Quantcast
Connect with us

Beck defends clause counting blacks as three-fifths of a person

Published

on

WASHINGTON — Glenn Beck offered listeners a rather unique version of U.S. Constitutional history on his radio show Tuesday.

In response to a question from an African-American caller, Beck defended the original “Three-Fifth Clause” in the Constitution, which deemed African-Americans to be “three-fifths of all other persons.”

It was a compromise reached between the North and South in the Philadelphia Convention of 1787, and served in many ways as the justification for slavery while it lasted.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I noticed you reference the founding fathers a lot,” said the caller. “And to me it’s kind of offensive because most of those guys were slave-owners. The Constitution that they wrote up — they didn’t even recognize my people as even human.”

“Where’d you learn that, Josh?” Beck soon responded, after asking him to explain his question. The caller said he “learned that in school.”

“Well, you didn’t, really,” Beck retorted, launching into his curious defense of the Constitutional clause the United States later abolished and deemed unequivocally immoral.

“That is the common misconception,” Beck said, recommending that the caller learn the truth by reading “a really good history book not written by progressives.”

“Do you know who wanted slaves to be counted as a full person?” he asked. “Slave owners.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Josh argued with that assertion, but Beck wouldn’t have any of it.

“The reason why they wanted that is because of the balance of power,” Beck explained. “The South could control the numbers in Congress. Their representation would go through the roof.”

“That’s why,” he continued “in the Constitution, African-Americans were deemed three-fifths people, because the Founders wanted to end slavery and they knew if the South could count slaves as full individuals you would never get the control to be able to abolish it.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Beck’s interpretation of the motives of the Founding Fathers for writing the three-fifths clause is highly curious, as it did ultimately serve as a key Constitutional justification for establishing African-Americans an unequal and thus holding them as slaves.

His assertion that Founding Fathers cleverly designed the clause to set the stage for the abolition of slavery is also a dubious version of history.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is not the first time that Beck has made controversial comments about the Constitutionality and justifications for slavery.

The audio was captured by Think Progress:

ADVERTISEMENT


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Latest Headlines

In regional game-changer, US seeks to sell F-35 jets to UAE

Published

on

The United States has agreed to sell more than $10 billion of top-of-the-line F-35 fighter jets to the United Arab Emirates to reward its recognition of Israel, potentially reshaping power dynamics in the turbulent region, Congress was informed Thursday.

In an informal but required notification to Congress, President Donald Trump's administration said it had approved the sale of 50 F-35 Joint Strike Fighters -- equivalent to Israel's fleet of the jets -- worth an estimated $10.4 billion, a congressional aide said.

If it goes ahead, the sale could "significantly change the military balance in the Gulf and affect Israel's military edge," said Representative Eliot Engel, a Democrat who leads the House Foreign Affairs Committee.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

GOP Senator pulls out of final debate after being humiliated onstage the night before

Published

on

On Thursday, Sen. David Perdue (R-GA) withdrew from the third and final debate of his Senate race.

His Democratic opponent, Jon Ossoff, condemned him over the news.

BREAKING: Senator Perdue just cancelled our final debate.

At last night's debate, millions saw that Perdue had no answers when I called him out on his record of blatant corruption, widespread disease, and economic devastation.

Shame on you, Senator.

— Jon Ossoff (@ossoff) October 29, 2020

Continue Reading
 

Latest Headlines

US sells oil seized from Iran to Venezuela for $40 million

Published

on

The United States said Thursday that it had sold Iranian oil seized on its way to Venezuela for more than $40 million.

Washington announced in August that it had confiscated 1.1 million barrels of petroleum from four tankers en route between the two countries, which are both under US sanctions.

"We estimate that in excess of $40 million will be recouped by the United States related to the sale of petroleum from those four vessels," Michael Sherwin, the acting US attorney for the District of Columbia, told reporters by telephone.

He said a "great portion" of it would be contributed to a US fund for victims of "state-sponsored terrorism."

Continue Reading
 
 
Democracy is in peril. Invest in progressive news. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free. LEARN MORE