No, a high-ranking conservative did not try to take out MAGA’s newest sticker-selling superstar’s aide, but you wouldn’t know it from his successful congressional campaign, a lawsuit contends.
New York Conservative Party chairman Gerard Kassar is readying for legal battle against Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino (R-NY), the rapping and boxing sensation best known for funding the majority of a $17 million campaign that ended with an acceptance speech in which he called multiple people “a------” in front of a little girl.
That campaign began with, and was defined by, another alarming comment: that somebody had cut the brakes of Constantino’s aide’s car in a failed assassination attempt — and Kassar was to blame, the lawsuit contends.
“The call threatening to kill me, it turns out, was made by the same scumbag … New York Conservative Party Chairman Jerry Kassar,” Constantino said in a 2025 campaign speech, according to the lawsuit.
“I talked to [a] well-known political advisor and he said to me: Anthony, I’ve heard a lot of crazy s--- in my life but I never heard a politician say ‘kill you’ before — you should take this seriously.”
The claim of the Sticker Mule CEO, who many in the party consider a superstar because of the brash way he won Rep. Elise Stefanik's New York seat as dozens of other Republicans lost around the country, appeared in music videos, campaign ads, X posts and stump speeches.
But it stands in stark contrast with local police records, reviewed by Raw Story, that show an unsubstantiated report of criminal mischief — and officers who said the only people raising the specter of attempted murder were Constantino and his aide.
The controversy stems from a recorded audio of Kassar’s telephone conversation with Constantino in 2024.
Constantino, a Democrat at the time, wanted Kassar’s blessing to run in a special election to replace Stefanik, then planning to accept President Donald Trump’s since-rescinded nomination as U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations.
Kassar told the professional boxer and sticker company CEO he wasn’t interested — and in no uncertain terms.
“Telling us you’re going to run in November is just a bigger reason why we intend to kill you,” Kassar says in audio Constantino shared on X in June 2025.
“If you get knocked out of the special [election]…and you tell us you’re going to run in November, then we’re going to do everything in our power to make sure you’re destroyed before you get to November.”
These words have been haunting Kassar ever since.
Kassar’s attorneys say that the chairman, a lifelong Brooklynite, was just telling it straight in a colloquial tone — and that Constantino knew it, court records show.
They say Constantino’s tone was polite as he asked clarifying questions and that he called Kassar again in January 2025 for another “amicable” chat.
Then suddenly, in a speech posted to X on June 13, 2025, Constantino began telling would-be constituents the New York Conservative Party chairman had tried to murder his aide Paul Antonelli by having the brakes of his car cut, according to the complaint.
Constantino played the audio clip for would-be constituents in Amsterdam, New York, during a speech that compared his aide’s alleged brush with death to the failed assassination attempt on Trump in July 2024, the complaint contends.
“I can’t imagine how bad it was for Paul to be the victim of an attempted murder,” Constantino said, according to the complaint and the then-candidate's X post.
“I tried to joke it off…telling Paul if you think about it, this really speaks highly of you, they only try to kill the best. He’s in an elite club now, along with the President.”
Soon the allegation against Kassar was appearing in campaign ads and on stickers sold on Sticker Mule, Constantino’s website, according to the complaint.
Kassar’s words also appear in a MAGA-themed music video called “New Blood” from DVS 7.0, Jesus AOK and KOZI-19, replete with Trump signs, American flags and crosses.
“NY Conservative Party Chairman Gerard Kassar threatened to kill me and my aide's brake lines were subsequently cut in an attempted homicide,” the video caption reads.
“As a result, I will spend $3 million to bring New Blood into the NY Conservative and Republican parties.”
Amsterdam Police Department reports tell a different story — not one that includes an attempted homicide.
On April 14, 2025, Antonelli filed a “criminal mischief” complaint that he’d been forced to roll to a stop at a rest area after his Ford Explorer’s brakes failed on a New York thruway, police records show.
Antonelli told the police a mechanic told him the brake cable had been cut, but does not appear to have presented evidence of this claim, according to the police report and Kassar’s lawsuit.
Antonelli argued his work for Constantino might have made him a target, but the only evidence investigating Officer Corey Rust was able to find were oil spots on the aides’ driveway, and the case was closed, the police report shows.
Rust then clarified to Kassar’s attorney Mark Luccarelli in July that he had found no evidence of an attempted hit, police records show.
“Paul believed that because of the conversation, Gerald [sic] Kassar may have had something to do with the damaged brake lines to his vehicle but again did not provide any factual information supporting this,” Rust wrote in a police report.
Rust also denied Constantino’s claim that he’d received a call from an officer who said, “the brake lines were indeed cut, someone tried to kill Paul,” according to the complaint.
“This officer has never had any contact with Anthony Constantino,” wrote Rust. “The allegations were false.”
Another Amsterdam Police Department officer, Christopher Cuddy, added that he’d asked Antonelli for any further information about the damage to his brakes.
“Antonelli stated that he believed Gerard Kassar was responsible for the damage to his break [sic] lines,” Cuddy wrote. “Antonelli was advised that the case was closed pending the development of further information.”
News reports show this was not Antonelli’s first contact with Amsterdam police.
A Mother Jones profile of Constantino notes Antonelli was arrested on grand larceny charges in 2020 after being accused of stealing $47,000 from a youth baseball league he presided over — and subsequently pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor.
Meanwhile, Constantino’s attorneys contend their client’s claims were fair game and Kassar was never defamed.
“These are not matters of interpretation — they are Chairman Kassar's exact recorded words,” they write in response to the complaint.
“Chairman Kassar cannot dispute the timeline surrounding the brake lines. The undisputed facts show that Antonelli’s brake lines were severed approximately three (3) days after he published harsh criticism of Kassar.”
The $250,000 defamation case, filed in July 2025, was stayed to allow Constantino to run for office, but is gearing up again now that Constantino has won the right to represent upstate New York in Congress, court records show.
Kassar’s attorneys on Monday told the judge overseeing the case that Constantino lawyers refused on Nov. 13 to schedule a deposition, even after their client won the campaign that stayed proceedings, court records show.
“Constantino’s attorneys once again indicated that no matter how many times we propose new dates, Mr. Constantino will not voluntarily produce himself at any time in the foreseeable future, despite having no legal basis for such a refusal,” wrote attorney Christian Browne.
“Mr. Constantino’s status as a politician does not relieve him from his obligations to comply with the law.”
Kassar is not the only conservative to express frustration with Constantino.
While Roger Stone, the former Trump adviser and convicted felon, has supported Constantino’s campaign, another Republican complained he was “by far the worst candidate I ever encountered.”
That’s Bruce Blakeman, the Republican who failed to unseat Democrat New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, and has since told Constantino he wants to physically hurt him.
In newly revealed texts, Constantino urged Blakeman to break with Kassar and New York Republican State Committee chairman Ed Cox.
“If you were tough and smart you would come out against Kassar and Cox,” Constantino wrote. “You sound very weak right now and citizens don’t like weak.”
Blakeman replied, “After the election you and I can get in the ring and find out who is tougher.”
Raw Story requested comment from Constantino's campaign and his attorney, but did not receive an immediate response.