,000 over the last list price for her family’s Capitol Hill home after it sat unsold.
The three-bedroom rowhouse, six blocks from the U.S. Capitol, sold in June for $2.9 million in cash, The Washington Post reported Friday. Only two Capitol Hill homes are publicly listed as having sold for more in the past year.
The house went on the market in September 2025 for $2.195 million. When it did not sell, the price dropped to $1.99 million in November, and the listing came down in February.
The buyer was AFS Real Estate Holdings, a limited liability company formed in Delaware about a month before the sale. It has no online presence, and the Post found nothing in public records identifying its owners. D.C. law requires companies formed in the city to disclose their owners, but not companies formed elsewhere.
Stefanik did not answer the Post’s written questions asking whether she knows who owns and operates the company.
“In this slumping housing market, this is definition of highly unusual,” Washington Sun reporter Paul Kane wrote on X. “She won’t ID who buyer is.”
A half-dozen real estate agents and estate lawyers, each with decades of experience on Capitol Hill, told the Post they could recall no other sale in which a buyer paid so much more than a seller had recently been asking. Nor could they see why the house would be so expensive.
“There may be outlying factors I’m not aware of, but from what I can see on the listing and the property records, it seems to be a very unusual purchase price,” said Patrick Tangney, a settlement attorney with two decades of experience in the Washington region.
The Post found no records or work permits showing any changes to the home in the four months between when it came off the market and when it sold.
“A reasonable appraiser looking at six months of sales in my opinion would not be able to justify $2.9 million for this house,” said Tom Faison, a broker with more than three decades on Capitol Hill who identified comparable sales at the Post’s request.
“I’ve never known a $3 million buyer, or any buyer, who would overlook the history,” Faison said.
“I live in Capitol Hill and homes are not generally selling for a million over asking after sitting on the market for months,” Slate senior politics writer Jim Newell posted on X.
Stefanik’s office told the Post the house was first listed during a government shutdown and “a slow holiday season,” then sold in a “commercially reasonable transaction.” Stefanik was a minority owner of the house, and her office said off-market sales are increasingly common in Washington.
“The offer to buy the investment property was made and accepted within the range of prices for comparable historic townhouse sales in the neighborhood that range from $2-$4 million,” her office said.
The Post confirmed that 13 of the 34 properties her office cited sold for more. But all but three had more bedrooms than Stefanik’s house, all but two had more living space, and most sold more than a year before hers.
Stefanik, whom Politico described in May as one of President Donald Trump’s “fiercest allies,” leaves Congress when her term ends in January. She dropped her bid for New York governor in December 2025 but told Politico she would not rule out a future run for any office.
After the June sale, the family company that sold the house bought a newly built $3.3 million home in McLean, Virginia. Stefanik signed a $434,425 mortgage on it, and the document identifies her as the company’s “managing member,” the Post reported.