Trump stares blankly at mass death -- and reveals just how out of touch he truly is
On Feb. 4, 1992, George Herbert Walker Bush was campaigning for reelection at the National Grocers Association convention in Orlando. There, the president âgrabbed a quart of milk, a light bulb and a bag of candy and ran them over an electronic scanner,â wrote Times correspondent Andrew Rosenthal. âThe look of wonder flickered across his face again as he saw the item and price registered on the cash register screen.â
âThis is for checking out?â asked Mr. Bush. âI just took a tour through the exhibits here,â he told the grocers later. âAmazed by some of the technology.â
This article was originally published at The Editorial Board
Rosenthal said this small moment was symbolic of something larger: The president, he wrote, âseems unable to escape a central problem: This career politician, who has lived the cloistered life of a top Washington bureaucrat for decades, is having trouble presenting himself to the electorate as a man in touch with middle-class life.â The Timesâ frontpage headlineââBush Encounters the Supermarket, Amazedââwas enough to set off a wave of news stories about Bushâs alleged remoteness from Americans worried about an economic recession that defined the election.
Iâll return to this. For now, I couldnât helping thinking of this moment in campaign history after watching the current presidentâs Axios interview. In a long and winding exchange, Donald Trump claimed that the new coronavirus pandemic, which has now killed 160,000 Americans and infected almost 5 millionâwith no end in sightâis under control. âUnder the circumstances right now, I think itâs under control.â
Jonathan Swan, stunned, asked: âHow? One thousand Americans are dying a day.â To which the president said: âThey are dying. Thatâs true. And it is what it is. But that doesnât mean we arenât doing everything we can. Itâs under control as much as you can control it. This is a horrible plague that beset us.â To which Swan, giving Trump room to back away from it is what it is, asked: âYou really think this is as much as we can control it? One thousand deaths a day?â To which Trump saidâwell, nothing really, except more of the same, by which I mean blaming other people for his problems.
It makes no sense whatsoever to say things are under control while at the same time blaming others for letting things get out of control. Thatâs not my point, though. My point is the presidentâs perfect absence of human emotion. One thousand deaths a day. Thatâs one Sept. 11, 2001, every third day. (Globally, someone dies every 15 seconds from Covid-19, according to Reuters.) In a previous America, a previous American president encountered a supermarket check-out and expressed a bit of amazement at some newfangled technology. We were told it captured something bigger. We were told heâs out of touch. In this life, this president feels nothing in the face of death and disease. Heâs not astonished. Heâs not shocked. And it is what it is. Has any president been as out of touch? The headline should be: âTrump Encounters Suffering, Unamazed.â
The thing about Presidentâs Bushâs amazement in 1992 is there was a good reason for it. The Associated Press ran a story a week after Rosenthalâs appeared in the Times, explaining that the check-out technology was novel at the time. Bush wasnât amazed by the sight of a supermarket scanner. He was amazed that the supermarket scanner could read bar-code labels that had been âripped and jumbled,â a true advancement.
Maybe Andrew Rosenthal just got it wrong, but I suspect something else. The press corps often wants to tell a certain kind of story, a story that will get attention, and it searches for opportunities to tell it. In his case, Rosenthal probably wanted to tell a story about a cloistered incumbent grown distant from the little people, and âthe look of wonderâ that flickered across Bushâs face was all the prompting he needed.
The same goes for Trump. Even now, the press corps maintains the story of a rich populist with the common touch, because maintaining it mangles political stereotypes in ways wholly satisfying to professionals wholly bored by political stereotypes. That might not be so bad if it did not also undermine previous criteria for being out of touch. Trump has never cooked his own meals, washed his own clothes, paid his own bills, or ever raised his own kids. He sure as hell never went grocery shopping. Yet Bush was out of touch and Trump isnât, even as this president stares blankly at mass death.
I think weâre seeing less storytelling and more truth-telling. CNNâs Jim Acosta reported this morning what âa source familiar with Trumpâs Tuesday Oval Office meeting with his coronavirus task force saidâ about the president. Trump, the source said, âis still not demonstrating that he has a firm grasp of the severity of the pandemic in the US. âHe still doesnât get it,â the source said. âHe does not get it.ââ
Acosta said that even when the team âtried to stress the dire nature of the situation to the president during the meeting, the source said Trump repeatedly attempted to change the subject.â Thatâs what you do when youâre out of touch. Thatâs what you do when youâve never been in touch. Thatâs what presidents do when they just donât care.
Letâs say so.
John Stoehr is the editor and publisher of the Editorial Board, a newsletter about politics in plain English for normal people and the common good. Heâs a visiting assistant professor of public policy at Wesleyan University, a fellow at the Yale Journalism Initiative, a contributing writer for the Washington Monthly, and a contributing editor for Religion Dispatches.




