Since then, milbloggers – ultraconservative Russian internet users who comment on the war in Ukraine – have been up in arms about what they call the failure of the Russian general staff to protect this Texan, whom they considered to be one of their own, the Wall Street Journal reported. “‘Texas' was killed! In the same way that they let so many of our brothers die" in the Donbas, was the reaction of Thirteenth, the nickname on Telegram of former Russian soldier Yegor Guzenko.
Faced with this criticism, Moscow has been very discreet about the circumstances surrounding Bentley's death. His wife, a Russian citizen, had not heard from him since early April, and Bentley, who was usually very active on social media, had stopped posting. Members of his former combat unit in the Donbas finally announced his death. No official confirmation was provided by Moscow.
“We will probably never know what really happened, but the information circulating online suggests that the most likely scenario is that he was killed by Russian soldiers who mistook him for an American spy,” said Stephen Hall, a Russia specialist at the University of Bath.
Putin's perfect little soldier
Bentley, 60, would probably never have believed that he could be mistaken for an agent in Washington's pay. Since leaving his native Texas in 2014, Bentley did everything he could to adopt both the Russian way of life and the most "Putinist" rhetoric possible. He married a Russian woman, converted to the Orthodox faith, obtained Russian citizenship and bought “a little house with a big garden” in the Donetsk region.
His final decade as a faithful servant of the Russian cause marks the final chapter in a life that had been anything but quiet.
Bentley began his career as a self-proclaimed “socialist” student in the very conservative state of Texas. Then, at the age of 20, he joined the military, and in the 1980s was posted to a base in Germany.
Returning to the U.S. a few years later, he first worked as a bartender at the resort town of South Padre Island, Texas. In 1990, he moved to Minneapolis, Minnesota, to become a lumberjack and then an activist for the legalization of cannabis. His commitment to the cause even led him to run as a U.S. Senate candidate for the Grassroots Party, which opposes drug prohibition.
Having failed to get elected, he decided to convert from socialism to communism and from cannabis activist to cannabis dealer. The latter activity got him into trouble with the law and he was sentenced to five years in prison.
Six months of fighting, ten years of correspondence
After serving his sentence, Bentley moved to Austin, Texas, to become a landscaper in the early 2010s. This new path gave him ample time to lose himself in pro-Russian news websites. These portals – the same ones that were later used in 2016 to try to influence the US election – present a propaganda-soaked version of Ukraine’s 2013 pro-European Euromaidan movement.
This alternative reality convinced Bentley that the 2014 Russian invasion of Crimea, followed by the fighting in the Donbas represented a “war against the pro-Nazi elements stationed in Kyiv”, the Texas Monthly wrote in a 2019 investigation report. He thus became one of the first American “victims” of the great Russian propaganda operation aimed at destabilizing the US.
In 2014, he moved to Donetsk, where he joined the Vostok battalion, one of the main pro-Russian units in the Donbas. But he would only fight for six months before becoming “Texas” and the “Donbass Cowboy”, nicknames he used on social media and on his regular appearances on the Russian news outlet Sputnik. He then spent ten years crisscrossing the Donbas as a “war correspondent” for various pro-Putin and ultra-nationalist websites and media.
At the start of the major Russian offensive in 2022, the “Donbass Cowboy” stated on the VKontakte social media service that the Russians “might stop in Kiev, or we might go as far as the English Channel. Maybe we'll even liberate the United States!”
Since then, he has repeated the Russian narrative on the Ukraine invasion, maintaining that NATO, particularly the US, was to blame for “forcing” Moscow to defend itself in Ukraine.
As a disciple of triumphant Putinism with a strong Texan accent, Bentley “was very useful for the Kremlin's propaganda, especially aimed at the Russian public”, said Jeff Hawn, a Russia specialist at the London School of Economics.
According to Hall, Bentley embodied an important facet of Moscow's discourse.
“Russell Bentley was living proof that Russian ideology had also been emulated in the West and even in the United States,” he said.
A valuable voice
The “Donbass Cowboy” was not the only Westerner to side with Russia. But “there is no reliable data”, on their numbers, said Hawn.
“As far as the Americans are concerned, there are probably no more than a handful of them, often with a criminal record", he added.
One example is Wilmer Puello-Mota, a former American soldier who decided to fight alongside the Russians in Ukraine last January – a few days before his trial for possession of child pornography was due to begin.
In Moscow's eyes, Russell Bentley had one advantage over the other Western fighters: he was very comfortable in front of the cameras. This, Hall said, is one of the reasons why milbloggers have been up in arms since his death.
“They regret that the army failed to protect one of the few American voices that could help them take their message of the war of civilizations beyond Russia's borders,” he said.
Another reason is that “these ultra-nationalists can use his death to continue criticizing Sergei Shoigu's ministry of defense, which they blame for not conducting the war in Ukraine properly,” Hawn said.
Bentley's death would be proof that Russia’s general staff has absolutely no control over the Russian-occupied territories in the Donbas.
“What is happening there is even more opaque to outside observers than what is happening in Russia,” Hall said.
(This article is a translation of the original in French.)
