Download Our App
Fetterman’s poll collapse has no historical match as he threatens to quit Dems: data guru
Senator John Fetterman (D-PA) speaks to reporters, weeks into the continuing U.S. government shutdown, in Washington, D.C. on Oct. 21, 2025. REUTERS/Kylie Cooper

Fetterman’s poll collapse has no historical match as he threatens to quit Dems: data guru

Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) floated the idea of leaving the Democratic Party, but CNN’s chief data analyst says his colleagues won’t lose any sleep over it.

Fetterman suggested he might quit the party if Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) unseats Chuck Schumer as Senate Democratic leader, but Harry Enten said that threat is landing with a thud after this month’s midterm landslide put Democrats on track for 56 Senate seats.

“They would say good riddance,” Enten said. “Good riddance to this guy.”

Then he pulled up a chart of Fetterman’s standing with Pennsylvania Democrats.

“Sometimes a slide says it all, and you literally get the inverse on it,” Enten said.

Two years ago, Fetterman’s net popularity among Democrats in his home state was plus-56 points, but now it’s minus-56 – a 112-point drop.

“In just two years’ time, Pennsylvania Democrats despise, they hate, hate, hate John Fetterman,” Enten said. “So this idea that he would move and make the majority go from 56 seats to 55 seats — real scary.”

Enten said the numbers look even worse for Fetterman’s reelection prospects next to senators who lost their own party’s primaries. Those senators’ ratings ranged from plus-15 points for former New Hampshire Sen. Bob Smith down to minus-15 for Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), who lost her 2010 primary but held her seat with a write-in campaign.

“John Fetterman is at minus-56 points; he is literally off the page,” Enten said. “Simply put, there is no historical analogy that quite fits the moment right now of just how unpopular John Fetterman is.”

He added that a senator at zero, with as many voters approving as disapproving, would normally be in trouble in a primary. Unless “we’re literally moved to planet Krypton,” he said, Fetterman “is almost certainly going to lose that primary.”

The split with Van Hollen centers on U.S. policy toward Israel. Fetterman is one of the war’s fiercest backers in Congress, and Van Hollen has been a leading critic.

Enten said voters are on Van Hollen’s side, showing a poll that found 74 percent of Democrats nationwide, and 71 percent of Pennsylvania Democrats, say the U.S. is too supportive of Israel. So do 52 percent of all Pennsylvania voters and 51 percent of voters nationally.

“No matter which way you slice this apple, voters and Democratic voters in particular are not with the senator from Pennsylvania,” Enten said. “They’re with the senator from Maryland.”

Fetterman, he concluded, is “very much on the outside looking in.”

- YouTube youtu.be

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?

VOTE NOW
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?