'You are vile!' Judge accused of using ICE threats to terrify truant teens

A municipal court judge in Somerset County who oversaw truancy cases threatened children who came before him and their mothers with deportation, according to a formal complaint issued by a judicial advisory board.

The 13-page complaint released Tuesday includes transcripts of court proceedings overseen by the now-former judge, Britt J. Simon, who was a municipal judge for Bound Brook, Bridgewater, Somerville, and Raritan Borough. It accuses Simon of violating the judicial conduct code by repeatedly threatening the children and using language that created the appearance of bias.

“Your mother’s going to get deported. You are going to end your mother’s life. You want other people involved in your family business? Your mother came to this country to get a better life,” he told one 16-year-old last August, the complaint says.

In January, eight days after President Donald Trump took office for his second term, Simon told a 14-year-old that “there’s a new sheriff in town” and that the courts were a “great place” to find people facing deportation.

“You think I’m kidding? The ICE officials wait outside the door for people like you,” Simon said.

Simon has been suspended from his judicial duties since Feb. 11. The state Supreme Court’s advisory committee on judicial conduct filed the formal complaint against him Monday.

Simon’s attorney did not return a request for comment.

The complaint includes details on three truancy cases overseen by Simon. It says he raised his voice, scolded the children in his courtroom, addressed them without a municipal prosecutor present, and roped in their parents for additional scoldings.

On Aug. 13, 2024, he told the 16-year-old that he’s going to be “a beggar, piece of garbage” because he doesn’t go to school. He then asked the student if his mom had legal documentation to be in the United States, to which the student said no.

“So you want to call attention to the school truant officer — two officers sitting here — that you get law enforcement involves (sic) in your lives. Don’t you? So your mother can get picked up and deported by ICE. That sound like a great idea? You’re a wonderful son. I say sarcastically because you’re not,” Simon told the teenager. “You are vile and contemptuous. You want your mother to get deported? You know what’s going to happen if she does, right?”

Simon then said he’d refer the student’s case to child protective services, adding that those workers may report his mother and “at some point, ICE is going to come and pick her up, all because of you.”

“You don’t be late. I am not kidding you. Look at your mother, get ready to say goodbye to her,” Simon said.

In another case that day involving a high school girl who was late to school every day and eventually stopped attending, Simon again turned his attention to her mother’s immigration status (the mother confirmed to Simon that she was not in the country legally).

“How are you going to feel when the law enforcement comes to the house — ICE comes to the house because they get reported this and they deport your mother because of you?” he told the girl.

On Jan. 28, Simon presided over the case of a 14-year-old girl who missed 67 of the previous 91 days of school. In this case, both the student and her parent were undocumented.

“You’re about to get plucked up by the ICE officials and sent back to El Salvador. Do you want to go there?” Simon asked the girl.

“No,” she responded.

“You miss another day for school and I’m going to personally have ICE here to pick you up,” Simon told her.

GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.

SUBSCRIBE

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence T. McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com.

ICE signs up private prison firm to open massive $60M-a-year immigrant detention center

The largest federal immigration detention center on the east coast will open in Newark, Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials announced Wednesday.

Delaney Hall, a 1,000-bed facility located next to the Essex County jail, will be the first immigration detention center to open under the Trump administration. The facility’s owner, private prison contractor Geo Group, said Thursday it signed a 15-year contract with ICE worth about $60 million annually.

ICE officials said the new detention center would help it manage growing arrests and deportations ordered under President Donald Trump, who campaigned for reelection pledging a mass deportation effort. Delaney Hall’s closeness to Newark airport is also key, according to ICE.

“The location near an international airport streamlines logistics, and helps facilitate the timely processing of individuals in our custody as we pursue President Trump’s mandate to arrest, detain and remove illegal aliens from our communities,” acting ICE director Caleb Vitello said in a statement.

I think what’s really surprising here is not that the site is opening. It’s that we’ve waited this long and still have done nothing.

– Amy Torres, executive director for the New Jersey Alliance for Immigrant Justice

In an earnings call Thursday, Geo Group officials said they expect to open Delaney Hall by the end of June, and that expanding detention capacity to address “unprecedented” enforcement efforts is a priority under the Trump administration.

George Zoley, CEO of the prison company, said Delaney Hall is “brand-new inside and it’s all ready to go. All we need to do is the recruitment, the hiring, the background screening, and the training.”

Delaney Hall housed immigrant detainees between 2011 and 2017. Geo Group has been considering reopening it since at least April 2024, when it sued New Jersey over a state law that bars private and public companies from contracting with ICE to house immigrant detainees. A federal judge in 2023 ruled that the law is unconstitutional as it pertains to private companies, a ruling that New Jersey has appealed and has yet to be heard by a federal appellate court.

Michael Symons, a spokesman for Attorney General Matt Platkin, said the office hopes the judge’s ruling will be overturned on appeal.

“Private detention facilities threaten the public health and safety of New Jerseyans, including when used for immigration purposes,” Symons said.

When it opens, Delaney Hall will be the state’s second private detention center for immigrants. The other is the Elizabeth Detention Center, which can hold about 300 detainees.

Amy Torres, executive director for the New Jersey Alliance for Immigrant Justice, criticized lawmakers for not acting on this issue while the Trump administration touted plans of mass deportation.

“I think what’s really surprising here is not that the site is opening. It’s that we’ve waited this long and still have done nothing,” she said. “The question of what more they could have done suggests they’ve done anything.”

Torres said critical protections could be put in place through the proposed Immigrant Trust Act legislation that has stalled in the Statehouse. The bill would bar public schools, health care facilities, shelters, and libraries from collecting data on immigration status and codify bans on local law enforcement from working with federal immigration authorities.

“The truth is, as soon as the first ruling was laid down, New Jersey should have gotten to acting on protecting immigrant communities, and they just, frankly, haven’t,” she said.

Rep. Rob Menendez (Fran Baltzer for New Jersey Monitor)

Rep. Rob Menendez (D-08) also urged lawmakers to pass the legislation, stressing that the unveiling of a new detention center in New Jersey is a clear signal of ramped-up enforcement removal efforts here.

“If they didn’t think the threat was real already, their eyes should be wide open right now, and the Immigrant Trust Act should be passed into law right now,” he told the New Jersey Monitor.

The Department of Homeland Security has touted a spike in arrests of undocumented immigrants since Trump regained the White House in January, saying Wednesday that more than 20,000 migrants have been arrested in that time. Raids have been reported around the state, from Union City to Haddon Township.

Newark made national headlines after ICE detained several migrants and questioned U.S. citizens at a warehouse in the city days after Trump took office. Thursday, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka condemned the plans to reopen Delaney Hall as “nothing short of lawlessness.”

“We are a nation of laws. We will not stand by while ICE, under the heavy-handed policies of the Trump administration, operates with impunity — violating not only our values but the very legal processes that govern this country. This is more of the same bully behavior from Washington, which disregards the Constitution when it is convenient for their agenda,” he said in a statement.

Baraka said he will “explore every legal and political avenue” to challenge ICE’s move.

ICE is also exploring reopening the Albert M. “Bo” Robinson Treatment Center, a 1,000-bed facility in Trenton that held state prisoners until 2022. According to records obtained by the American Civil Liberties Union in November, ICE is looking to house at least 600 immigrants there.

Menendez said lawmakers got “no heads up” about the decision to reopen Delaney Hall, but already knew the direction the administration was heading. During a recent visit to the Elizabeth Detention Center, the facility was nearing capacity, he said.

Eliana Fernández, director of organizing for immigrant advocacy group Make the Road New Jersey, said state officials have the ability to increase funding for deportation defense and ensure state resources won’t help ICE detain and deport immigrants.

“We must fight back against the narrative that detention and deportation is a moral crusade and a public good, but that in fact these are simply efforts to funnel public resources into the private prison industry,” she said.

Spokespeople for Senate President Nicholas Scutari (D-Union) and Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin (D-Middlesex) declined to comment. Earlier this week, Scutari said he doesn’t think the state needs to pass the Immigrant Trust Act, citing a 2018 attorney general’s directive offering some protections, like barring local police from sharing data with ICE and cooperating in civil immigration enforcement operations. He believes expanding and codifying that directive would open the state up to a lawsuit.

Tyler Jones, a spokeswoman for Gov. Phil Murphy, said the administration is “extremely disappointed” in the news about Delaney Hall.

“Our Administration has previously fought to limit such entities opening in our state and will continue to do so,” Jones said.

In his budget address Tuesday, Murphy said he would defend immigrant communities and wants to give the Attorney General’s Office $1 million to fight lawsuits against the Trump administration.

Torres said ICE’s move to reopen Delaney Hall is an opportunity for Murphy to “show us what that looks like.”

“The very first ICE facility under the Trump administration is opening in your own backyard, your largest city,” she said. “So you’re a target anyway, whether you have the courage to act or not.”

Immigrant activists conflicted on new state guidance to N.J. schools

Immigration activists have mixed feelings about guidance issued by the state Department of Education urging school districts to develop protocols in case federal immigration officials show up at schools.

The guidance came after the Trump administration threw out federal policies that protect undocumented immigrants from being arrested in “sensitive locations” like schools and churches, and amid a rise in uncertainty and fear in parents, children, and teachers about how far-reaching President Trump’s threat of mass deportation is.

“They knew that this was going to be the outcome, and they waited until this week to issue guidance. Better late than never, but at what cost?” said Amy Torres, director of the New Jersey Alliance for Immigrant Justice. “It’s great to put out this guidance, but I think it’s going to take a lot of effort to make sure that everyday administrators and teachers have time to go through and read all this.”

Since Trump took office Monday, his administration has rolled out the aggressive immigration policies he vowed to implement while on the campaign trail. He’s signed sweeping executive orders related to immigration, including expanding the military’s role in border security, canceling refugee resettlement, ending the asylum program, and attempting to limit the constitutional right to birthright citizenship.

On Tuesday, the Trump administration reversed guidance that had been in place for over a decade restricting immigration agencies from carrying out enforcement in “sensitive locations.”

“Criminals will no longer be able to hide in America’s schools and churches to avoid arrest. The Trump Administration will not tie the hands of our brave law enforcement, and instead trusts them to use common sense,” the Department of Homeland Security said in a statement.

The state issued its guidance to schools Wednesday. It urges districts to develop protocols for how to handle Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers who visit schools with an ICE warrant for arrest of alien or a warrant signed by a judge, how to support children and their families, and what type of information should be shared on the spot with immigration agents.

If an immigration agent declares an “exigent circumstance” and demands immediate access, school officials should comply and immediately notify top school administrators, the state says.

Torres called the language about exigent circumstances “fuzzy,” saying ICE agents have lied to families in order to arrest someone or masquerade as local law enforcement to get people to open their doors. ICE officials might make up those circumstances to access the school, she said.

Itzel Hernandez of immigrant rights group American Friends Service Committee said she supports the guidance, but believes it could be stronger. She said the vast majority of teachers aim to protect students and that they care about investing in students’ futures.

It’s why she’s not surprised at the overwhelming number of requests from schools seeking more resources on how to best support parents, educators, and students.

“There are so many schools asking for presentations and want to know what to do,” she said. “I’m glad guidance came from the top, and I’m sure that some folks will have at least some sense of direction after they see this.”

El Pueblo Unido is leaving these know-your-rights cards in businesses around Atlantic City. (Courtesy of Cristian Moreno-Rodriguez)

Cristian Moreno-Rodriguez is the founder of El Pueblo Unido, an immigrant advocacy group in Atlantic City. The organization sent a letter to Atlantic City school officials urging them to “move with all sense of urgency” to set up the protocols and policies called for in the guidance, he said.

“Our sense is that unless the community responds and shows up, that they won’t move on it. Our fear is that they won’t respond swiftly, and unfortunately, we’re in a situation where every day, families are at risk,” he said.

All the activists said they’ve heard reports of parents unenrolling their children from public school out of fear that ICE agents could show up and low attendance rates in schools with high immigrant populations.

“What we’re hearing both from our community and the network of teachers we organize with is that everyone is anxious and everyone is fearful of what could happen,” Moreno-Rodriguez added. “Everyone is sort of on alert in terms of when the next ICE raid will be. Will it be a job site? Will it be on the school route while parents are walking their kids to school?”

School staff should be prepared for the basics, Moreno-Rodriguez said, like educating secretaries and administrators on different warrants and ICE forms, how to communicate with immigration agents, and how to inform families of their rights related to immigration.

El Pueblo Unido and other immigrant organizations are holding “know your rights” workshops to educate people on what to do if there’s an ICE raid (Newark Mayor Ras Baraka said ICE agents raided a business in that city Thursday). Moreno-Rodriguez said he’s received messages from Atlantic City teachers who want to distribute the cards with information about people’s rights.

To avoid creating a sense of distrust or fear, Moreno-Rodriguez said he wants to be proactive and collaborate with multiple groups in the area — including teachers — to ensure immigrants don’t feel like they have to hide.

“I think the reality is that there will come a day where immigration officers come to Atlantic City or come to New Jersey, and that’s where if we’re not organizing now, then we’ll lose that battle of people retreating back into the shadows,” he said.

Disgraced Republican mayor resigns under plea agreement in misconduct case

Embattled Clark Mayor Sal Bonaccorso stepped down Friday as part of a plea agreement that required his resignation following criminal charges and a racism scandal.

Bonaccorso, 64, pleaded guilty in Superior Court in Union County to conspiracy to commit official misconduct in the third degree, and forgery in the fourth degree. As part of his plea agreement, Bonaccorso will have to pay a $15,000 fine over the course of three years and will be sentenced in February to probation.

Bonaccorso also agreed to forfeit his right to hold public office or employment again. After the court documents were signed during Friday morning’s hearing, the forfeiture went into effect immediately.

Voters reelected Bonaccorso, a Republican, in November to a seventh term, despite the public corruption charges and racist rants caught on tape.

He was first charged in November 2023 when the New Jersey Attorney General’s Office of Public Integrity & Accountability claimed Bonaccorso used municipal resources — computers and fax machines — while operating his oil tank storage removal business, Bonaccorso & Son LLC, without proper removal licensing. They also said he directed or used township employees to perform duties for his business while being paid by the township.

During their investigation, officials also found fraudulent signatures impersonating an engineer on permit applications.

“Today’s guilty plea secured by OPIA ends a long and sad betrayal of the community by someone who had been in a position of power and trust for a long time,” Attorney General Matthew Platkin said in a statement. “Anyone who betrays the public’s trust by placing their own interests ahead of their duty as a public servant to New Jersey residents will be held accountable.”

His company is now ineligible from bidding for any public contracts, entering into public contracts, or conducting any business with the state or political subdivisions for five years. The company also is barred from conducting, or contracting to conduct, any storage tank removals for three years.

Bonaccorso wore a red tie and black suit in court Friday, making few comments besides directly addressing Judge Lisa Miralles Walsh’s questions. When asked if the value of the township services he used was below $200, he said, “I believe so.” And to another question about the charges he pled guilty to, he responded, “I know now.”

“Do you understand that it doesn’t matter whether or not you knew then?” Walsh asked Bonaccorso, who replied, “Yes.”

After the hearing, he walked past reporters without answering questions. His attorney Robert Stahl issued a statement calling the plea agreement the “best course forward for his health, his family and the town he so dearly loves and has devoted more than two decades to.”

Council President Angel Albanese will serve as acting mayor until the township’s Republican committee submits candidates to serve as interim mayor.

Bonaccorso came under fire in 2022 when NJ Advance Media published a conversation in which he used slurs to describe Black people. Gov. Phil Murphy then called for his resignation, but Bonaccorso refused to step down.

'We have to save America': GOP strategist claims 'suburban moms' are 'afraid' of Harris

Within days of Vice President Kamala Harris announcing she would seek the presidency this November, Geri Jannarone said her phone buzzed nonstop from women reaching out to find ways to get involved.

Jannarone is the head of Emerge New Jersey, an organization that aims to increase the number of Democratic women in public office. She said the surge in interest in the race for the White House didn’t just come from politically active women, but also from those who have never labeled themselves as political people, she said.

“We’ve never seen anything like it, not since the Obama campaign,” said Jannarone. “It’s really exciting and important to have someone like Kamala at the very top because it is so representative of who New Jersey is, who we are, and what makes us.”

Jannarone is one of the many Democrats celebrating their party’s new ticket, with Harris at the top and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz as her running mate. Jannarone believes Harris as the party’s standard-bearer will inspire more women to run for office, and she’s seen a new excitement over the campaign in communities of color and among younger voters.

Some polling backs her up. An Aug. 4 CBS News poll found younger and Black voters are more likely to go to the polls now that Harris is the nominee. The poll says 74% of Black registered voters say they will definitely vote, compared to 58% in July, when President Biden was still planning to seek reelection.

Marilyn Davis of public affairs firm MDD Connections said her 20-year-old niece, who wasn’t planning to vote for Biden in part because of his failed attempt to fully forgive student loans, is eager to campaign for Harris, Davis said.

“I’m like, ‘What? In a nanosecond, you’re not only ready to support the vice president, but actually go out on the campaign trail, which you’ve never done in your life,’” Davis said. “So there is absolutely so much excitement about her candidacy.”

Davis previously worked with the Democratic National Committee during Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign. Now, she’s helping organize virtual fundraisers for Harris, create county-level teams to boost her campaign, and shift some resources over to Pennsylvania.

Harris’ campaign may resonate with women not just because some want to see a woman win the White House but because of how front of mind reproductive rights is in this election, Jannarone said. She also noted former President Donald Trump “showed us who he is again” after telling a group of Black journalists last week that Harris “happened to turn Black” — Harris is the daughter of a Jamaican father and an Indian mother who both immigrated to America — and that undocumented immigrants are “taking Black jobs.”

Those comments “absolutely offended” communities of color, said Davis. And, she added, who is Trump to define someone’s race?

Republicans have blasted Harris’ promotion to the top of the Democratic Party’s ticket as one that disenfranchised 14 million primary voters who cast their ballots for Biden.

Jeanette Hoffman, a Republican public affairs strategist, said New Jersey Republicans are happy to have women as their party’s leaders, noting that New Jersey’s only woman governor, Christine Todd Whitman, is a Republican and former Lt. Gov. Kim Guadagno was the Republican nominee for governor in 2017 (Whitman this week endorsed Harris over Trump).

But Hoffman added Trump’s running mate, Ohio Sen. J.D. Vance, isn’t doing any favors to gain support from voters, pointing to comments he made in a 2021 Fox News interview saying that people without children “don’t really have a direct stake” in the nation.

“Republicans always need to work harder to appeal to women voters, and J.D. Vance and his ‘childless cat women’ comments certainly isn’t helping that mission,” she said.

The CBS News poll also showed a third of Republicans are more motivated to vote now that Harris will be Trump’s opponent. Christine Fano, who chairs the Republican Committee of Montville Township, said Harris’ “leftist” policies and Walz’s “extreme” views have suburban moms afraid of what a Harris presidency would look like.

“This is basically, it’s a call — we have to save America,” she said.

Fano said she doesn’t believe suburban moms are connecting with Harris. People want to hear more about kitchen table issues, she said, like the skyrocketing cost of groceries, gasoline, and housing.

“They don’t buy what she’s selling. They feel as though she’s a phony,” Fano said. “She didn’t really have any accomplishments before she became vice president. I think many women believe it’s wonderful someone who is in leadership be a woman, but she really has to have merit.”

Amid Democratic excitement for the new ticket — Davis said she joined a Zoom call with tens of thousands of Black women that was organized within hours of Harris’ campaign launch — some Democrats remain trepidatious.

Earlier this month, former Assemblywoman Sadaf Jaffer joined a similar Zoom call for South Asians supporting Harris. She said numerous messages in the chat asked what Harris would do to bring a cease-fire in Gaza and how her approach to the war in Gaza would be different than Biden’s.

Jaffer said it’s “definitely powerful” to have a Black and South Asian woman on a major-party ticket, but said she and others remain “cautiously optimistic.” While Arab American communities are relieved that Biden isn’t seeking reelection, families are also grappling with losing dozens of members amid the war, she said.

Jaffer wants to see more outreach from the Harris campaign to Muslim communities and Arab Americans in New Jersey. With their priorities and perspectives heard, the Harris campaign would have a “winning strategy,” she said.

“We have to be consistent as Democrats — if we say that we believe in equality, and that every person’s life is valuable and deserves dignity and safety, that has to apply in our international endeavors as well,” she said.

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence T. McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and X.

Political power broker George Norcross indicted on racketeering charges

George Norcross III, a powerful Democratic power broker, was charged with racketeering on Monday along with five others including his personal lawyer, his brother, and a former Camden mayor.

New Jersey Attorney General Matt Platkin unveiled the 13-count indictment during an unusual press conference in Trenton in front of an audience that included Norcross, who sat in the front row and at one point refused to move seats when asked to by someone in Platkin’s office.

“Is there someone more significant than the lead defendant in the case to have a seat in the front row while he’s being excoriated by the attorney general of the state?” one of the defendant’s lawyers asked.

The indictment accuses Norcross of overseeing a criminal enterprise, using direct threats and intimidation to win development rights along the Camden waterfront and then benefiting from millions of dollars in state-issued tax credits.

In one instance, the indictment alleges Norcross told an unnamed developer who didn’t want to give up their waterfront property that he would ensure the developer never does business in Camden again. The indictment alleges that Norcross later recounted the conversation in this way in a recorded conversation:

“Are you threatening me?” the developer asked.

“Absolutely,” Norcross responded.

Platkin said Monday that Norcross and his allies manipulated government programs designed to attract development and investment to instead suit their own financial desires.

“Instead of contributing to the successes of the city of Camden, through a series of criminal acts alleged in the state’s case, the Norcross enterprise took the Camden waterfront all for themselves,” the attorney general said.

The indictment includes salty language not uncommon to New Jersey political scandals. It alleges Norcross once threatened a developer that he would “f**k you up like you’ve never been f**ked up before.”

The charges come during a turbulent year in New Jersey politics. In March, Democratic Party bosses lost the chance to use county-line ballots to push their favored candidates during primaries, and in May, U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez’s second corruption trial in the last seven years began in a federal courthouse in Manhattan. Menendez, a Democrat, has indicated he will seek reelection as an independent in November if he is not convicted, a move that is certain to harm the chances of the Democratic nominee to succeed him, Rep. Andy Kim.

Norcross’ co-defendants are his brother Philip Norcross, who runs the Parker McKay law firm; Dana Redd, the former Camden mayor; Bill Tambussi, Norcross’ attorney; Sidney Brown, the head of trucking company NFI and a Norcross business partner; and John J. O’Donnell, a real estate developer and president of The Michaels Organization. There are also several unnamed co-conspirators, Platkin added.

“This alleged conduct of the Norcross enterprise has caused great harm to individuals, businesses, nonprofits, the people of the state of New Jersey, and especially to the city of Camden and its residents,” Platkin said. “That stops today.”

When a reporter asked about Norcross’ presence at the press conference, Platkin refused to comment.

The charges including racketeering, official misconduct, conspiracy to commit theft, financial facilitation of criminal activity, and misconduct by a corporate official.

Norcross denies the allegations. Norcross, an insurance executive and chairman of the Camden-based Cooper University Health Care, has long maintained great political power in Camden and in greater South Jersey. His brother Donald is a member of the House of Representatives.

Speaking to reporters after the charges were released, Norcross suggested the case is Platkin’s payback for being “humiliated and exposed” in front of a Senate committee that investigated rape allegations of a campaign staffer for Gov. Phil Murphy (the staffer has said she told Platkin about her claims and he mishandled them). Norcross also suggested Platkin’s political ambitions are to blame — Norcross called Platkin a politician “masquerading as an attorney general.”

“I want to go to trial in two weeks. I want Matt Platkin to come down here and try this case himself, because he’s a coward, because he has forced people in this building to implement his will,” Norcross said.

Platkin’s announcement comes on the heels of charges his office filed Friday against two South Jersey Transportation Authority board members who are alleged to have used their positions to punish a Norcross foe.

The new allegations stretch back to at least 2012. Norcross and his allies wielded their political influence — at the time, Norcross was aligned with the state Senate president, Stephen Sweeney — to tailor economic development legislation to their preference before extorting and coercing landowners to obtain property rights in Camden to benefit Norcross and his allies, Platkin alleges.

“As George Norcross himself allegedly said, ‘This is for our friends,’” Platkin said.

Platkin alleges Norcross and his allies helped pass a law in September 2013 called the Economic Opportunity Act. Norcross, in a meeting with allies ahead of the law’s enactment, said he wanted to use the new legislation to construct an office building for free, according to the indictment.

The indictment lays out how the Norcross team exchanged emails with top political leaders at the time, including former Gov. Chris Christie and Sweeney, sending talking points in support of the bill. And following the law’s enactment, lawyers lobbied to amend it in a way that would benefit Cooper hospital, according to the indictment.

Authorities allege Philip Norcross touted the law — even while noting “this probably is not such a good thing” — because the state would cover tax credits for all capital and related costs for developers coming to Camden with jobs.

“Over ten years, it’s a hundred percent, and … it will cause real havoc, it’s unlimited,” he said in a recorded conversation, according to the indictment.

Overall, the law doled out lucrative tax breaks to businesses in the form of billions of dollars. Later, Murphy’s administration would establish a task force to investigate how the awards were granted.

The charges announced Monday include allegations surrounding the L3 complex, two three-story buildings and surface parking on a 21-acre lot near the Camden waterfront. The claims offer an illustration of how Platkin’s office alleges the Norcross team operated.

Cooper’s Ferry Partnership, a nonprofit redevelopment organization, was seeking to purchase the L3 site. Norcross allies intervened, according to the indictment, by having the Camden mayor’s office instruct the nonprofit’s leaders to meet regularly with Philip Norcross “so the Norcross Enterprise could monitor what the nonprofit was doing,” the indictment says. Philip Norcross then told the nonprofit it would suffer repercussions if it chose their own developer instead of one of the Norcross team’s choosing, according to the indictment.

In the end, Cooper’s Ferry — which could have partnered with a developer and earned millions from shared profits — instead sold the property at a “discounted price” to the Norcross-chosen developer, the indictment says. Cooper University Health Care then bought a substantial ownership share in the developer and over the next four years, won $27 million in state tax credits, the indictment says.

The state also claims that after this episode, a Norcross ally threatened the Cooper’s Ferry CEO, forcing him to resign. Cooper’s Ferry became Camden Community Partnership in 2021. Redd is now its president and CEO.

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence T. McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and X.

New Jersey mayor at center of racism scandal charged with public corruption

The state Attorney General’s Office accused a Republican mayor in Union County Monday of abusing his office by using public resources to operate his private landscaping business — actions the state says investigators uncovered while they were probing allegations of racism within the town’s police department.

Attorney General Matthew Platkin announced the charges against Clark’s longtime mayor, Sal Bonaccorso, during a press conference where Platkin also released a scathing 43-page report alleging police brass of violating the department’s regulations and making “disturbing” racist comments.

“There is a social contract that imposes an expectation that officials in positions of governmental and law enforcement leadership will do the right thing, act not in self-interest but in service to the greater good, and treat all people with respect and dignity as equals,” Platkin said. “These are not naive ideals or lofty ambitions but rather the bare minimum expectations communities should have in their leaders. The leaders in the Clark Police Department, and the township more generally, failed to keep up their end of that bargain.”

Platkin’s investigation stems from allegations dating to 2020, when the town agreed to pay $400,000 to settle a lawsuit to avoid the release of secret recordings of Bonaccorso and police officials using racist and misogynistic language.

The long-awaited report says there is no evidence of criminal misconduct stemming from the racism investigation, but officials recommended terminations for two police officials anyway, including the town’s police chief. Platkin said he does not have the authority to fire them.

That investigation exposed the mayor’s alleged wrongdoing, state investigators say. While acting as mayor, Bonaccorso, 63, used municipal resources by storing records related to his landscaping business, Bonaccorso & Son, in the mayor’s office and using township devices like computers and fax machines for the private business, state officials said. He also directed township employees to perform work for the business, according to Platkin.

Platkin’s office also alleges Bonaccorso improperly removed hundreds of underground storage tanks in nearly two dozen towns starting in 2017. It claims not only that Bonaccorso did not have the necessary permits to perform this work, but that he also fraudulently used an engineer’s name and license number — and forged a signature on permit applications — without that engineer’s knowledge.

Platkin’s office also alleges Bonaccorso misrepresented to the towns where he formed this work that the engineer was the on-site supervisor.

Plus, after Bonaccorso learned of the state’s investigation, he told a witness to provide false information to state investigators, according to the complaint.

Bonaccorso is charged with official misconduct, records tampering, witness tampering, falsifying records, and forgery. He faces up to 10 years in prison if convicted. His attorney did not respond to comment.

Bonaccorso apologized for the racist comments heard in the secret recordings but resisted calls to step down. He was last reelected in 2020 and his term expires next year.

The Clark Police Department has remained under the control of the Union County Prosecutor’s Office and Platkin’s office since July 2020. Platkin said both agencies took “painstaking care to thoroughly investigate all aspects of this case.”

The report recommends two men, Police Chief Pedro Matos and Sgt. Joseph Teston, be terminated. They have both been on paid leave since the inception of the investigation.

“Our findings render them unfit to serve as law enforcement, and I’m calling for their immediate termination,” Platkin said.

State investigators claim Matos failed to conduct an internal affairs investigation, did not self-report allegations of misconduct, and violated standards of conduct related to derogatory comments. Platkin also said Matos lied to investigators during internal affairs proceedings.

Investigators obtained a recording of Matos using a racial epithet to describe a group of children who said they were victims of a bias crime. The report calls his comment “reprehensible” with a “disturbing” context.

The recordings were first published by NJ Advance Media, which revealed the town’s $400,000 settlement.

The report also alleges that while on paid leave, Teston was arrested at a sporting event in New York for striking a stranger in the head with a glass bottle. The report doesn’t state the charge, which was eventually dropped, but says it would have been a charge of aggravated assault in New Jersey. His actions “demonstrate a troubling level of poor judgment and frankly, a lack of respect for human life,” the report states.

The report touches on allegations that Clark police improperly pull over Black drivers more than white motorists. The Division on Civil Rights, which is within the Attorney General’s Office, will review preliminary data revealing the stark racial disparities in traffic stops in the town. The report found that 44% of people arrested during traffic stops in Clark were Black. Ninety-three percent of the town’s residents are white.

Platkin noted township officials could face additional civil investigations. The state Office of Attorney Ethics, the state Comptroller’s Office, and the Division of Pension and Benefits will continue investigating aspects of the case.

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

State Sen. Vin Gopal wins reelection, handing New Jersey Democrats a key victory

Monmouth County Democrat Sen. Vin Gopal coasted to reelection in the 11th District Tuesday , nabbing nearly 60% of the vote over GOP candidate Steve Dnistrian and helping to flip control of both of the district’s Assembly seats for Democrats.

Gopal’s victory in this closely watched race came amid Republican attacks on his stances on offshore wind, crime, and LGTBQ issues in schools. His election to a third term in the state Senate dimmed GOP hopes that they could take control of the chamber.

“What we did tonight in Monmouth County is we drew political parties together to bring this massive landslide. If that doesn’t send a message to our opposition, I don’t know what will,” Gopal said to a crowd of about 300 supporters Tuesday night in Long Branch.

Gopal and his running mates —Assemblywomen-elect Margie Donlon and Luanne Peterpaul — were introduced by Senate President Nicholas Scutari (D-Union), who said the trio showed that the Republican-leaning 11th District “is no longer competitive.”

Gov. Phil Murphy also joined the festivities, whooping and cheering after the speeches wrapped up.

“You are rocking, baby!” Murphy told the crowd of energetic supporters

Throughout the night, as it became clear Gopal would win, his supporters chanted, “Vin with win!”

On the campaign trail, Gopal focused on abortion, tax relief, and increased school funding for local districts. He also highlighted his bipartisanship and his support from law enforcement.

Democrats said voters clearly rejected the GOP’s arguments on parental rights. Republicans had hoped legal battles between the Murphy administration and some Monmouth County school districts — battles focused on whether school employees should be required to tell parents if their children change their gender identity or sexuality — would boost the GOP in this district.

Murphy called Tuesday’s outcome a “huge validation of our collective agenda, and that has been extraordinary.”

“This should tell every Republican senator that when you’re running on culture wars, you’re not doing anything productive for residents on affordability, taxes, mental health. That should tell you that your message is not a good one,” Gopal said.

Republican Assemblywomen Marilyn Piperno and Kim Eulner lost their seats to Donlon and Peterpaul by about 7,000 votes each. Dnistrian, a businessman who has never held elected office, did not immediately comment on the election results.

“It’s a good night for Democrats,” Scutari said. “I feel great.”

This year, Democrats spent millions to defend Gopal’s seat and flip the two Assembly seats, making it one of the most expensive races in state history. In 2021, Gopal won reelection with 52% of the vote, but his running mates lost to Eulner and Piperno.

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

Election law watchdog to face hearing over allegations of homophobia, racism

The head of the state’s election law watchdog will face a public hearing next week over remarks he emailed to a staffer that state officials have characterized as homophobic.

Stephen Holden, a commissioner with the Election Law Enforcement Commission, announced next week’s public hearing during a Tuesday morning commission meeting, where he called the allegations aimed at the commission’s executive director, Jeff Brindle, “serious.” There are also allegations of racism, Holden said.

“If true, and if not true, it still requires a response from the commission because the commissioners have legislative responsibility and authority to address these kinds of concerns,” Holden said. “Most importantly, the commissioners believe in the due process requirements for all concerned.”

This comes as state lawmakers are mulling a bill that would, in part, give Gov. Phil Murphy the power to single-handedly appoint an entirely new ELEC board, a move intended to allow the Murphy administration to oust Brindle. The Senate approved the bill Monday, and it now awaits approval by the Assembly.

The Murphy administration’s clash with Brindle stems from an Oct. 11, 2022, email Brindle sent to an unknown commission employee about National Coming Out Day.

“Are you coming out? No Lincoln or Washington’s Birthday’s [sic] but we can celebrate national coming out day,” Brindle wrote, according to a copy of the email obtained through a public records request.

The state’s probe of the email stretches back to at least Nov. 4. The state Office of Equal Employment Opportunity received a complaint about Brindle’s “inappropriate comments of a homophobic nature,” interviewed an unidentified staffer, and reviewed the email sent by Brindle, according to a Nov. 4 letter obtained by the New Jersey Monitor.

Brindle’s email “on its face” is a violation of the state’s anti-discrimination policy, according to the letter, which is four pages and heavily redacted.

The letter was sent to ELEC commissioners on Nov. 14, according to emails reviewed by the New Jersey Monitor.

At Tuesday’s meeting, Holden said commissioners told Murphy administration officials they would “handle the allegations and make a decision.” They received a report with underlying facts less than two weeks ago, he said.

He said next week’s hearing would include testimony, an analysis of documents sent from Murphy’s office, and an examination of whether Brindle should face any discipline.

“That, I think, is consistent with our statutory responsibility. It’s consistent with our due process obligations. And it’s consistent with our ongoing efforts since we’ve been here to maintain the independence and bipartisanship and transparency of the things that are undertaken by the commission,” Holden added.

Brindle, who has worked for the Election Law Enforcement Commission since 1985 and been at its helm since 2009, claims in a lawsuit that Murphy and his aides are conspiring to interfere with the independence of the commission and seeking a way to get rid of him.

He alleges that the governor’s aides confronted him with the email and threatened to publicize it if he didn’t step down.

The public hearing will take place Tuesday at 1 p.m. at the commission’s office in Trenton.

The governor’s office declined to comment. The commission’s attorney did not immediately return a request for comment.


New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

Hit man hired by NJ political consultant sentenced to 20 years in prison

The admitted hit man who killed a New Jersey political consultant in 2014 was sentenced to 20 years in prison Thursday, marking the first person sentenced in a murder-for-hire plot that has transfixed the state’s political world.

During the hour-long sentencing hearing in federal court in Newark, Bomani Africa, 62, apologized for the murder of Michael Galdieri, who was found dead in his Jersey City home with multiple stab wounds to his neck, head, and upper torso in May 2014.

Africa, shackled and wearing a yellow jumpsuit with a long-sleeved white shirt underneath, said he is “truly remorseful.”

“Every day I sit and I replay back that incident. It’s the only way it played out. Would I have made different choices? Yes, now I did see that,” he said. “Again, I can never justify those actions. I’m taking full responsibility and acknowledge what I’ve done.”

Africa is one of two men who pleaded guilty to killing Galdieri. The other, Michael Bratsenis, is scheduled to be sentenced March 23.

Both men say they were hired by Sean Caddle, Galdieri’s business associate, to carry out the murder in exchange for $15,000. Caddle, a political consultant who played a major role in the campaigns of former state Sen. Ray Lesniak, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit murder in January 2022 and awaits sentencing.

Judge John Michael Vazquez said he had expected to sentence Africa to up to 26 years in prison but decided on 20 years because Africa admitted his guilt and has been cooperating with prosecutors.

Vazquez called himself skeptical that Africa is truly remorseful. He noted Africa did not confess to the murder until after federal officials confronted him with evidence of his guilt. The judge repeatedly called the murder plot a “difficult case” and described the crime as “depraved, debased, vile” and “heinous.”

Vazquez also noted Africa’s extensive criminal history that began when he was young and referenced a string of armed robberies Africa committed after murdering Galdieri.

“I don’t know how to put it into words — to get away with murder and then decide, let’s do some armed bank robberies. That shows a total lack of consciousness, empathy, or any type of normal human emotion,” Vazquez said.

The 2014 murder

Africa’s sentencing has revealed some details about the murder-for-hire plot that federal prosecutors have until now kept under wraps.

In 2014, Caddle met with Bratsenis — the two met working on a state Senate campaign together — and said he was aware of Bratsenis’ extensive criminal history. Apparently angry after believing Galdieri had been stealing money from him, Caddle hired Bratsenis to kill Galdieri.

Caddle paid Bratsenis between $2,000 and $4,000 upfront, and Bratsenis found a co-conspirator in Africa (the two had previously served together in prison).

On May 22, 2014, Galdieri opened the door to his Jersey City apartment to let the two men in. They stabbed him to death and then used gasoline to set the apartment ablaze.

The following day, Caddle met Bratsenis in the parking lot of an unnamed Elizabeth diner to pay him the remaining thousands for the job. Bratsenis and Africa split the $15,000.

Shortly after, the pair committed the bank robberies in Connecticut. Africa was arrested in 2015, and eventually both men confessed to Galdieri’s then-unsolved murder.

Africa faced a life sentence for his role. Prosecutors had called for a 15- to 18-year sentence, citing his cooperation with the government, according to sentencing materials unsealed by the court.

“Without Africa’s substantial assistance, I don’t think we’d be standing here,” said Executive Assistant U.S. Attorney Lee Cortes Jr.

Africa, a Paterson native, will be 82 when released and faces five years of additional supervision. He does not have to pay a fine or any restitution for the murder. He requested to be placed in a facility in North Carolina, where his family and son live.


New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

NJ governor ‘disgusted’ by abuse allegations — at women’s soccer team he co-owns: report

Gov. Phil Murphy called the details in a scathing investigative report alleging systemic abuse of the women’s soccer team he co-owns “disgusting, completely reprehensible, and completely unacceptable.”

But the governor declined to comment when asked whether he bears any responsibility for the alleged misconduct.

“I’ve not read the entirety of the report, but I’ve read enough of it and it’s disgusting,” Murphy said at an unrelated news conference Wednesday morning. “I hope the (National Women’s Soccer League) will get out ahead of this and will put reforms in place, put steps in place so that stuff like this could never, ever happen again.”

The U.S. Soccer Federation commissioned the investigation after stories published by The Athletic and The Washington Post revealed allegations of harassment and sexual abuse ignored by national soccer officials. The report was released Monday and paints a picture of verbal abuse and sexual misconduct running rampant in the culture of the National Women’s Soccer League.

A spokesperson for Gotham FC — Murphy’s soccer team, formerly known as Sky Blue — said it is reviewing the report and is “indebted” to the players and employees who shared their experiences.

“We are confident that their courage, and the future publication of the independent NWSL/NWSLPA joint investigation, will usher in player-focused reforms that will continue to enhance the safety, well-being, and success of our players and employees,” the team said in a statement. “Club leadership is committed to working with the NWSL and remains a strong advocate for those reforms.”

The yearlong investigation by the U.S. Soccer Federation, overseen by former acting Attorney General Sally Yates, included interviews with 200 people, including First Lady Tammy Murphy, another Gotham co-owner.

The 173-page report says investigators found abusive coaches were moved from team to team because league, federation, and team officials “failed to identify misconduct and inform others when necessary.” It largely focuses on three former coaches, including Christy Holly, who the report says was fired in 2017 as head coach of Sky Blue.

Tony Novo, the now-former Sky Blue general manager, told investigators the team fired Holly because he was “abusive to players” and because Holly “had a relationship with a player,” the report says.

But the team concealed the reasons for Holly’s departure in August 2017, creating what the report calls “another narrative” by issuing a press release thanking Holly for his work and saying both sides agreed to part ways “on good terms.”

The report does not mention the governor specifically and does not say whether the first lady knew about the allegations of abuse and misconduct. Holly could not be reached to comment.

After Holly left Sky Blue, he worked for the U.S. Soccer Federation and then was hired in August 2020 to coach Racing Louisville, the women’s soccer team in Kentucky. One of the Louisville team’s owners told The Equalizer in 2020 that he was “given a glowing reference from Sky Blue ownership” about Holly.

After reading this, Sky Blue’s CFO emailed the Murphys and Steven Temares — the Bed Bath & Beyond executive who co-owns the team with the governor and first lady — to say she “certainly did NOT give him a glowing review” and asked whether any of them had spoken to Racing Louisville’s owners.

The report does not say whether the Murphys responded. But Temares told investigators he gave “what could be considered a positive reference, but it would be in the ‘eye of the beholder,’” the report says.

While coaching Louisville’s team, Holly would send a player sexually explicit photos and demand others in return and grope her in public, the report says. In another instance, the player said Holly forced her to watch a video of a soccer game and groped her every time she made a bad pass in the video, according to the report.

Holly was fired from Racing Louisville in August 2021 after an investigation substantiated his inappropriate relationship with players and “unacceptable behavior.” The team didn’t provide a reason publicly.

The player Holly is accused of assaulting told investigators she wanted to remain anonymous, but “felt that the cryptic public messaging left others unsafe,” according to the report. She “remains concerned” that because of the lack of transparency, Holly is “still out there” and may be able to coach soccer again, the report says.

Holly told investigators he admitted sending and soliciting sexual photos to a player but denied any sexual conduct while coach of Racing Louisville.

Murphy, a Democrat who has owned the team since 2006, commended the “brave women” who came forward to tell their stories. He noted his family bought the team “because of our daughter … and that’s why we’re gonna stay in it.”

This isn’t the first time Sky Blue faced backlash during Murphy’s time as governor. In 2018, former players said they were living in squalor, with plastic bags for windows, ice baths in 50-gallon trash cans, and facilities with no showers.

New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

New Jersey governor says state will clarify sex education standards that riled GOP

As the uproar surrounding the state’s new sex education standards intensifies among some parents, Republican lawmakers, and conservative media, Gov. Phil Murphy defended the standards Wednesday but said the state will clarify what children will be learning in public schools starting in the fall.

Murphy blamed the controversy on partisan actors attempting to divide parents. The governor’s announcement came after a parade of GOP legislators blasted the new standards and proposed legislation that would bar any instruction on gender identity and sexual orientation to young students.

“I have directed my Department of Education to review the standards and provide further clarification on what age-appropriate guidelines look like for our students. My administration is committed to ensuring that all of our students are equipped to lead healthy, productive lives now and in the future,” Murphy said in a statement.

The controversy here comes as states nationwide seek to bar discussion of LGBTQ issues in the classroom, sparked by a new Florida law that limits instruction on gender and sexual orientiation.

The new New Jersey standards were adopted by the state Board of Education in June 2020 and are supposed to be implemented starting in September. They expand what students are taught about gender identity, sexual orientation, consent, and gender expression.

Parents are allowed to opt their children out of sex education lessons in New Jersey public schools.

In his statement, Murphy pointed to politicians who are “seeking to divide and score political points” by misrepresenting how far the new standards go. State Sen. Holly Schepisi (R-Bergen) last week shared sample sex education materials on Facebook that she said “go so far as unnecessarily sexualizing children.” Officials say those documents are an example of what schools can use, and are not curriculum. Murphy said the materials Schepisi shared “do not reflect the spirit of the standards.”

Murphy said it’s paramount for public schools to promote inclusivity and respect for all children, including LGBTQ students.

“In New Jersey, parents always have and always will have a say in their child’s education, which includes opting their child out of any health lesson that they would rather discuss in the privacy of their own home,” he said. “Any proposed educational content that is not age-appropriate should be immediately revised by local officials.”

Schepisi said she is happy Murphy will provide more information to parents who are confused about the new standards. But she disputed the charge that she is spreading misinformation, noting the documents she shared can be found on the state Department of Education website.

“Providing information to parents about what’s going on while the state gives a lack of guidance is not misinformation,’ she said. “Parents need to remain engaged and make sure their voices are appropriately heard.”

GOP senators have sent a letter to Murphy and state Senate President Nicholas Scutari (D-Union) asking for public hearings on the new standards and delayed implemention. In the letter, they note the expanded guidelines were adopted in June 2020, at the height of the pandemic.

Republicans and some parents have taken issue with the apparently graphic nature of the proposed standards, and the age at which topics like gender identity, sexual orientation, and anatomy may be taught.

State Sen. Vin Gopal (D-Monmouth), who chairs the Senate Education Committee, said he’s reviewed the documents at the heart of the controversy and hasn’t found anything that glaringly crosses a line. But he called on Murphy to reassure parents about the new standards.

Gopal called Murphy’s statement Wednesday a “step in the right direction.”

The Department of Education did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

Legal settlement in works over sham college set up by ICE

Federal immigration authorities have reached a potential settlement with hundreds of foreign nationals who enrolled at the University of Northern New Jersey, a fake university and elaborate scam set up by the federal government to crack down on student visa fraud.

The proposed settlement agreement, which needs final approval from a judge, would settle a class-action lawsuit filed by migrants who say they unknowingly enrolled at the sham university that was created as part of a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement sting, according to court documents.

The government would pay $450,000 in legal fees and not admit to any wrongdoing under the proposed deal.

Plaintiffs who saw their visas overturned after the sting was revealed may have their removal proceedings canceled by the Department of Homeland Security and be allowed to apply for new visas, or seek reinstatement to attend another school, if the deal is approved.

A court hearing is scheduled for May 2 at the U.S. District Court in Newark. An ICE spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The sting operation was revealed in 2016 by then-U.S. Attorney Paul Fishman, who announced the arrests of nearly two dozen brokers who recruited people to enroll in the fake university beginning in 2013 for the purpose of getting the “students” fraudulent visas. The brokers knew classes didn’t exist.

Most students claim they didn’t know the process to get the F-1 visa — student visas allowing people to complete their studies and travel freely outside the country — was illegal, according to their lawsuit. Still, the government terminated the immigration status of most of the foreign nationals, forcing them to return to their home countries or remain here to fight the immigration charges.

At the time of the arrests, the government said the operation was an attempt to combat visa fraud. A high-profile sham university case in 2011 resulted in more than 1,500 students, largely from India, seeking student visas for the uncredited (and now shuttered) Tri-Valley University without knowing the visas were fraudulent.

Elizabeth Montano, attorney for the New Jersey students, said the enrollees had no idea the visas they obtained were fraudulent. Students who visited the alleged school’s Cranford office spoke with agents disguised as administrators and secretaries.

“It was very hard for them to discover it was fake, because the government went to great lengths to make it seem like an institution,” she said in a phone interview from her office in Florida.

No learning took place at the university, no professors were hired, and no classes offered. The website has been scrubbed, but archived pages show it claimed to offer undergraduate and graduate degree programs in subjects ranging from business to health care management, and was advertised as an accredited school by the New Jersey Department of Education.

According to the lawsuit, the school even maintained a social media account, posting when it was closed for inclement weather or sharing wedding photos after two “alumni” were married. Government agents even made shirts for UNNJ “students.”

“The only thing lacking appears to be a reference to UNNJ’s men’s or women’s basketball team in the Final Four,” a judge wrote in a 2019 opinion.

ICE shut down the school in 2016 after the academic brokers were arrested for fraud, and immediately terminated all related student F-1 visas based on “fraudulent enrollment” at UNNJ, the suit states.

The plaintiffs say they were effectively collateral damage, and at one point federal prosecutors admitted the plaintiffs were victims of fraud.

Most of the 1,076 foreign nationals voluntarily left the country to avoid immigration proceedings or are currently awaiting hearings for an order of removal, Montano said. The fraudulent enrollment at UNNJ is a stain on their record, keeping them from applying to other U.S. schools or forcing them out of the country they worked hard to come to, she said.

The lawsuit alleges the plaintiffs’ due process rights were violated and says ICE improperly disregarded the Administrative Procedure Act, which requires federal agencies to provide legitimate reasons for their actions, in this case the overturning of their visas.

The case, first filed in Nov. 2016, was dismissed by the U.S. District Court in New Jersey in 2017. Montano appealed to the Third Circuit, which overturned the dismissal and remanded the case for further proceedings in August 2019.

Montano said while the government refuses to accept any liability for the troubles it’s caused to more than a thousand migrants, the potential of a settlement is a “beacon of hope that there are people out there who will fight for immigrants who have been wrongly harmed.”

She said the government did not provide a list of how many foreign nationals remain in the country or returned to their home nation, or how many reside in New Jersey. She said of the 100 people she’s been in contact with for the settlement, many live in or close to the Garden State.

This is the second known fake university set up by the U.S. government in an attempt to catch visa fraud. Authorities revealed in 2019 the University of Farmington in Michigan was also a sham operation, which led to the arrests of 161 students and the deportation of 600 people.

“It all boils down to, the government thinks what they’re doing is fine — and we don’t agree with them — but they believe they have the power to keep doing this. It’s awful,” Montano said. “The settlement, at least, goes to show the government can’t get away with doing this.”


New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.

Dem leader slams ‘desperate’ New Jersey Republicans for vaccine protest that delayed voting

New Jersey Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin criticized his Republican colleagues for their “desperate efforts to delay important legislation” after a Monday voting session that lasted for about 11 hours.

Several GOP lawmakers stretched the last voting day of 2021 into a marathon over their objections to a policy that requires them to show proof of vaccination or a clean COVID test to enter the Statehouse. Coughlin (D-Middlesex) in a statement called the policy “fair and sensible,” and noted COVID cases are rising in New Jersey and the region.

The lengthy day came in part because remote voting takes longer than in-person voting, and about 20 lawmakers — Democrats and Republicans — voted remotely. But a handful of Republican Assembly members also stalled voting on many bills by making long-winded comments, asking seemingly pointless questions, complaining they couldn’t hear, or saying they had technological difficulties during their calls into the session.

Throughout the day, Coughlin became weary of the Republican lawmakers’ tactics. Their attempts to filibuster the proceedings included talking about different types of corn, recalling beach days, discussing their children’s opinion on school security drills, and reading directly from the text of bills.

“You guys are running out of things to say,” Coughlin said at one point.

As Coughlin sought to speed up the voting process, he began to quickly open and close the option for lawmakers to comment on bills. When Republicans shouted at Coughlin that they weren’t being given the chance to speak, Coughlin told them they should have asked sooner.

Throughout the 11-hour session, technical difficulties existed on both ends. The clerk couldn’t hear votes being cast, lawmakers were speaking over each other, and some apparently couldn’t figure out how to put themselves on mute.

As the night dragged on, more and more lawmakers left the building and joined the session over the phone, adding to the delays. The session, which began at about 1:20 p.m., ended just after midnight.

Assembly sessions typically don’t last longer than a few hours, depending on how many bills are scheduled. Lawmakers ultimately acted on more than 100 bills Monday.

In the state Senate, which started its session nearly two hours late, voting concluded by 5 p.m. Republican senators all showed their vaccine cards or negative test results without issue, though during the session some said legislative leaders should consider natural immunity.

Coughlin applauded Assembly members who showed up to vote and complied with Statehouse vaccine rules “with respect for their colleagues, staff, and the public.” When a group of Republicans entered the building without complying with the vaccine policy during the last voting session, Coughlin criticized them for putting the health of their colleagues and their families at risk.

Confirmed COVID cases in New Jersey have topped 1.1 million since the pandemic started, with 28,730 COVID-associated deaths, according to state data.

“Despite the desperate efforts of several members of the minority party to delay important legislation, we succeeded in passing major mental health legislation for our students, took steps on gun safety, honored our service members and veterans, furthered our support for economic development in Atlantic City, and kept commitments to safeguard our natural resources,” Coughlin said.


New Jersey Monitor is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. New Jersey Monitor maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Terrence McDonald for questions: info@newjerseymonitor.com. Follow New Jersey Monitor on Facebook and Twitter.