Connect with us

Solitary confinement on trial: Senators consider human rights issues in U.S. prisons



The first-ever congressional hearing on the use of solitary confinement in US prisons has begun in Washington.

Members of the Senate judiciary subcommittee on the constitution, civil rights and human rights are hearing testimony from a range of speakers including a former prisoner who spent years locked alone in his cell for a murder he did not commit, a psychology professor who has studied the effects of long-term prison solitude, a senior prison official who has eschewed his support for the tactic, and a former Republican assemblyman who is at the forefront of the conservative movement for prison reform.

The hearing follows a year in which thousands of prisoners across the country took part in coordinated hunger strike in response to California’s extensive use of solitary confinement, and it comes less than one month after an unprecedented class action lawsuit challenged the constitutionality of holding hundreds of men in solitary for a decade or more at the state’s Pelican Bay facility.

Illinois Democrat Dick Durbin, chairman of the committee, issued a statement indicating the hearing will “focus on the human rights, fiscal and public safety consequences of solitary confinement in US prisons, jails and detention centers.”

“During the last several decades, the United States has witnessed an explosion in the use of solitary confinement for federal, state and local prisoners and detainees. The hearing will explore the psychological and psychiatric impact on inmates during and after their imprisonment, fiscal savings associated with reduced use of solitary housing units, the human rights issues surrounding the use of isolation, and successful state reforms in this area,” the statement said.


Prison reform advocates have welcomed the hearing, with supportive statements issued from a range of legal organizations, community groups and representatives of the faith community.

“It’s a tremendously significant development,” said David C Fathi, director of the American Civil Liberties Union national prison project.

While the hearing will cover the state of solitary confinement in the US and is not examining legislation proposals, Fahti said a number of steps can be taken to address the issue. While an estimated 25,000 prisoners are currently held in solitary confinement in the country and another 80,000 believed to be held in so-called restrictive housing, information on the scope of the punishment remains difficult to obtain.


“We just need greater oversight and reporting requirements about prisons and jails’ use of solitary. Right now there are none, and so getting a piece of information as basic as how many prisoners are in solitary on any given day is a very difficult undertaking,” Fahti said.

He added, however: “We already know enough to make some very concrete recommendations. First of all, people with mental illness are highly over-represented in solitary confinement.” He said an inability to manage the stresses, rules and expectations placed upon mentally ill prisoners in solitary confinement often results in their prolonged isolation.

“People with mental illness, if you put them in solitary confinement, most of them will break down quite dramatically,” he said. “More than half the jail suicides in this country occur in solitary confinement.”


Fahti said there should be a prohibition on placing mentally-ill prisoners in solitary confinement. “Same with children,” he added, noting that juveniles who are housed in adult prisons and jails are sensibly separated from the adult population, but as a result are sometimes kept in isolation.

Finally, Fahti added, there need to be “durational limits” on the amount of time prisoners can spend in solitary confinement.

“The US is an outlier, not only in how many people it puts in solitary, but in how long they stay there,” he said. The American Bar Association has recommended that prisoners not be held in solitary confinement for more than one year, while the United Nation’s expert on torture says isolation that lasts more than 15 days can amount to torture.


With just five percent of the global population and a quarter of the planet’s prisoners, Fahti says the United States is without equal in its use of solitary confinement when compared to other democratic nations.

“No other democratic country comes close to the US in its use of solitary confinement, both in terms of the number of people in solitary and the extraordinary lengths of time that many of them stay there,” Fahti said.

The witnesses at Tuesday’s hearing include Harley Lapin, director of the federal bureau of prisons, representatives from the US justice department, and corrections officials from Maryland and Illinois.


They will be joined by Anthony Graves, who in 1982, along with a man named Robert Carter, was convicted of killing a Texas woman, her daughter and her four grandchildren. Moments before his execution in 2000, Carter admitted Graves was not involved in the crime. Graves was eventually exonerated in 2010 after spending 18 years behind bars, the bulk of that time on death row and in solitary confinement.

University of California psychologist Craig Haney, one of the foremost experts on the impact of solitary confinement on the human brain will also address the committee. While testifying before the California assembly’s committee on public safety last year, Haney said that all of the men housed at Pelican Bay – and many more held in similar conditions at other facilities – were routinely treated “worse than prisoners in any civilized nation anywhere else in the world are treated, under conditions that many nations and international human organizations regard as torture.”

Haney said the men he interviewed at Pelican Bay “complain of chronic and overwhelming feelings of sadness, hopelessness and depression” adding that they were “paying a terrible price as pawns in this failed experiment”.


Mississippi’s commissioner of corrections, Christopher B Epps, has also been called to testify. In 2007, Epps was responsible for the state’s super-maximum security prison, a facility that was rapidly descending into chaos, where prisoners held alone for 23 hours a day in insect-infested cells – the walls smeared with excrement – listened to mentally ill men scream through the night. Tensions increased, leading to stabbings, murders and suicides.

Rather than crack down, prison officials relaxed the harsh conditions, allowing the men recreation, privileges and human contact. The number of prisoners held in isolation fell dramatically. Since that time Mississippi has become symbol of potential in solitary confinement reform. The perceived success in the state prompted Colorado, Illinois, Maine, Ohio and Washington state to begin the process of reducing the number of inmates held in long-term isolation. Epps, who once believed in locking men down as tightly as possible, now advocates for more humanitarian alternatives.

Former Republican leader of the California state assembly and current vice-president of Prison Fellowship, Pat Nolan, another witness in the hearing, has argued for reducing prison spending by cutting the “astronomical growth” in the prison population, which is expanding 13 times faster than the general population and cost taxpayers $68b in 2010.


“Solitary confinement is actually the most expensive form of incarceration, costing up to three times much as general prison population housing. Indeed, Mississippi has reportedly saved $5m by closing its super-max unit, and Colorado will save $4.5m as a result of its pending supermax closure,” Nolan wrote in recent letter he co-authored with the reverend Richard Kilmer, executive director of the National Religious Campaign Against Torture.

Alexis Agathocleous, an attorney with the Center for Constitutional Rights, one of the organizations involved in filing the class action lawsuit targeting Pelican Bay, supports the witnesses’ diverse relationships to the punishment.

“They come from a broad range of perspectives, and I think that what it will serve to illustrate is the range of concerns that the overuse of solitary confinement raises,” he said.


“We know that keeping someone in solitary confinement puts them at very serious risk of descending into irreversible mental illness,” he said. “That’s not tolerable in a society that values the dignity and humanity of all people, no matter whether they are incarcerated or not.”

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media 2012

[Solitary confinement via Fer Gregory / Shutterstock]

Report typos and corrections to: [email protected]om. Send news tips to: [email protected].
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

When radioactive wastes aren’t radioactive wastes



The U.S. Department of Energy wants to redefine what constitutes high-level radioactive waste, cutting corners on the disposal of some of the most dangerous and long-lasting waste byproduct on earth—reprocessed spent fuel from the nuclear defense program.

The agency announced in October 2018 plans for its reinterpretation of high-level radioactive waste (HLW), as defined in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act (NWPA) of 1982, with plans to classify waste by its hazard level and not its origin. By using the idea of a reinterpretation of a definition, the DOE may be able to circumvent Congressional oversight. And in its regulatory filing, the DOE, citing the NWPA and Atomic Energy Act of 1954, said it has the authority to “interpret” what materials are classified as high-level waste based on their radiological characteristics. That is not quite true, as Congress specifically defined high-level radioactive waste in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act, and any reinterpretation of that definition should trigger a Congressional response.

Continue Reading


Wendy Davis announces bid for Congress, will challenge US Rep. Chip Roy



The former state senator is running for office for the first time since her unsuccessful campaign for Texas governor.

Former Texas state Sen. Wendy Davis is running for Congress.

Early Monday morning, Davis announced her candidacy for the Democratic nomination in Central Texas' 21st District. She is challenging U.S. Rep. Chip Roy, a freshman Republican from Austin.

She made her intentions known in a biographical video, narrated in part with archival footage from her late father, Jerry Russell.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

How Julian Assange turned his London refuge into an election meddling command post



What We Read last Week: Our Investigative News RoundupWikiLeaks Founder Met Russian Agents in the Ecuadorian Embassy

Surveillance reports obtained by CNN reveal that WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange received in-person deliveries, potentially of hacked materials related to the 2016 US election, during a series of suspicious meetings at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London. The reports also describe how Assange turned the embassy into a command center and orchestrated a series of damaging disclosures that rocked the 2016 presidential campaign in the United States. Despite being confined to the embassy while seeking safe passage to Ecuador, Assange met with Russians and world-class hackers at critical moments, frequently for hours at a time. He also acquired powerful new computing and network hardware to facilitate data transfers just weeks before WikiLeaks received hacked materials from Russian operatives. These stunning details come from hundreds of reports compiled for the Ecuadorian government by UC Global, a private Spanish security company. They chronicle Assange's movements and provide an unprecedented window into his life at the embassy. They also add a new dimension to the Mueller report, which cataloged how WikiLeaks helped the Russians undermine the U.S. election.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2019 Raw Story Media, Inc. PO Box 21050, Washington, D.C. 20009 | Masthead | Privacy Policy | For corrections or concerns, please email [email protected]

Join Me. Try Raw Story Investigates for $1. Invest in Journalism. Escape Ads.