Download Our App
'No demolition': Judge defangs Trump's Kennedy Center threats with demand for secret texts
Fencing surrounds the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, D.C., US, October 5, 2026. This year's Kennedy Center Honors will be held at Washington's Capital One Arena as the Trump administration faces legal and congressional challenges over plans to demolish the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, a center spokesperson said on Friday. REUTERS/Eric Lee

'No demolition': Judge defangs Trump's Kennedy Center threats with demand for secret texts

A federal judge refused to allow the demolition of the Kennedy Center and demanded Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s texts in the lawsuit over President Donald Trump’s plan to close it.

U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper heard arguments Thursday in Washington on the Trump administration’s request to lift the order he issued in May blocking the two-year closure. He did not rule from the bench.

Cooper ordered the Justice Department to give him withheld records by Friday for private review, including messages between Lutnick and Kennedy Center Executive Director Matt Floca.

“The exact words of the judge bear repeating: ‘No demolition.’ There’s a court order in place,” Norm Eisen, a lawyer for Rep. Joyce Beatty (D-OH), told reporters outside the courthouse after the hearing.

“We have learned the lesson … from the demolition of the East Wing, from the takedown of those hundreds of trees at the East Potomac Golf Course: You need a court order in place,” Eisen said.

Beatty, who sits on the center’s board as a member of Congress, sued last December after the board Trump chairs voted to add his name to the center. In May, Cooper ruled the name was added illegally.

“The whole reason we went to court and we got an order from the judge that is on the books was after the president was on Air Force One and was photographed with placards,” said Nathaniel Zelinsky of the Washington Litigation Group, Beatty’s co-counsel.

Trump was photographed in September looking at a placard that appeared to read “Kennedy Center DEMOLISHED.” The next day, Cooper ordered the center to give 30 days’ notice before any major changes, including demolition.

The administration has fought to keep the Lutnick messages from Beatty. Trump formally invoked executive privilege, a president’s power to keep some advice confidential, over records about the closure and the center’s finances.

The withheld records include roughly 180 texts between Floca and Lutnick, who holds no formal position at the center. Beatty’s lawyers have described Lutnick as Trump’s “go-between.”

“They have been hiding basic information from the congresswoman and her colleagues ever since,” Zelinsky said, referring to Beatty’s court fight in March to obtain records about the closure plans.

The Justice Department urged Cooper to let the closure proceed. Government lawyers said in a filing that the center has become “dangerously dilapidated and decrepit,” with part of a ceiling collapsing in early September, according to The Associated Press.

“I think the judge was skeptically questioning at the very end of the hearing when the government said that whatever the chair, who happens to be the president of the United States, says is irrelevant,” Eisen said.

Congress set aside roughly $257 million last year for maintenance on the main building at the center’s request, an AP review found.

“Donald Trump doesn’t wanna do anything unless his name can be fixed back on that building, and I believe he’s holding those dollars because he knows it’s unlawful,” Beatty explained on Thursday.

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?

VOTE NOW
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?