An FBI report containing a confidential informant's claim that Jeffrey Epstein was an Israeli spy was processed for release despite it being considered a “sensitive” national security matter — and amid uncertainty about whether it was “part of an active investigation,” Raw Story has learned.
The allegation, part of an official written report known as a 302, came from an April 2020 FBI interview with a confidential human source who “expressed concern that Jeffrey Epstein was an Israeli spy.” The informant also raised concerns that Steve Bannon, a prominent ally of President Donald Trump, may have received Israeli money through a business relationship with Epstein, and speculated that Bannon might have used cellphone surveillance technology to extract information from the White House.
The FBI's release of the materials, part of a counterintelligence probe by former Supervisory Special Agent Johnathan Buma that swept up Epstein and his associates, scuttles any future investigation by publicly exposing the matter and tipping off any associates who might have been acting on Israel's behalf.
The informant, named in documents released by the FBI, is Charles C. Johnson, a notorious, right-wing internet troll who had previously worked for Bannon as a reporter at Breitbart News Network. Johnson has extensive ties to Trumpworld, including attending the 2018 State of the Union address as a guest of former Congressman Matt Gaetz, and exchanging Signal messages with JD Vance, the future vice president, following his election to the U.S. Senate in 2022.
Johnson’s view that Epstein was an asset of Israeli intelligence has been echoed by Vance, as recently as July in an interview with podcaster Joe Rogan.
Johnson’s FBI interview surfaced in March 2025, when the bureau scrambled to assemble records from its holdings on the Epstein investigation in response to an order from former Attorney General Pam Bondi to fulfill the mounting demand for disclosure from Trump’s base.
The sweeping review hit closer to home than Trump’s supporters might have expected, landing on one of his closest allies instead of his many perceived enemies in the Democratic Party, national security establishment and so-called “globalist” network of nonprofits.
The report was one of two containing allegations about Epstein and Bannon that the FBI deemed as “sensitive” and that had not been visible in Sentinel, the bureau’s agency-wide automated case management system.
The reports, known as “serials,” were only identified due to a quality-control review conducted by agents in the New York Field Office, according to Darcy Jones, a section chief in the Criminal Investigation Division. In late March 2025, an unnamed official at the Washington Field Office, where the reports were kept, sent them to colleagues in the Criminal Investigation Division and Office of General Counsel late on a Sunday night.
Emails show FBI personnel from the Criminal Investigations and Information Management divisions, along with officials from the New York and Washington field offices, held a conference call on the following Monday morning. Jones wanted to get the documents “rushed as quickly as IMD is able to make it happen.”
At 2:37 p.m. that afternoon, an unidentified Information Management Division employee wrote in the email chain that their chief of staff had “confirmed” with an unnamed official at the Office of the Deputy Attorney General “that these should be processed if they are a serialized part of the file,” specifically mentioning the report containing allegations about Epstein and Bannon’s alleged involvement with Israeli intelligence.
At the time, the Office of the Deputy Attorney General was led by Todd Blanche, who went on to succeed Bondi as attorney general.
But FBI personnel weren’t quite ready to process the reports for review by Blanche’s office.
“We are holding on a determination until we learn whether these files are part of an active investigation,” an unnamed employee at the Information Management Division wrote at 4:01 p.m.
Then, less than 45 minutes later, an unnamed Information Management Division employee reported: “From a classification analysis review of these two serials and their attachments, nothing rises to the level of classification in the serials."
“Please let me know if any further NSCOU action is needed,” the unnamed employee added, referring to the FBI’s National Security Covert Operations Unit.
Michael Seidel, the FBI Record/Information Dissemination Section Chief, responded, “Thanks so much for the quick NSCOU flip. Proceed on the normal course of declass and mark the serials accordingly.”
It remains unclear how the FBI determined that the reports wouldn’t compromise an active investigation and why the national security unit decided the report with allegations about Epstein and Bannon’s potential involvement in Israeli intelligence operations could be declassified. The bureau did not respond to a set of written questions submitted by Raw Story.
The classification markings on the email chain give some indication of why the files were considered “sensitive.” The emails were initially classified as “secret/no forn,” indicating they should not be disseminated to foreign citizens. One of the emails includes a notation “1.4.(C)” as the reason for the secret classification. This appears to reference an executive order signed by President Barack Obama to designate materials whose “unauthorized disclosure could reasonably be expected to cause identifiable or describable damage to the national security” regarding “intelligence activities (including covert action), intelligence sources or methods, or cryptology.”
The Department of Justice did not respond to an inquiry as to why the Office of the Deputy Attorney General directed that the reports be processed for eventual release.
Whatever the reasons for processing the reports about Epstein and Bannon’s alleged intelligence activities on Israel’s behalf for eventual release, the source had been terminated by the FBI in 2021. The FBI agent who authored those reports had been criminally charged by his own agency only a week before officials retrieved them and discussed whether they could be declassified without compromising national security.
Johnathan Buma, a former supervisory special agent, said in a whistleblower statement submitted to the Senate Judiciary Committee that a confidential human source codenamed “Genius” had been reporting to him on the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol and on counterintelligence matters. When he returned from vacation in 2021, Buma reported he learned that FBI management had terminated the source without consulting him. Buma’s whistleblower statement was leaked, and it became the subject of stories by Business Insider and other outlets. In response to the Business Insider story, Johnson published a Substack article identifying himself as the “confidential human source codenamed Genius.”
Buma claimed in the whistleblower statement that FBI management was suppressing investigations and intelligence gathering related to alleged links between former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, then serving as Trump’s personal lawyer, and the Russian Intelligence Service. While he was collecting intelligence on Giuliani, Buma, who was assigned to the Los Angeles Field Office, said one of his managers told him they had received a call from a supervisor in the New York Field Office who had “taken issue with his work.” After that, Buma said, his managers in Los Angeles “started suppressing my reporting in an increasingly aggressive fashion.”
On March 17, 2025, Buma was arrested by the FBI at JFK International Airport while preparing to board a flight to London. He was charged with disclosure of confidential information. Among other things, Buma is accused of printing off FBI files with protected information about confidential human sources and sharing protected information with various individuals helping him negotiate a book deal with a publishing company.
Buma told Raw Story he could neither confirm nor deny that he was Johnson’s handler, noting that he could be prosecuted for disclosing the identity of a confidential human source. He also said he disputes the FBI’s assertion that he exposed a source’s identity, contending that “the relevant disclosure originated elsewhere.”
But speaking as a subject matter expert, Buma said he believes the allegations that Epstein spied for Israel warrant further investigation.
“As a former FBI supervisory special agent who spent years investigating Russian intelligence operations, I consider the allegations that Jeffrey Epstein functioned as an Israeli intelligence asset credible enough to warrant serious investigation,” Buma told Raw Story. “My assessment is based on the convergence of several counterintelligence indicators, not any single allegation.”
Epstein maintained a years-long friendship with former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak. Yoni Koren, an Israeli military intelligence officer, reportedly stayed at Epstein’s Manhattan apartment on at least three occasions between 2013 and 2015. Epstein also reportedly invested $1 million in an Israeli surveillance tech company with the help of Barak.
“Taken together, Epstein’s financial relationships, intelligence-connected associates, access to powerful Americans and involvement in sensitive Russian and Israeli networks provide a reasonable basis to investigate whether he operated as an intelligence facilitator benefiting Israeli interests,” Buma said. “They do not establish that Israel directed his activities or that his crimes were part of an intelligence operation. My conclusion is that the Israeli intelligence hypothesis is credible and deserves rigorous investigation, not that it has been conclusively proven.”
Buma said, in his opinion, allegations about whether Bannon was involved with Israeli intelligence also deserve scrutiny.
“It begs the question, as Bannon has a history of involvement in criminal activity and being pardoned,” Buma said. (Bannon pleaded not guilty to a federal felony fraud charge related to a scheme to raise money for a southern border wall, but received a pardon from Trump. He later pleaded guilty in a state case based on the same conduct.
Bannon could not be reached for comment for this story.
Buma said he finds it ironic that he’s being prosecuted for allegedly disclosing the identities of confidential human sources when the whole purpose of his whistleblower complaint was to expose selective disclosure for political objectives.
“The FBI should release information in accordance with the law and legitimate congressional oversight demands, not selectively disclose intelligence based on its anticipated political consequences,” he said. “Selective disclosure designed to advance political objectives is precisely the kind of weaponization of intelligence that I blew the whistle on.”
Like Buma, his suspected former source, Charles C. Johnson, has faced legal trouble in recent years.
In October 2024, Johnson was sued by a Texas-based investor for allegedly running a fraud and extortion scheme by falsely presenting himself as an intelligence agent and threatening to sabotage companies’ government contracts if they don’t accede to his demands. From November 2025 through February 2026, Johnson was jailed for contempt of court as a result of failing to turn over discovery documents.
Before he brought his concern about Epstein, Bannon and alleged Israeli intelligence operations to the FBI, Johnson had established a reputation as a political operative with a dubious track record for credibility and ethics, while maintaining close relationships with some of the very people he reported to the FBI.
As a right-wing internet provocateur, Johnson published articles baselessly accusing President Barack Obama of being gay, and doxxed the woman at the center of a discredited Rolling Stone story about an alleged rape, along with reporters covering the 2014 protests in Ferguson, Missouri.
In 2017, he argued on Twitter that the Holocaust was a hoax, while accusing the Allies of war crimes for the bombing of German cities during World War II, and reportedly founded a crowd-funding website that was used to raise more than $150,000 for neo-Nazi propagandist Andrew Anglin, who played a significant role in promoting the deadly Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Virginia.
Last year, the federal judge who ultimately ordered Johnson to jail for contempt of court told him, “I don’t believe anything you tell the court. Your word cannot be trusted.”
Johnson has continued to move through MAGA circles in the midst of his many controversies, from writing for Bannon at Breitbart News Network to exchanging Signal messages with future Vice President JD Vance.
Johnson and Bannon helped stage a press conference with Trump and four women who accused President Bill Clinton of sexual assault, according to a Forbes report. Later, according to the report, Johnson worked with billionaire tech investor Peter Thiel to help the presidential transition team vet personnel for the new administration. Then, in 2021, Johnson told Business Insider he recruited Thiel as a confidential human source to the FBI, reporting to Buma.
Johnson could not be reached for comment for this story.
Johnson’s track record of antisemitic and inflammatory internet postings appears to have raised concerns among the higher-ups at the FBI in 2021.
In his 2023 whistleblower statement to the Senate Judiciary Committee, Buma wrote that the decision by his management to terminate his source “Genius” — confirmed by Johnson to be his codename — was “ostensibly because he had previously made inappropriate comments on social media.” But Buma argued that was all part of Johnson’s cover.
“I was aware of and had already reported concerning these postings and knew they had been done in an attempt to garner trust from certain racially motivated violent extremists, which proved to be effective,” Buma wrote. “I had already reported that this informant had previously been branded as a racist, which empowered him to infiltrate various tightly knit, dangerous and violent fringe groups.”
The revelation about the National Security Covert Operations Unit’s role in performing a classification review analysis of the reports on Epstein and Bannon’s alleged involvement in Israeli intelligence operations raises questions about how the FBI unit determines which materials should be declassified, Buma said.
“The relevant questions are whether classification decisions were consistent, whether legitimate national security interests justified withholding particular information, and whether any decisions were influenced by the identities or political relationships of the individuals involved,” Buma told Raw Story.
“What concerns me even more is the potential chilling effect on FBI personnel who encounter politically sensitive intelligence,” Buma continued. “An agent who develops credible information implicating powerful individuals should not have to calculate whether pursuing that information could destroy their career, expose their family to retaliation, or result in criminal prosecution.”