A motion to dismiss filed by the Justice Department asked a judge not to prevent new assault charges in a case related to President Donald Trump's Minnesota immigration crackdown, even though prosecutors admit they cannot find the immigration officer who they say is the victim.
Federal prosecutors filed the motion Tuesday in the case against Abdikadir Noor, a St. Cloud man charged with assaulting an Immigration and Customs Enforcement deportation officer during a Jan. 12 operation in that city, part of the administration’s immigration surge in Minnesota.
“The victim officer has left federal employment, and the United States has been unable to locate him to testify for trial,” prosecutors wrote.
The government “moves that the Court dismiss this case without prejudice,” the filing says, which would let prosecutors refile the charge. It cites “developments” since the charge was filed.
On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Nancy E. Brasel gave Noor until Dec. 1 to respond and canceled his Dec. 7 trial, court records show.
The motion ties the officer’s absence to his departure from ICE, but does not explain why leaving a government job would excuse him from testifying.
Under federal court rules, either side in a criminal case can subpoena a witness to appear at trial anywhere in the United States, and most witnesses have never worked for the government. When a subpoena may not be enough, a federal law lets a judge order a material witness arrested to secure the testimony.
The motion does not say whether prosecutors tried either step. It also does not say when the officer left ICE or why.
Prosecutors also told the judge that they were moving to dismiss the case because the "memories of the other witnesses have faded since the charged offense."
The motion does not identify the witnesses, what they might have forgotten, or why their recollections are more fragile than those in any other case.
Written reports existed within two weeks of the clash. The Jan. 23 affidavit supporting the charge, sworn by Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent Richard Berger, says officers “saw” Noor throw a brick and that Berger drew on “the review of reports.” Federal evidence rules let a witness read such a document to refresh his memory on the stand.
The trial was first set for August. It moved to December on a date both sides agreed to in July, according to a letter from Noor’s attorney, Dane DeKrey.
Prosecutors asked to keep the power to charge Noor again, but they offered no concrete evidence to support the request.
“The United States requests dismissal without prejudice in order to allow potential future prosecution if material evidence should become available,” the filing says.
“A video recording of the charged offense, for instance, would potentially provide proof beyond a reasonable doubt,” it continues. Several spectators were recording nearby that day, the motion says, “but the U.S. to date has not found footage of the precise time and location.”
The motion argues that a video which hasn't been alleged to exist might "potentially provide proof" needed to refile the charges. But the Justice Department admitted to the judge that a 10-month effort "has not found footage of the precise time and location."
The missing officer was also not among the evidence that prosecutors said might turn up.
Noor was one of 16 people federal prosecutors charged in January with violently assaulting federal officers and property. Berger’s affidavit said a thrown brick is a “deadly or dangerous weapon,” which made the charge a felony.
In February, prosecutors replaced it with a misdemeanor charge that does not mention a weapon, court records show. Noor pleaded not guilty. Sahan Journal reported at the time that he was accused of throwing ice after officers pepper-sprayed him.
If Brasel grants the motion, a case prosecutors have now scaled back twice will end without a jury deciding what Noor threw.
“Mr. Noor has decided he no longer wishes to enter into a plea agreement with the government and, instead, wishes to proceed to trial,” DeKrey wrote in that July letter.
Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.
For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?
VOTE NOW




