Download Our App
Samuel Alito is right to be terrified

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito attend a private ceremony for retired Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor on Dec. 18, 2023. Jacquelyn Martin/Pool via REUTERS/

Opinion

Samuel Alito is right to be terrified

The single most openly political Supreme Court justice — and one has to work hard for that title — just used a ton of political juice to complain... about the new political landscape and, of course, what that means to him and the political Court.

The irony would leak with laughter were the subject not so serious.

There used to be an old legal maxim, "Don't tell me about the case, tell me which judge." But with Samuel Alito (and thus also Clarence Thomas), a new mantra may as well emerge: "Don't tell me about the law or judge, tell me about the parties."

With Alito, the rule breaks down with such simplicity as to be open to all: Government v. Regular Citizen (Non-Billionaire)? Government wins. National Corporation v. Regular Citizen? Corporation wins; National Corporation v. Government? National Corporation wins. Literally "Any Party" v. Charity, Foundation, Trust? "Charity and poors" lose. You see how it goes.

The temptation might be to shout out, "Yeah, just like any conservative justice," but that doesn't hold. Some conservative justices look for conservative issues in and among parties to impact conservative causes down the road. Alito worries about the party in front of him. He is a special justice, one who will work out down-the-road kinks when, well, down the road.

Enter the Federalist Society, an organization as politically befitting for Alito as any in the country, one that has handpicked the group of acceptable appointees during Donald Trump's term. On Thursday night, Alito did what no Justice would have done 30 years ago, and gave a speech at the elite club to complain that the new blue Congress could "shut the lights out at the Supreme Court" because... it's so political.

He went on to say Congress could "stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities. And there are many, many, many other things that they can do, or at least try to do."

Justice? Don't you dare tempt us with a good time.

But up with all this Alito will not put, and thus he delivered his hammering point while hitting his political thumb, “So, it is important to preserve the independence of the judiciary.” He then noted that the Constitution would never be the same.

Well.

As anyone might guess, Congress is only a concern to Alito when Democrats wrestle power. After all, were it not for senatorial political gamesmanship, liberals would have at least two more justices on the Court. Republicans versus Dems, Republicans win, as Alito would see it.

To be fair, his ultimate conclusion — that Congress could toy with the Court — happens to be right; it sure did so under Obama, and thus can damn sure now.

Yes, yes, the House can refuse to fund the Supreme Court's electric bill, defund the law clerks who actually do all the work, and most anything else to be the proverbial pain in the posterior, enough so as to "encourage" retirements. Certainly Alito knows he's got years with a Democratic Senate (having 56 seats makes the map excruciatingly hard for the other side to flip in any given election.) It'll be a while before Dems allow a SCOTUS appointment. Perhaps his retirement situation just got infinitely more difficult than if he had declared before the election, or now, in an attempt to ram it through. He is cranky.

But let's talk about what we're really talking about. Alito is afraid that, come two years from now, Democrats will push to pack the Court with at least two more seats. The ideal has a ton of appeal and a ton of danger, and I should know, having traveled the country four summers ago reporting from a tour to gain support for packing the Court.

The situation's appeal comes from balancing the court, obviously. But there is the added advantage of allowing the SCOTUS to take more cases (a good thing). After all, there is no rule that says all nine justices have to hear a case. If the court expanded to 11 or 13 justices, major life-changing issues would be heard by all, and some more narrow or technical cases might be sent to a seven-justice or even a five-justice panel.

The disadvantage, of course, is the disadvantage to doing anything so aggressive when facing Republicans. If Democrats expand the Court to 11 and balance it out, Republicans could, in turn, when in power, expand it to 33 ultra-right-wing justices. Perhaps some fractional exaggeration there. Perhaps.

But Alito is definitely less concerned with the lights or his salary than he is with diluting his vote by expanding the Court.

The story gets a little bit sad when one concentrates on the fact that the Republicans played the real political game to get the advantage, whereas the Democrats might play politics only in response, and only in proportion to what the GOP did — balancing the Court, not stuffing it with 15 35-year-old liberals. You have seen similar situations before; in fact, the dynamic has come to define the post-Clinton era.

But Alito doesn't care about even the obviousness of it all. He is the one who reversed Roe, writing in effect that Roe was wrongly decided all along. He, Alito, knew better than every justice before him and he alone would fix it. Fairly political of him.

But he just knew: Government versus a women's health organization? Pffft.

Jaosn Miciak is a Raw Story columnist, past editor at Occupy Democrats, author, attorney, consultant, and single parent girldad. Please follow on Bluesky and he can be reached at jasonmiciak@gmail.com

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?

VOTE NOW
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?