The Department of Justice’s internal ethics watchdog has found that two of its own lawyers broke professional conduct rules by misusing artificial intelligence, and one of them made false statements to a court about it.
That could put them on the road to potential disbarment.
According to Bloomberg Law, the findings appeared in two anonymized summaries the DOJ’s Office of Professional Responsibility released Tuesday. In each case, the office sent its conclusions to the department’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which has the power to recommend that state bars take action.
The more serious case involves a lawyer who relied on AI to draft a court filing that turned out to include invented quotes, and who then misled the court about it. According to OPR, the violations were committed “knowingly and intentionally.”
Bloomberg Law noted that the summary lines up with its previous coverage of Rudy Renfer, a veteran civil lawyer with the federal prosecutor’s office in North Carolina. Renfer submitted the faulty brief in a case where he was defending the government. He was let go in March, and a judge later issued a formal reprimand over both the filing and his lack of candor in his response to the court.
The second lawyer, whose name wasn’t released, got in trouble for uploading documents to a publicly available AI program. That move violated a protective order issued by a tribunal and broke department rules. OPR called the conduct “reckless.”
The cases are a sign that concern across the legal world about AI-generated errors in court papers has caught up with government attorneys, too, the report notes.
Fake or faulty material has surfaced in government filings before. A DOJ lawyer faced embarrassment in court when bogus quotations came to light, and a judge left legal experts reeling after finding ICE attorneys had cited cases that don’t exist.
In a separate immigration matter, a frustrated judge removed a DOJ lawyer from the case, citing a “deliberate attempt to mislead.”