Sheriff: Jobless SC mom who 'wanted to be free' suffocated young sons, faked drowning accident
Broke, jobless and berated by her mother for her failings, Shaquan Duley killed her young sons, then strapped their lifeless bodies into their car seats before rolling the vehicle into a South Carolina river in a desperate cover-up attempt, authorities said.
On Wednesday, the 29-year-old mother was expected to appear before an Orangeburg County judge for an arraignment hearing on two murder charges.
Duley's attorney, Carl B. Grant, said Wednesday morning he hasn't had the opportunity to review any of the evidence against her.
"We want everybody to keep an open mind and to understand that they don't know the whole story," said Grant, who would not say what he discussed in his first talk with his client.
Investigators were not convinced when Duley said her sons, ages 2 years and 18 months, drowned after her car plunged into a river. She ultimately confessed to killing the toddlers, they say Ã¢â‚¬â€ not by dumping them in the water but by suffocating them earlier with her own hands.
"She truly felt, 'If I don't have these toddlers, I can be free,' " Orangeburg County Sheriff Larry Williams said at a news conference Tuesday. "I think she was fed up with her mother telling her she couldn't take care of the children, or she wasn't taking care of the children and just wanted to be free."
Duley's sister, Adriane Duley, said Wednesday she doesn't think Williams' portrayal of events has been unfair.
"I don't feel that he's dragging my sister through the mud," she said outside the home she shared with her mother, sister, niece and nephews. "I actually feel that he's speaking fairly compassionately on her part."
Adriane Duley said her family has been overwhelmed by the media attention and cannot even do day-to-day tasks such as taking out the trash or getting the mail, much less plan two funerals and grieve for their loss.
"I've had enough," she said. "My family needs their privacy. We need to grieve and we can't do that with a whole bunch of cameras in our faces."
Coroner Samuetta Marshall told several media outlets Tuesday the older boy had defensive wounds that suggested he had been in a struggle.
Monday's tragic scene of a car found submerged with children's bodies inside was eerily reminiscent of the 1994 case of another South Carolina mother, Susan Smith, who is serving life in prison for killing her young sons by rolling her car into a lake in the northwest part of the state.
Duley lived with her sons, a 5-year-old daughter and her mother in a rented home along a street filled with boarded-up, abandoned houses in Orangeburg, about 35 miles south of Columbia, South Carolina's capital. Out of work and estranged from the children's father, Duley relied on her mother to support her and her children, Williams said.
The sheriff said Duley told investigators her mother constantly harangued her about her failures as a mother and inability to provide for her family financially.
Leaving her daughter at the house after a night of arguing with her mother Sunday, Duley strapped 2-year-old Devean C. Duley and 18-month-old Ja'van T. Duley into their car seats and drove the boys to an Orangeburg motel several miles from where she lived.
Late that night, in a corner room tucked at the back of the rundown, one-story motel complex, Duley suffocated the boys with her hands, Williams said. On Tuesday, red evidence tape still sealed the door to that room.
Distraught and not knowing what to do, Duley strapped the boys into their car seats and drove to a boat ramp some 10 miles away, investigators said. They said Duley rolled her car into the water, watching as it sank into the slow-moving current, then took off on foot.
Without a cell phone, Duley walked some distance down a country road, flagging down a passing motorist to call the Highway Patrol at 6:15 a.m. Monday.
A man on the tape of a 911 call released by the Orangeburg Emergency Medical Services on Wednesday tries to give an operator the car's location and information about the children. He can be heard asking someone else at the scene for specifics during the call.
When the operator asks "Do you happen to know how old these children are?" the man asks someone at the scene: "How old they are honey?" He then tells the operator: "One and two."
When asked whether the woman driving was also trapped in the car, the man responds, "No, she got out some kind of way."
The children were still strapped in their child seats when divers found them and recovered their bodies about 45 minutes after being called to the scene.
Duley was initially charged only with leaving the scene of an accident, but Williams said deputies knew there was more to the story than she was telling. There were no skid marks on the road leading to the water, and no obvious signs of a crash.
"We felt that the story she was telling us wasn't factual," Williams said.
Williams said Duley eventually admitted to a female deputy after hours of questioning that she killed the boys, citing the pressures both of parenthood and those she felt from her own mother. He said Duley expressed little remorse about the deaths.
"I think that the opportunity presented itself and she reacted to whatever condition presented itself for her to get rid of the children," Williams said.
Funeral services for both boys have been scheduled for 11 a.m. Friday at St. Paul Baptist Church in Orangeburg, officials with Simmons Funeral Home, which is handling arrangements, said Wednesday.
The state agency responsible for child welfare in South Carolina said it has had no involvement with Duley. Williams said the 5-year-old girl is now staying with Duley's mother.
The boys' deaths stunned another young single mother who lived near the struggling family.
"I can never imagine it getting that bad to where you just feel that that's the end of it," said Shannon Stamos, 22, who has two children about the same ages as Duley's sons. "There are so many other families that are willing to take on kids nowadays ... for somebody that feels they need freedom, or whatever the case may be."
In the 1994 case, Smith left her 3-year-old and 14-month-old sons strapped in their car seats as she rolled her car into a lake in Union County. Smith, who is white, initially claimed a black man had carjacked her and drove off with the children.
Associated Press Writers Jack Jones and Page Ivey in Columbia, S.C., contributed to this report.
Source: AP News
Mochila insert follows...