Make fun of the 'Million MAGA March' all you want — white supremacy has not been defeated
Last Saturday, between 10,0000 to 15,000 supporters of Donald Trump, including right-wing street thugs, "militia" members, neo-Nazis and neo-Confederates, Klansmen, and other extremists gathered in Washington for the "Million MAGA March" in support of their soon-to-be deposed leader.
Trump's acolytes at the Million MAGA March did not wear Klan hoods, robes, and other regalia — today's "professional" white supremacists prefer tan khaki pants, golf shirts and MAGA hats — but they share the Klan's core values and beliefs. Most central of those is the credo that America should be a country where white people are the dominant, most important, and most powerful group, accorded special rights and privileges. It should be no surprise that the Ku Klux Klan formally endorsed Donald Trump's presidency in 2016.
On social media and elsewhere, the Million MAGA March was mocked as a "failure" and another sign that Trump's base of support is weakening. Trump and his marchers were also deemed to be "losers". Other observers perceived the low turnout at the march as evidence that right-wing political street gangs, QAnon conspiracists, white supremacist groups and other Trump cult members are now in "disarray" or experiencing "low morale" because of Joe Biden's victory in the 2020 election.
For many people, it feels good to deride and lampoon Trump and his followers after their electoral defeat. Such emotions are understandable, given the immense pain that Trump and his movement have caused so many people these last four or so years.
Biden's landslide victory also creates a communal feeling of joy — members of the "Resistance" feel reaffirmed in the righteousness of their struggle, knowing that they were in fact legion and not alone.
On the most basic level, Donald Trump and his followers are easy targets for Schadenfreude and other forms of mockery. Trump is a wannabe professional wrestling villain and fake billionaire, as well as a useful idiot for Vladimir Putin and other authoritarians. He is a man possessed by delusions of grandeur who lives in his own alternate reality. Trump's rank-and-file followers are the very definition of the rabble the framers warned of more than 200 years ago, who do not realize that their leader is a thoroughly corrupt con man who feels only contempt for them.
That may all be true, but Trump's power to inspire violence should never be underestimated. Last Saturday night following the MAGA march, Donald Trump's political thugs provoked numerous confrontations with anti-fascists, Black Lives Matter supporters and others deemed to be "the enemy". On Saturday, Trump exalted this lawbreaking and barbarism on Twitter:
ANTIFA SCUM ran for the hills today when they tried attacking the people at the Trump Rally, because those people aggressively fought back. Antifa waited until tonight, when 99% were gone, to attack innocent #MAGA People. DC Police, get going — do your job and don't hold back!!!
In a fundraising email sent on Monday, Trump continued to cheer on violence by his followers:
The silent Fake News media is truly the Enemy of the People! They are ignoring the Radical Left ANTIFA SCUM assaulting Trump supporters, who are proudly (and peacefully!) showing support for their favorite President.However, this doesn't come as any surprise — this is what Biden's America would look like.
The Left HATES YOU. They want to keep you DOWN and keep you SILENT because they are afraid of YOU and everything you stand for.
We can't let them get away with this. It's important that EVERY Patriot comes together at a time like this to send a united message that we will not stand for their radical actions any longer.
The Million MAGA March would end with 21 people arrested. Eight guns were confiscated by police. One man was hospitalized after being stabbed multiple times by right-wing street thugs. Two police officers were also treated for injuries.
This relatively minor outbreak of street violence at Trump's MAGA march is but a preview of what will likely happen all across the country in the weeks before Trump is removed from office in January. Right-wing political violence will most certainly continue and escalate in response to Joe Biden's presidency.
At NPR, Hannah Allam offers a specific warning:
Extremism analysts say the hastily organized attempt to gather the right under a single banner — for now it's "Stop the Steal" — is a chilling reminder of the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017. They say the thousands who showed up Saturday represent countless others who followed via social media, donated to travel funds or watched from home — on Fox News, for those with a foot still in reality, on InfoWars-style channels, for the fully inculcated.Brian Levin, a California-based hate and extremism researcher, called the Million MAGA March the debut of the pro-Trump insurgency, a preview of the "multiheaded Hydra" of far-right opposition expected when President-elect Joe Biden takes office.
Levin said the loyalists who showed up in Washington are only the public face. The bigger concern, he said, are the extremists "whose names we don't know yet," plotting in the shadows.
"Irrespective of the crowd," Levin said, "the fact that this is being organized shows that the hard, hard right is angling for some kind of activity to show that they have some potency."
Biden defeated Donald Trump on Election Day by a historic margin. But Biden's victory is but one battle in a very long war. To the immense shock and discomfort of many observers, Trump received more than 73 million votes, at least 10 million more in 2016.
Biden and the Democrats won this round, at least at the presidential level. But white supremacy in the form of Trumpism has not been vanquished, and its takeover of the Republican Party and the American conservative movement appears complete. If anything, American fascism and racial authoritarianism are now more powerful than at any time since the formal end of Jim and Jane Crow American apartheid in the 1960s.
For four years, white supremacists held power at the highest levels of the American government. For a movement which was isolated to the periphery of society in the post-civil rights era, that is a remarkable achievement.
The white supremacist policies put in place by the Trump regime impact every area of American life.
- The Republican Party has made Jim Crow tactics and strategies, aimed at preventing Black people and other nonwhites from voting, a cornerstone of its electoral strategy.
- White supremacist ideologues such as senior White House adviser Stephen Miller have implemented policies to restrict immigration from nonwhite countries to levels not seen since the 1920s.
- The Trump regime unleashed ICE, the Border Patrol and other law enforcement agencies (as well as private "militias") in a terror campaign against nonwhite communities.
- Tens of thousands of nonwhite migrants, immigrants and refugees were confined in Trump's concentration camps and other detention centers.
- The people of Puerto Rico — who of course are U.S. citizens — were effectively left to die after Hurricane Maria. Trump obviously viewed that U.S. commonwealth and its Spanish-speaking citizens as less than, other and not quite American.
- Black and brown children were stolen from their families as a "deterrent" to migrants and refugees entering the U.S. More than 600 of those children may never be reunited with their families.
- Civil rights laws and other protections designed to stop racial discrimination and other forms of unfair treatment have been rescinded.
- Police thuggery and brutality has been encouraged, covered up or exonerated.
- Muslims were banned from entering the United States.
- DACA was overturned.
- Trump and the Republicans have loaded the federal courts at every level with judges who oppose the idea that the state should intervene to protect the rights of nonwhite Americans and other marginalized groups.
- Trump has used and continues to use stochastic terrorism to encourage violence by white supremacists and other right-wing extremist groups and individuals against nonwhite people, Muslims, Jews and other groups marked as "the enemy."
- Trump has repeatedly slurred Blacks, Latinos, and other nonwhites as being disease carriers, rapists, murders, thugs, traitors, criminals, not "patriotic" and disloyal.
- Trump has repeatedly demeaned and insulted Black and brown women who dared to criticize him and his policies.
- Trump threatened to unleash the military against Americans who protested against police violence and the murder of George Floyd.
- Trump has effectively declared that teaching accurate and true history in America's schools about the country's origins in slavery and racism is a thought crime. The Trump regime has also terminated federal funding for training sessions about white privilege, racism and the societal value of diversity.
- Trump has enacted policies that have worsened the racial wealth and income gap, as well as making economic inequality more extreme for the country as a whole.
- The Trump regime's sabotage of coronavirus relief efforts was also a function of animus and hostility toward nonwhite people, who have suffered disproportionately from the pandemic and are more likely to live in cities or states governed by Democrats.
During Trump's time as president, white supremacists and the white right more broadly have been able to mainstream the false narrative that nonwhite people are "invading" Western nations, including the U.S., and "replacing" the current population (understood as predominantly white). This is part of a larger pattern where the language of "white nationalism" (verbiage developed by white supremacists to make their hate message more palatable for the public) has also been made more mainstream under the Trump regime.
In all, the Age of Trump has broadened the limits of approved public discourse in the United States. Racist and white supremacist ideas and language that not long ago were considered verboten are now increasingly acceptable.
White supremacy was not defeated in the 2020 election. In many ways, it scored a victory -- perhaps most notably in how the appeal of Trumpism has now spread beyond his core base of white followers.
In a case of political Stockholm syndrome and identifying with one's abuser, initial exit polls show that 26 percent of Donald Trump's voters were non-white. His support also grew among women and the LGBTQ community. Such growing appeal does not make Trumpism less racist and white supremacist or less misogynistic. Rather, what this broadening base of support reveals is that many millions of Americans — of different backgrounds — are attracted to Trumpism's core values of nationalism, militarism, nativism, misogyny, patriarchy, hypermasculinity, right-wing libertarianism, racism and Christian fascism.
As Daniel Martinez HoSang and Joseph E. Lowndes show in their compelling 2019 book "Producers, Parasites, Patriots: Race and the New Right-Wing Politics of Precarity," white supremacy and American neofascism are more than skin deep.
Conservatism and racism have been the same thing in America since at least the 1960s. The Age of Trump has made that even more obvious. In that way, the Age of Trump has been a grand triumph for white supremacy: It has shown the Republican Party's leaders that becoming an explicitly white racist organization is not an impediment to power. Indeed, it may even be a way to achieve and keep power in a country that, by many demographic measures, is becoming more racially diverse.
* * *
While many political observers and members of the press desperately hope otherwise, Trumpism has not shown itself to be a house of sand and mud that will collapse once Donald Trump leaves the White House.
Fascism is not exclusively a European phenomenon, or some other type of "foreign" invention. Fascism's American origins are the racial authoritarianism and violence of Jim and Jane Crow — and now a renewed and updated 21st-century commitment to white minority rule.
Furthermore, Trumpism is but one iteration of American neofascism. There will be others. Whatever its label and form, American neofascism has fully mated with the Republican Party, the right-wing media machine, right-wing Christian fundamentalists, and the agents of plutocracy and gangster capitalism. To wit: it drew at least 73 million people to vote for Donald Trump in the 2020 election.
Donald Trump is more than a man to his followers and cult members. He is a symbol and an idea — ideas cannot be exorcised or otherwise defeated in one electoral cycle. Moreover, the United States is a pathocracy. Sick societies produce sick political movements and leaders.
Many Americans, both experts on race as well as laypeople, have hoped that white racism in its various forms would slowly disappear from American life and politics through a process known as "generational replacement," in which older people die and younger people with more liberal and progressive ideas replace them. Exit polling from the 2020 presidential election complicates that narrative: Young white men apparently supported Donald Trump by about 51% to 45%.
There is a deep yearning among many of America's pundits, political reporters and other public voices on both the left and the right — loyal as they are to the civic religion of American exceptionalism — to throw the Age of Trump down the memory hole. They would like to declare premature victory and pronounce that Trumpism and its devotees are in "disarray" or have been decisively defeated. And of course, there is the naïve and enduring belief that Trump's followers can somehow be reasoned with and then convinced to reject authoritarianism and rejoin democratic society — if only their "pain" and "anger" is heard and acknowledged.
Such feelings and beliefs reflect the desperate yearning and compulsion to return to a pre-Trump state of "normal." That will not be possible without a true reckoning with the Age of Trump, one that goes well beyond stories about personalities and the controversy of the day or week. Such a reckoning will demand that the country's elites, especially its journalists, pundits and other political observers, focus on the force of ideas. American neofascism held power for (at least) four years. It will hold sway over the Republican Party and the American right for many more years, likely decades into the future.
