Delaware’s top court on Tuesday struck down the state’s death penalty statute, arguing that it grants judges powers that juries should wield and that it is unconstitutional.
The 3-2 Delaware Supreme Court decision came in the case of Benjamin Rauf, who was charged with first-degree murder and robbery and being in possession of a firearm during the crimes. Prosecutors have been seeking the death penalty against Rauf.
The judges determined that since the state’s death penalty law allows a judge to sentence a convict to death independent of a jury and also allows a jury to hand down a death sentence without a unanimous verdict, it violated the U.S. Constitution.
“Put simply, the Sixth Amendment right to a jury includes a right not to be executed unless a jury concludes unanimously that it has no reasonable doubt that is the appropriate sentence,” the 92-page ruling said.
“Throughout our history, capital sentencing has been a ‘responsibility traditionally left to juries,’ and the decision of whether a ‘fellow citizen should live or die’ has been considered a responsibility too great for any one person to make alone,” the ruling said.
Delaware Governor Jack Markell, a Democrat, applauded the ruling.
“The use of capital punishment is an instrument of imperfect justice that doesn’t make us any safer,” Markell said in a statement. “It is my hope that today’s decision will mean that we never see another death sentence in our state.”
Delaware Department of Justice spokeswoman Nicole Byers said the office was reviewing the decision.
Rauf’s attorney, Santino Ceccotti, said he was “elated” with the ruling.
“We’re still going through the decision, it’s a lengthy one, but we’re very happy with the court’s decision,” he said.
Ceccotti added that the ruling would require all capital offense cases currently pending statewide to be prosecuted again with non-capital charges, though it was not immediately clear if the court’s ruling would be retroactive.
The decision said it would fall to the state’s General Assembly to decide whether to craft a new death penalty statute that does not violate the U.S. Constitution.
The ruling noted that the U.S. Supreme Court made a similar determination when it struck down Florida’s death penalty statute in January, arguing that a jury, not a judge, was required to impose a death sentence.
(Reporting by Curtis Skinner in San Francisco; Editing by David Gregorio, Toni Reinhold)
ABC News had the goods on Jeffrey Epstein years ago — and killed the story
Multimillionaire predator Jeffrey Epstein died in suspicious circumstances at a Manhattan correctional facility on Aug. 10. The wealthy and powerful New York financier, a convicted sex offender, stands accused by dozens of women and girls of trafficking, rape and sexual abuse. He was an enormously influential and well-connected man who counted as friends billionaire business owners, Hollywood stars, British royals, and even top media figures like Katie Couric and Charlie Rose — with some of his associates falling under suspicion of condoning or even participating in a pedophile ring.
Child killed as quake strikes southern Philippines
A powerful earthquake hit the southern Philippine island of Mindanao on Sunday, killing a child, injuring dozens and damaging buildings in an area still recovering from a string of deadly quakes in October.
Police said a rescue operation had been launched at a heavily damaged market building in Padada near the 6.8 magnitude quake's epicentre, which is about 90 kilometres (55 miles) south of the major city of Davao.
Patients were evacuated from hospitals as a precaution and nervous crowds massed outside shopping malls after the jolt and dozens of smaller, but strong aftershocks.
50 bodies unearthed from Mexican mass grave
The bodies of at least 50 people have been unearthed from a mass grave at a farm outside Mexico's western city of Guadalajara, local authorities said.
The grim site was discovered just over three weeks ago in Jalisco -- a state hard-hit by violence linked to organized crime.
The local prosecutor's office said Saturday 13 of the dead -- 12 men and a woman -- have been identified and the remains given to their families.
The process of identifying more of the victims and how they died will continue, it added.
A mass grave with 34 bodies was discovered in a suburb of Guadalajara on September 3, while another was found nearby in May with the remains of 30 people.