Reeling MAGA abandons 2028 — but plots a terrifying long game
U.S. Vice President JD Vance is reflected in the screen of a reporter's phone as he, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles attend a meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (not pictured) in the Cabinet Room at the White House, in Washington, D.C., U.S., October 20, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque
Opinion

Reeling MAGA abandons 2028 — but plots a terrifying long game

MAGA is dead, having been in a coma since late summer and succumbing a couple of weeks ago. But that doesn't mean we're rid of the far right in the GOP — only Trumpism. And as bad as MAGA got, what remains might grow worse: festering unfed populism.

This isn't yet 2028 talk — we'll all get there soon enough. This is more compass stuff, finding their general direction even as we gauge our own. Thankfully, the Republican direction is clear because its identity, its North Star, was and will remain anger-as-identity. Trump didn't so much demonstrate the GOP's hunger for hate; he taught the GOP that it was okay to gorge itself, to shove it in others' faces, to laugh at suffering. A little racism goes a long way, marginalized people exist to get kicked around, all that. They didn't have to hide.

Check out X sometime if you have questions.

Trump and MAGA became the Republican voter's persona, not belief, and that identity is going nowhere without replacement as relief. A large shift to moderation, even as a predicate to electoral success, would function as an admission they were wrong all along. It won't happen because another of Trump's lessons was to never back down, never admit defeat.

By any measure of reasonableness and, given a choice between winning and losing general elections, the GOP voters will happily remain a minority party over six years, perhaps even a generation, until sorted out. Hopefully. (Thought Democrats must not be complacent; a mandate means nothing if not acted on.)

Trump failed the general public, to be sure, but he sure didn't fail to feed the anger in the reddest of the red, the primary voters who nominated Ken Paxton. So when surveying the political landscape, look out for Trump 2.0: bolder, angrier, less "fun," more fear. Consider someone with Stephen Miller's values, only far better packaged, terrifyingly sweetly-packaged in red, white, and blue, smiling with fanged teeth.

Having learned to hunt for its own needs, the GOP voter will vote more for trophy game than workhorse. It mainlined the power of pre-populism by granting Trump god-like status, but that electorate wants purer stuff now. Then it was about him, now it's about them.

To be sure, they still want iron-fisted rule. They still want a father figure, an abusive one at that, but they want that father working for them rather than hauling Trump around. The Trumpers' first four to five years were "fun": owning the libtards, happily working for Trump. The last six have just been work, working to feed Trump. Now they need the food they've gone largely without.

Toss around some of the candidates floated by the media, just to get a feel. JD Vance — even with the power of the VP office — can't win, forever saddled with Trump's loss. Rubio? Much the same, only worse, riding the war horse. Besides, these are names given to the GOP primary voters. To be sure of ownership, they'll want to pick their own. Think Tucker Carlson more than Ted Cruz. Perhaps Ron DeSantis with marching orders. Remember, the Texas GOP picked Paxton over a perfectly suitable conservative suit. Now picture a Paxton without the baggage.

Please don't worry that the candidate who eventually responds to the GOP's primal scream has a chance of winning in 2028. Even much of the GOP already expects to lose in 2028 and yet say they want a "fighter" in that race. Democrats also want a fighter, but one presumes the word means entirely different things in this context.

What do Republicans even want to fight about, having seen the results of this last election?

That part is easy. There are some Trump-remaining absolutes. Sensible immigration is off the table for good. Any sort of tolerance toward diversity is also a non-starter, further alienation from the "good countries," more China than Japan, more Argentina than Canada, more Russia than Ukraine. The Israelis will soon be on their own, no matter what. But Democrats see it as a responsible rejection of genocide; future Republicans see it as long-overdue anti-Semitism. Think "true America-First" fascist populism.

Populism cannot survive without an internal enemy. Trump taught that lesson all too well, and thus any eventual successor must punish Democrats with greater efficiency.

Yes, there are moderates in the GOP who know that all the above is a formula for losing. They learned their lesson the hard way. Laugh at them. They made their bed, and for a time, few politicians will claim any association with Trump — even the ever-DOGER Musk himself, facing a Texas regulatory state, wants us to know he was never MAGA. But no moderate will rise through the ranks in a post-2028 world.

One of the clearest divides between the two parties in a highly polarized nation is that Republicans will nominate whoever provides them bounty with the assumption he will win (there is no "she" in this context). We progressive Democrats have our demands, knowing that precisely none of them will get passed if we can't put forth someone who can win in November, perhaps the right type of progressive. Moreover, no Democrat will allow their identity to be subsumed by one candidate. The agenda remains first and always.

In a sense, Republicans will knowingly pick the loser of the 2028 presidential election without feeling like losers, having the hard right getting more and more comfortable, the country in ever-increasing danger of post-2030 moderates becoming frustrated with Democrats and with nowhere to turn but to the nice, smiling, presentable, long-knifed alternative. That's the real danger.

On the way out, note that Nick Fuentes didn't even see the blue tsunami as a loss, more the wave taking moderate trash out to sea. Politico quotes him as saying, “It’s our party now. You need to cooperate with us. You don’t have a choice."

For now, Fuentes means "win primaries." For now. Trump's party is dead, MAGA is dead. That's a good thing. But never forget, the country that surely did have moderates surely did elect Trump... twice. We are a nation with a few moderates ready to feel disaffected in a post-2030 world, and will soon look around. Populism stands, powerful, patient, and willing.

Our job is to run the country so well in a post-2028 world that few are willing to ever look back, but to never make that an assumption. The far right is far from dead. Having Trump scratch its more moderate identity, it's never been more powerful.

Jason Miciak is a Rawstory columnist, former editor at Occupy Democrats, an author, attorney, consultant, and single parent girldad. Please follow on Bluesky and he can be reached at jasonmiciak@gmail.com

Report typos and corrections to corrections@rawstory.com.

For customer support contact support@rawstory.com.

Top Stories Recommended For You

YOUR OPINION MATTERS

Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?

VOTE NOW
Should Howard Lutnick be investigated for his ties to the Nvidia scandal?