Podcast host and legal expert Katie Phang blasted the Justice Department’s “egregious” handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files after new filings in her lawsuit shed light on how the records were reviewed before release.
“This is huge, huge admission by the Department of Justice here,” Phang said Friday on her YouTube channel, flagging a sworn declaration that identified Everlaw, an AI-enabled legal document review platform, as the software the department used to review the files.
The MeidasTouch host zeroed in on a redacted email address for Epstein as she questioned how the department decided what to keep from the public.
“Why would Jeffrey Epstein of all d— people have his email address redacted?” she asked.
Phang, who sued the Justice Department over records it withheld or redacted under the Epstein Files Transparency Act, highlighted instructions for reviewers on how to apply redactions in batches and change or remove them.
“How do they actually screen it?” she asked.
The sworn declaration described a second round of reviews. Everlaw offers generative AI tools, but it was unclear whether reviewers used those features for the excerpts Phang discussed Friday.
Phang called out the Trump DOJ for its handling of the case, as she questioned how the identifying information of survivors still made it into the public.
“They have outed people that never wanted to be outed as victims of Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and others,” Phang said, adding that top DOJ officials still “want to shrug their shoulders and say, ‘Yeah, but we did our best.'"
“What a crock of s—,” she added.
Phang said U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan ordered the department to produce its administrative record by Dec. 1. That record could show what instructions reviewers were given when deciding what to black out.
“We know for a fact that they messed up that production so egregious that even now some of it is still not right,” she concluded.