Quantcast
Connect with us

Here’s how the Trump administration is bringing back child labor

Published

on

Continuing on its mission to deregulate worker protections, the Trump administration’s Wage and Hour Division of the Department of Labor has proposed a new rule that would allow 16- and 17-year-old nursing-home workers to operate power-driven patient lifting devices without any adult supervision or assistance, despite evidence that it is dangerous. These devices are used to lift and transfer patients out of their beds or a chair who cannot lift themselves.

ADVERTISEMENT

Huh? You ask. Didn’t we settle the issue of child labor like a century ago? Don’t we have a government agency that researches the hazards of this kind of work?

Background

The Wage and Hour Division of the Department of Labor — and not the Occupational Safety and Health Administration — is the agency tasked with determining what kind of work children can perform safely, under the child labor provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act. The main rule is that if you are not yet 18, you are prohibited from being employed in occupations that have been declared hazardous by the Secretary of Labor. That seems pretty clear, until you ask what the Secretary of Labor considers to be “hazardous.” For example, is the use of power-driven hoists to lift and transfer patients in hospitals or nursing homes hazardous?

Good question. Wage and Hour didn’t have the expertise to decide, so when this issue first came up during the Obama administration, they went to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health for some help. And what did NIOSH say? According to Deborah Berkowitz at the National Employment Law Project:

Based on a review of the relevant scientific literature regarding evaluations of patient handling devices and biomechanical analyses, NIOSH has determined that many 16- and 17-year-old employees cannot safely operate power-driven hoists to lift and transfer patients by themselves . . . Independent use of power-driven hoists by 16- and 17-year-olds would put them at increased risk for serious musculoskeletal injuries.  Moreover, the scientific literature indicates that most 16- and 17-year-old workers do not have the ability to properly assess the risks associated with using power-driven lifts.

OK, that sounds pretty clear. Which is why the Obama administration adopted, a common-sense enforcement policy mandating that if a 16- or 17-year-old caregiver is going to use a mechanical lift, he or she must have completed 75 hours of nurse’s aide training and must be assisted by an experienced caregiver who is at least 18 years old.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Current Proposal

Despite the NIOSH recommendation and the current policy that seems to be working pretty well, the Labor Dept. has now proposed to rescind this enforcement policy, allegedly in order to expand apprenticeships for young workers.

With over 1.1 million jobs currently open in healthcare and social assistance, the U.S. Department of Labor today announced a proposal to allow younger Americans to safely develop critical skills for fast-growing jobs in healthcare.

New regulations need to be justified with hard evidence. Weakening those regulations also need hard evidence. Wage and Hour must consider all comments and evidence submitted before it issues the final rule. The agency is accepting comments on the proposal until Monday, Nov. 26. If you’re interested, you can submit comments here: www.regulations.gov/comment?D=WHD-2018-0002-0001.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why are they deregulating and weakening these protections?

A bipartisan group of lawmakers and the regulated community have criticized the 2010 regulation on the grounds that it unnecessarily deprives youth of valuable skills development opportunities; exacerbates staffing shortages at healthcare facilities; delays the care patients receive; and causes youth to manually lift patients – even though using patient lifts is widely recognized as safer.

ADVERTISEMENT

In other words, the Labor Dept. is bowing to industry pressure for cheap and compliant labor.

Many in Congress aren’t pleased. A group of 47 House Democrats sent a letter to Sec. of Labor Alex Acosta last August “to express their concerns that DOL’s efforts to weaken hazardous work protections for minors could put the health and safety of young workers at risk” and asked that the department first request a NIOSH review of the proposed changes.

Weakening protections for young workers could reverse the progress of lowering fatalities among young workers and further jeopardize their health and safety. Workplace safety laws and the Department’s [Hazardous Occupation Orders (HOs)] have made a difference in saving lives and limbs of young workers. The number of young workers aged 15 to 17 killed on the job has declined over the past 18 years….While we believe in expanding job opportunities for young workers, I am sure you would agree this should not be done at the expense of their health, safety or lives.

ADVERTISEMENT

Patient Lifting: Health Worker Hazard

Healthcare workers often experience musculoskeletal disorders at a rate exceeding that of workers in construction, mining, and manufacturing. These injuries are due in large part to repeated manual patient handling activities, often involving heavy manual lifting associated with transferring, and repositioning patients and working in extremely awkward postures. The problem of lifting patients is compounded by the increasing weight of patients to be lifted due to the obesity epidemic in the United States and the rapidly increasing number of older people who require assistance with the activities of daily living.

And on Sept. 25, Reps. Bobby Scott (D-Va.), Rosa DeLauro (D-Conn.), Mark Takano (D-Calif.), and Lucille Roybal-Allard (D-Calif.) called on Acosta to rescind the proposal:

There are many ways to expand job opportunities for young people without risking their safety and the safety of patients in hospitals and nursing homes across the country. The administration should follow the scientific evidence and withdraw this proposal.

Patient advocates aren’t very happy either. A group composed of the California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform, Center for Medicare Advocacy, Long Term Care Community Coalition, National Consumer Voice for Quality Long-Term Care and Penelope Ann Shaw a nursing home resident stated that

ADVERTISEMENT

Revoking the 2011 DOL Field Memo that prohibits 16- and 17-year-old nursing home assistants from operating patient lifts by themselves would recklessly ignore research and experience and turn over one of the most complicated and hazardous jobs in nursing homes to the least experienced workers. The most vulnerable and dependent patients in the health care system would be at increased risk of injuries that can cause pain, broken bones, medical complications, increased disablement, hospitalization, and frequently, death.


Report typos and corrections to: [email protected].
READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION
Continue Reading

Breaking Banner

Can it happen here? Bill Moyers says it’s happening right before our very eyes

Published

on

At 98, historian Bernard Weisberger has seen it all. Born in 1922, he grew up watching newsreels of Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler as they rose to power in Europe. He vividly remembers Mussolini posturing to crowds from his balcony in Rome, chin outthrust, right arm extended. Nor has he forgotten Der Fuehrer’s raspy voice on radio, interrupted by cheers of “Heil Hitler,” full of menace even without pictures.

Fascist bullies and threats anger Bernie, and when America went to war to confront them, he interrupted his study of history to help make history by joining the army. He yearned to be an aviator but his eyesight was too poor. So he took a special course in Japanese at Columbia University and was sent as a translator to the China-Burma-India theater where Japanese warlords were out to conquer Asia. Bernie remembers them, too.

Continue Reading

2020 Election

Republicans fear Trump’s boast the economy is roaring back will blow up in his face before the election: report

Published

on

Republican campaign consultants and advisers are hoping Donald Trump will tone down his boasting that the economy will quickly come roaring back as businesses begin re-opening due to COVID-19 concerns.

With the White House preparing a "recovery summer" roll-out that will tout the economic recovery as a way to reverse the president's collapsing poll numbers, some GOP officials worry Trump's words could come back to haunt him in November.

Continue Reading
 

Breaking Banner

‘Bye Felicia’: Sheriff says Buffalo cops resigning from emergency unit should be booted from the force

Published

on

On MSNBC Saturday, Philadelphia County Sheriff Rochelle Bilal laid into the Buffalo police officers who resigned from the emergency unit, allegedly to protest the disciplinary action against two cops who shoved an elderly man to the ground.

"As far as those officers resigning out of protest, I would say to that, Bye Felicia, because they should go," said Bilal. "Because if they didn't see anything wrong with that, then they shouldn't have been on the force from the beginning. We are not run by a Gestapo type of community. This has been going on for decades. So at this point now, we should be fighting for those who want to be on this job to treat people fairly and for those who don't, say bye. Get them out of here, those of us who want to do this job right want them gone anyway."

Continue Reading
 
 
You need honest news coverage. Help us deliver it. Join Raw Story Investigates for $1. Go ad-free.
close-image