Download Our App
Staggering number of people could vanish from US census under new Trump rule: report
U.S. President Donald Trump holds a board showing Census Monthly Basic CPS, Author's calculations on 'Monthly Estimates of Net Change in Real Median Household Income (Trump 2nd Term)', as he makes an announcement on the economy, in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., August 7, 2025. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst

Staggering number of people could vanish from US census under new Trump rule: report

A Trump administration plan to overhaul the 2030 census could leave tens of millions of people out of the count, whatever their immigration status, according to a new analysis built on the Census Bureau’s own data.

The report from the Coalition on Human Needs, a group of advocacy organizations and think tanks focused on low-income Americans, found that as many as 38 million people could be left uncounted if the bureau finalizes its proposed rule, reported Talking Points Memo.

The Commerce Department proposed the rule on Sept. 9 that would change how the census decides where a person lives. For decades, the census has counted people where they “live and sleep most of the time,” but under the new plan, a person’s residence would instead have to be “consistent with, and evidenced by, their tax records.”

That’s a problem for the millions of people who don’t file taxes. Citing Census Bureau research, the coalition found that 11.5 percent of the population has no IRS forms at all, and many low-income households aren’t required to file, including some gig workers and self-employed small business owners.

Bureau research also showed that as many as 30 million people had no matching addresses between their IRS records and the 2020 census. Combining the two groups, the coalition estimated the rule could undercount roughly 20 percent of the country.

“Overall, this proposal is so broken, you can’t even tell which 20 percent of the country is going to be left out,” Christopher Kang, the coalition’s executive director, told TPM.

The rule’s main target appears to be noncitizens, and it could remove most of them from the census for the first time in the survey’s history, shifting congressional seats and Electoral College votes away from states with large immigrant populations.

Republicans have long tried to exclude immigrants from the count despite the Constitution’s requirement to tally “the whole number of persons in each State.”

The plan has met fierce resistance, including from inside the administration. TPM previously reported that Treasury Department officials warned Commerce to use tax data only as “corroborating evidence” of where someone lives, but Commerce ignored the advice.

Of the nearly 150,000 public comments submitted on the rule, 88 percent opposed it, according to the data policy coalition Hands Off Our Census.

Experts say tax returns were never designed to show where people live and instead exist so the IRS can reach filers.

“Fundamentally, there would always be an undercount of how many people show up on our tax system,” said Aravind Boddupalli of the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.

The Census Bureau did not respond to TPM’s request for comment.

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?

VOTE NOW
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?