Quantcast
Connect with us

Prosecutor: Advocating jury nullification ‘not protected by the First Amendment’

Published

on

Advocating for a controversial legal tactic known as jury nullification can get U.S. citizens prosecuted for jury tampering, according to one Manhattan prosecutor who’s pursuing that very charge against a 79-year-old former chemistry professor.

Indicted last year, all Julian P. Heicklen says he was doing is handing out pamphlets from the Fully Informed Jury Association near a courthouse. He wasn’t targeting any specific jury or juror, and his activism has taken him to dozens of courthouses around the country, according to The New York Times.

Manhattan prosecutor Rebecca Mermelstein argued in a recent court filing examined by the paper that because he hoped to “target prospective jurors,” he was tampering with the legal process.

“I’m not telling you to find anybody not guilty,” he allegedly told an undercover officer. “But if there is a law you think is wrong then you should do that.”

Essentially, he’s right: Jury nullification is the right of citizens to nullify the application of laws the feel are unjust. During alcohol prohibition, nearly 60 percent of trials were nullified by jurors. Nullification was often used in cases involving the Alien and Sedition and Fugitive Slave Acts, but it was also common in the South, where it was used to stymie civil rights trials.

ADVERTISEMENT

But far from being a rarely used, forgotten tactic, just last year jurors nullified charges against a Montana man accused of possessing 1/16 of an ounce of marijuana, regardless of any evidence the state presented against him. In an even more recent case, George Washington University law professor John Banzhaf suspected that jury nullification was used to spare former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich during his first public corruption trial, although he was later convicted by a separate jury.

The use of nullification in drug trials is what brought Heicklen to his activism in the first place, he told the Times. In the 90s he smoked marijuana out in public, just so he could get arrested in protest of its prohibition, their report noted. That’s when his true advocacy of jury nullification began, arguing for its use as a means of negating minor drug and gambling charges.

That, too, is not unheard of today: in July 2010, a former Texas police officer who turned against the drug war and became an activist filmmaker was arrested on charges of making a false report to a peace officer, which he earned by attempting to film police committing crimes. He turned himself in to state troopers after a press conference at the Texas capitol, the words “jury nullification” written across his forehead.

ADVERTISEMENT

Unsurprisingly, Heicklen has asked the judge for a jury trial.

The prosecutor, also unsurprisingly, is opposed. Mermelstein wrote that Heicklen would just “urge a jury to [nullify] in a case against him,” which, in her view, is “not protected by the First Amendment.”

With prior reporting by David Edwards.

ADVERTISEMENT

Photo: Flickr user Kaja.A.


Report typos and corrections to [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

2020 Election

The media’s ‘Made in America’ problem: Trump creates racist controversy — and gets free campaign coverage

Published

on

Let’s presume, however depressing that notion may be, that mainstream news organizations will continue to fumble the ball when it comes to directly calling blatantly racist statements coming out of Donald Trump’s mouth what they are, which is racist.

Let’s also presume that in the fallout of such incidents like Trump’s racist tweets on Sunday, media organizations adopt predictable stances. Most struggle to maintain a sense of equanimity and fairness when it comes to calling out Trump’s racism. Fox amplifies it.

Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Gay man’s family cut off his ear after he came out

Published

on

A teen man came out to his parents and in response his dad severely mutilated him, reports Gay Star News.

The 19-year-old was then locked in a closet, where he tried not to bleed to death.

The teen is from The Gambia and is trying to get asylum in The Netherlands.

“I was so afraid to tell my family about my sexuality,” he said.

“I thought, maybe, my family will accept me because I am their family. This is who I am.”

“That was the biggest mistake I ever made.”

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

Longtime Trump loyalist warns the president that his racist tweets are about to permanently stain his image

Published

on

On Tuesday, former Trump administration official Anthony Scaramucci criticized President Trump for telling four freshman congresswomen to go back to their own countries. All four are American citizens.

Scaramucci accused the president of playing to his base, in a way that has dangerous manifestations: for the president and the country.

“He’s blowing very hard on a dog-whistle that every ethnic group that’s landed in the United States has had to hear,” Scaramucci told the BBC.

“I don’t think the president is a racist, but here’s the thing: if you continue to say and act in that manner, then we all have to look at him and say, ‘OK, well, maybe you weren’t a racist, but now you’re turning into one.'”

Continue Reading
 
 
 

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

close-image