RawStory

Arthur Engoron

'We got caught': Trump's team reportedly 'very surprised' by huge E. Jean Carroll ruling

Donald Trump's team was "very surprised" by the $83.3 million damages ruling in the E. Jean Carroll defamation case, and those close to the former president see a need to recalibrate their approach, according to a reporter on Saturday.

The Guardian's Hugh Lowell appeared on MSNBC's Alex Witt Reports, where he was asked about how Lowell's sources close to Trump viewed the recent Carroll decision. The host asked him if the massive number is "even being seen as something that will effectively rein Donald Trump."

Keep reading... Show less

'Trump will be convicted so fast it will make his head spin': former federal prosecutor

Friday's $83.3 million judgment against former President Donald Trump in writer E. Jean Carroll's defamation lawsuit is proof that the former president can and will be convicted in criminal court, according to a veteran federal prosecutor.

In a Saturday thread posted to X (formerly Twitter), Glenn Kirschner — who was an assistant US Attorney in the office of the US Attorney for the District of Columbia — predicted that Carroll's judgment is merely the first guilty verdict in court Trump will experience in 2024.

Keep reading... Show less

'Unusual inclusion' in E. Jean Carroll jury instructions helped seal Trump's fate: expert

According to former U.S. Attorney Joyce Vance, a cautionary warning provided to the jury deciding the E. Jean Carroll defamation trial by the judge all but assured there would be no jury nullification in support of Donald Trump.

On her Substack platform, the former prosecutor admitted she had never seen anything quite like the comments made by U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Senior Judge Lewis Kaplan as he sent the jury off to decide the case that ended with the former president being slapped with an $83.3 million judgment.

While praising Kaplan for keeping the trial on track and not putting up with any foolishness from Trump and his lead attorney Alina Habba, Vance suggested a key turning point came when Kaplan made an "unusual" appeal to the jurors.

ALSO READ: Alina Habba is persona non grata at her Pennsylvania law school

Pointing out that Trump was likely banking on "jury nullification" from just one juror to avoid a massive penalty, Vance wrote, "Judge Kaplan had an unusual inclusion in his jury instructions, something I’ve never heard a judge do before. He read from the Constitution. He talked about 'we the people' and the establishment of a justice system. And he referred to the history of the Southern District of New York, where federal courts have been in existence since 1789."

Keep reading... Show less

'I would regret having her represent him': Trump's ex-lawyer slams Alina Habba's blunder

Trump might as well have been defending himself.

That was the sentiment offered by his former attorney Timothy Parlatore during an interview with Kaitlan Collins on CNN's "The Source" after a jury in New York federal court took three hours to award an $83.3 million sum in favor of the former president's sexual assault accuser E. Jean Carroll.

Keep reading... Show less

Trump in for 'rude awakening' when these cases 'hit him where it hurts': legal expert

Former President Donald Trump is getting hit in the pocketbook in a painful way that he never has been before, attorney and legal expert Katie Phang told MSNBC's Alex Witt on Friday evening — both in the new $83.3 million judgment for defamation of E. Jean Carroll, and more civil litigation still to come.

"This is money for defaming Ms. Carroll ... and the price tag here is extraordinary," said Witt. "But I wonder if you can talk a little bit about your expectations for how Donald Trump actually coughs up this money, and whether this is held in escrow, whether he seeks, alone given what happened in previous civil trials."

Keep reading... Show less

Trump Org. gave error-riddled and 'inconsistent' disclosures: court-appointed monitor

The court-appointed monitor for the Trump Organization in the New York civil fraud case is sounding the alarm that the company's disclosures are "inconsistent" and riddled with errors, reported The Messenger on Friday.

"'I have identified certain deficiencies in the financial information that I have reviewed, including disclosures that are either incomplete, present results inconsistently, and/or contain errors,' former federal judge Barbara Jones, tasked with scrutinizing the former president's business empire, wrote in a 12-page letter," reported Adam Klasfeld. "Though she described Trump and his businesses as 'cooperative' with her investigation, Jones added that 'information required to be submitted to me pursuant to the terms of the monitorship order and review protocol has, at times, been lacking in completeness and timeliness.'"

Keep reading... Show less

Alina Habba was 'a little sneaky' before being 'shut down' by Trump trial judge: expert

The New York judge in Trump's second defamation case involving E. Jean Carroll permitted only a "little bit" of sneakiness by Alina Habba before she was shut down, a legal expert said Thursday.

That's all according to former federal prosecutor Harry Litman whose "Talking Feds" series on YouTube attempted to decipher the cryptic three minutes of what he called "nontestimony testimony" by former President Donald Trump on Thursday in Manhattan federal court. Litman said that performance will send the jury to "scratch" their heads.

Keep reading... Show less

'He was a bit nervous': Trump aide says ex-president was 'intimidated' by Carroll judge

America isn't Trumpistan.

Former White House press secretary Stephanie Grisham appearing on CNN's "Out Front" said she believes that her former boss and the 45th president was a small figure in Judge Lewis Kaplan's courtroom when he took the stand in the defamation case against him for disparaging E. Jean Carroll, a writer claiming he sexually assaulted her back in the 1990s.

Keep reading... Show less

'Most ridiculous direct examination I’ve ever seen': Trump testimony bemuses experts

Legal analysts were quick to call the decision to put Donald Trump on the stand in the E. Jean Carroll damages trial absurd before it happened Thursday. Once it unfolded, they concluded it had earned Trump nothing — and likely worked against him.

While discussions were taking place about whether Judge Lewis Kaplan was going to allow Trump on the stand, the president began yelling about not being at the first trial, where he was ultimately found liable for sexual abuse and defamation.

Keep reading... Show less

Trump facing bankruptcy with 'profound' trial judgments headed for 'nine figures': experts

According to two legal experts, the combination of financial fines Donald Trump is facing in the E. Jean Carroll defamation case and the Trump Organization financial fraud case being heard in Judge Arthur Engoron's Manhattan courtroom just blocks away, could push the former president to the precipice of filing for bankruptcy protections.

With Trump and his family having already been found guilty in the fraud case brought by New York Attorney General Letitia James, and the defamation trial in the damages stage with a decision on the monetary amount expected very soon — possibly before the weekend — one former Department of Justice official claimed the dollar amount could be "profound."

Speaking with Newsweek's Kate Plummer, ex-DOJ litigator Gene Rossi explained, "A jury is not going to tolerate repeated defamatory behavior. If a large money judgment is entered to stop him, the Herculean task for Ms. Carroll will be collection. Her efforts to get even a nickel from Mr. Trump could indeed force him into bankruptcy."

"If the jury is appalled by the conduct of Mr. Trump and is turned off by the arguable antics of his lawyers, then the judgment could be tens of millions of dollars," he added.

Former prosecutor Matthew Mangino set the outside number of financial penalties even higher.

ALSO READ: Trump suggests he will ‘suspend my campaign’ to seemingly dupe supporters out of cash

"Donald Trump already lost—the compensatory and punitive damages could be enormous," he explained before adding, "I'm sure his assets are neatly tied up, bankruptcy is a mere business decision. Trump has all his marbles in winning back the presidency whatever the cost. His outward contempt for the court and the process is very dangerous. I would guess, and juries are impossible to predict, that the punitive award could be as high as nine figures."

The report notes that estimates of Trump's worth at $2.6 billion according to Forbes.

You can read more here.

'What does narcissism mean?' Alina Habba probes witness as Trump watches

Alina Habba, an attorney for Donald Trump, asked a witness to define "narcissism" as the former president looked on.

After attorneys for E. Jean Carroll rested their defamation case Thursday, Habba called Carol Martin, a longtime friend of Carroll, to the stand.

Keep reading... Show less

Eric and Don Jr.'s lawyer aghast at 'brazen' comparison to pharma bro Martin Shkreli

An attorney for Eric and Donald Trump Jr. expressed outrage Wednesday after the brothers were compared to financial criminal Martin Shkreli.

In a letter to New York Supreme Court Justice Arthur Engoron, New York Attorney General Letitia James cited an appeals court decision to uphold Shkreli's lifetime ban on doing business in the pharmaceutical industry.

Keep reading... Show less

Latest court filing could see Trump banned for life from working in New York

New York Attorney General Letitia James is again pushing to see Donald Trump hit with a lifetime ban from the state's real estate industry.

In a letter filed with the court Tuesday Colleen Faherty, a lawyer in James' office, argued that New York State Executive Law 63(12) allows the court to "issue a permanent and plenary ban in a particular industry."

Keep reading... Show less