A federal judge swiftly rejected the Justice Department’s last-minute bid to sideline her from a dispute over evidence in a case brought after President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown in Chicago.
U.S. District Judge April Perry issued the "quick slap-down" Friday morning, just 14 hours after Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward argued that she was acting as both prosecutor and judge in her inquiry into alleged misconduct in the “Broadview Six” case, the Chicago Tribune reported. He asked her to appoint someone else to decide what evidence was protected ahead of a Dec. 2 hearing.
“But Perry was having none of it,” Tribune reporter Jason Meisner wrote. In her ruling, Perry said the “substance of the motion reflects a basic misapprehension about what a special master does.”
The judge added that she would still have to make the final decisions about which communications were privileged, the Tribune reported.
Perry also called the motion “untimely.” She said in her ruling the Justice Department had known for more than five months that she planned to hold the hearing but waited until 6:50 p.m. the night before potentially privileged materials were due to file its request.
“Perry has so far shot down attempts by the Justice Department to limit or derail the proceedings,” Meisner wrote Friday.
The case stems from felony charges against six protesters outside an immigration detention facility in Broadview, Illinois. Chicago U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros, who is expected to testify in December, dropped the charges after allegations of grand jury misconduct surfaced.
Meisner added that the case “could offer the spectacle of Boutros being ordered by his bosses in the attorney general’s office not to answer certain questions, or even with Chicago’s top federal law enforcement officer asserting his Fifth Amendment rights."