A Republican senator trashed Social Security as a "Ponzi scheme" ahead of a committee hearing on the federal social insurance program's future, and critics pounced on his claims as drag on the GOP's chances of winning back their congressional majorities in two years.
Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI), a longtime detractor of the social safety net for retirees, on Wednesday morning will chair a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Social Security, which has has repeatedly derided as a "scam" – a claim he repeated on Fox Business.
"At this point, there's really no way to fix Social Security," Johnson said. "It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it, you just shut it down and hope that you can recovery some of your money."
Social media users expressed puzzlement that Johnson would telegraph future efforts to dismantle the popular program.
“No. Americans have paid into their Social Security with every paycheck," stated Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV). "I’m not going to let Senate Republicans like Ron Johnson gut the benefits seniors have earned across a lifetime of work. My priority is working toward solutions that protect Social Security for current seniors and future generations."
“Strong start to Ron Johnson’s ‘28 re-election campaign," chuckled Pod Save America's Jon Favreau.
"A winning 2028 message," agreed tech CEO Arthur Colker.
"Coming to a Democratic ad in Wisconsin near you," predicted The Independent's Eric Michael Garcia.
"Well I guess we know Ron Johnson isn’t running for reelection," observed political commentator Matt Stoller.
"I get why most Republicans favor cutting Social Security to higher taxes, but I don’t understand how this proposal — shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money — is supposed to work," opined political commentator Matt Yglesias. "Who recovers whose money?"
"Not only is this politically toxic, but it is just totally wrong substantively," pointed out Michael Linden, of the Center for Equitable Growth. "Over the next 4 decades, the gap between SS revenues and obligations is about 1.25% of GDP. That’s not nothing, but it’s actually a bit smaller than the tax cuts Sen. Johnson voted for last year."
“The top red to blue Senate flip opportunity in 2028 wants to shut down Social Security," advised Democratic strategist Matt McDermott.
“Social Security is the most popular and effective program in America. Ron Johnson wants to ‘shut it down,'" argued the activist group Social Security Works. "And any Republicans who won’t commit to making billionaires pay their fair share agrees with him.”