A federal appeals court said on Monday a Virginia politician violated the Constitution by temporarily blocking a critic from her Facebook page, a decision that could affect President Donald Trump’s appeal from a similar ruling in New York.
In a 3-0 decision, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Phyllis Randall, chair of the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors, violated the First Amendment free speech rights of Brian Davison by banning him for 12 hours from her “Chair Phyllis J. Randall” page.
The ban came after Davison had attended a Feb. 3, 2016 town hall meeting, and then under his Facebook profile “Virginia SGP” accused school board members and their relatives of corruption and conflicts of interest. Randall had also removed her original post and all comments, including Davison’s.
Circuit Judge James Wynn rejected Randall’s argument that her Facebook page was a private website, concluding that the “interactive component” was a public forum and that she engaged in illegal viewpoint discrimination.
Davison’s speech “occupies the core of the protection afforded by the First Amendment,” Wynn wrote for the Richmond, Virginia-based appeals court.
The decision upheld a July 2017 ruling by U.S. District Judge James Cacheris in Alexandria.
A lawyer for Randall did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, which represented Davison, had no immediate comment.
Lower courts have disagreed over whether government officials’ social media pages are public forums.
Davison’s case was the first of its kind at the federal appellate level, and other courts could cite it as precedent.
In one case, Trump has asked the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan to overturn a May 23 ruling by U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald that he could not block Twitter critics from his @RealDonaldTrump account.
The Department of Justice, which represents Trump, has called Buchwald’s decision “fundamentally misconceived.”
It has said the president controls the Twitter account in his personal capacity, uses it to disseminate his views rather than to offer a platform for public discussion, and is not required under the First Amendment to receive messages he does not want to hear.
Trump set up the account in 2009 and has more than 57 million followers. Oral argument on his appeal has not been scheduled.
The case is Davison v Randall, 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Nos. 17-2002, 17-2003.
Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Frances Kerry
Trump lies to the press about his massive tax increasing while departing to France for the G7 Summit
President Donald Trump was caught repeating inaccurate claims when he spoke to reporters before boarding Marine One for his trip to France for the G7 Summit.
"I think our tariffs are very good for us. We're taking in tens of billions of dollars, China is paying for it," Trump argued.
In reality, China is not paying for the tariffs, which are paid by American importers and passed on to consumers, making the announcement a massive tax increase on Americans.
"Our tariffs are working out very well for us, people don't understand that yet," Trump argued.
Bill Maher presents ’25 things you don’t know about Stephen Miller’ on Real Time
The host of HBO's "Real Time" presented "25 things you don’t know about Stephen Miller" on Friday.
"In high school, I was voted 'Most Likely to Comb My Mummified Mother's Hair,'" was one item.
"I think tacos are stealing jobs from hamburgers," was another.
"I'm a Cancer. I don't know my astrological sign," was a third.
"The worst part about my car smelling like wet dogs, is that I don't own dogs," was a fourth.
Bill Maher dances on David Koch’s grave: ‘I’m glad he’s dead and I hope the end was painful’
HBO "Real Time" host Bill Maher celebrated the death of right-wing billionaire David Koch, who died of prostate cancer.
"I guess I'm going to have to reevaluate my low opinion of prostate cancer," Maher said.
"Condolences poured in from all the politicians he owned and mourners are being asked, in lieu of flowers, to just leave their car engine running," he said.
"I know these seem like harsh words and harsh jokes, and I'm sure I will be condemned for them on Fox News, which will portray Mr. Koch as a principled libertarian who believed in the free market," Maher said. "He and his brother have done more than anybody to fund climate science deniers -- for decades."